Eminence Domain: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
When a city and its metropolitan areas are designed and settled, the purposes for which an area is used are taken into consideration. This subject is examined by Sociologist Ernest Burgess in "The Growth of the City," in which he examines Chicago and vicinity. In addition, Bruce Epperson (2007), the author of “Eminence Domain: Reassessing the Life and Public Works of Robert Moses” examines the way in which Robert Moses geared his projects for New York City and the surrounding area (p.1). However, one may find that the way in which Moses plans projects for New York City may connect to the way in which Chicago was planned.
Before the formation of suburbs, the majority of Americans tended to live in cities as they were able to live a short commuting
…show more content…
One way in which Burgess’s study shares ideas with the way in which Robert Moses’s planning is that they both took class into account. For example, Burgess (1967) mentions that there are areas of Chicago where there are poorer workers living closer to the city (p.94). Bruce Epperson (2007) states: “On the other hand, it was beset by problems, many of which the exhibit touches on only lightly. Just 15 percent of those displaced by the slum clearance program were relocated in the Title I or Title III units intended to replace the lost housing. Moses initially favored consortiums of small private developers, who often failed miserably, and it was the big players, such as William Zeckendorf and Herbert Greenwald, who eventually pulled the program out of trouble. Title I was not primarily a housing program; it was for slum clearance, and it was often used to clear land for university buildings and cultural amenities for the wealthy. The program was not race neutral. Although the extent of Moses 's racial feelings was the subject of considerable debate at the symposium, it is clear that he did not strongly object as the NYCHA and his private developers systematically denied applications from single-parent households and the dependent poor, and that he embraced a "separate but equal" doctrine by using two middle-class Harlem projects, Lenox Terrace and Delano Village, to meet federal fair-housing requirements (p.822). With this statement, it is clear that Moses took account for separating the wealthy classes from less wealthier

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Hans Speier, Historical Development Of Public Opinion, (Chicago, 1950), 386. [ 7 ]. Hans Speier, Historical Development Of Public Opinion, (Chicago, 1950), 386. [ 8 ]. Mike Sharp, Ian Westwell, John Westwood, History Of World War I, War And Response 1914-1916, (New York, 2002), 65.…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Herbert Hoover criticized Roosevelt’s New Deal because it harmed the liberty of the nation and he proposed to endow the business with more freedom. However, capitalism had its own disadvantages and it could not always run well. Therefore, moderate intervention of the government was necessary. Minnie Hardin admitted that the original intention of the policies on relief was good, but the policies did not work well when implemented. The reliefers took the relief for granted and wasted the taxpayers’ money.…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For example, Kennedy’s personality did not aid in congress’ belief in his reform programs because they did not pass, but it did help with the nation’s perceptions of him because of how genuine he was. President Johnson, on the other hand, used his hard edge to…

    • 1241 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Raisin in the Sun and Segregation in Chicago In today’s century, especially in places like Chicago, relations between Caucasians and African-Americans are not always equivalent. There are differences between some of the major aspects in life, including segregated neighborhoods, poverty, the workforce, and income. It is believed that racial prejudice has improved since the Civil Rights Movement in 1950. It has been proven by facts from poverty and income percentages that the segregation is still present. In A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry, which takes place in the 1950’s, the Younger family struggles with money issues and racial prejudice.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Corporate Nomadism

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages

    His, essay lacks enough information and statistics to prove stronger than Kotkin’s essay because of his personal story. Lovenheim’s approach in his article appears sympathetic in order to reach the reader, “A family had vanished, yet the impact on our neighborhood was slight. How could that be? Did I live in a community or just in a house on a street surrounded by people whose lives were entirely separate?” (459). Although, he might not have plenty of information in his work, there are some trends that can support Lovenheim’s contention that people do not know their neighbors as they used to.…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Are the State Lottery’s Helping Education, or Hurting the Poor? In Gloria Jimenez’s essay Against the Odds, and against the Common Good, Jimenez states that “…most of the tickets are bought by people who don’t have much money, people who are near the bottom of the economic scale.” (Jimenez, Against the Odds…). This statement may seem like a stereotype to the lower-class of the United States, however, is there any merit behind such a claim? The answer is simple, yes! According to Journalistsresource.org, they presented a claim from 2010 by the Journal of Community Psychology stating that “…lottery outlets are often clustered in neighborhoods with large numbers of minorities, who are at greatest risk for developing gambling addictions.” (Journalists Resources).…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    What remedies could be applied to address the housing problems? 1.4. Research objectives 1.4.1. Main Objective The main objective of this study is to evaluate the impact, on household welfare, of living in a rented house; so as to contribute to the understanding on the Household welfare Impact of rented House on Urban Households: A case of Woreda 08, yeka sub-city, Addis Ababa. 1.4.2.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Zhang et al. these areas were selected to reflect the diversity in US cities such as size of population, spatial extent of cities, and land use planning. Data for the study were from household travel surveys, land use data, Traffic Analysis Zones (TAZ), and census tracts. These data were used to measure residential density, employment density, entropy (which indicates the level of mixed land developments), average block size, and distance from city…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first data of interest is on the socio-economic standards of southern and northern suburbs of Illinois pertinent to teacher evaluation. The other primary source of data is by the ISBE. The education regulatory body acts as the custodian of data on teacher evaluation. It further provides leadership and resources to facilitate improved education performance across Illinois. The researcher relies on the…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One market entrepreneur, Cornelius Vanderbilt, defeated all the others, Fulton, Collins and Cunard. Meanwhile, Folsom begins to explain how market entrepreneurs should not be labeled as robber barons. Folsom felt that the market entrepreneurs stayed behind the growth of America. They made sound products and didn’t take aid from the Government where political entrepreneurs did collect aid from the Government. market entrepreneurs were known for being risk-takers and also very humanitarian individuals, caring for others well-being.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays