Eminence Domain: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
When a city and its metropolitan areas are designed and settled, the purposes for which an area is used are taken into consideration. This subject is examined by Sociologist Ernest Burgess in "The Growth of the City," in which he examines Chicago and vicinity. In addition, Bruce Epperson (2007), the author of “Eminence Domain: Reassessing the Life and Public Works of Robert Moses” examines the way in which Robert Moses geared his projects for New York City and the surrounding area (p.1). However, one may find that the way in which Moses plans projects for New York City may connect to the way in which Chicago was planned.
Before the formation of suburbs, the majority of Americans tended to live in cities as they were able to live a short commuting
…show more content…
One way in which Burgess’s study shares ideas with the way in which Robert Moses’s planning is that they both took class into account. For example, Burgess (1967) mentions that there are areas of Chicago where there are poorer workers living closer to the city (p.94). Bruce Epperson (2007) states: “On the other hand, it was beset by problems, many of which the exhibit touches on only lightly. Just 15 percent of those displaced by the slum clearance program were relocated in the Title I or Title III units intended to replace the lost housing. Moses initially favored consortiums of small private developers, who often failed miserably, and it was the big players, such as William Zeckendorf and Herbert Greenwald, who eventually pulled the program out of trouble. Title I was not primarily a housing program; it was for slum clearance, and it was often used to clear land for university buildings and cultural amenities for the wealthy. The program was not race neutral. Although the extent of Moses 's racial feelings was the subject of considerable debate at the symposium, it is clear that he did not strongly object as the NYCHA and his private developers systematically denied applications from single-parent households and the dependent poor, and that he embraced a "separate but equal" doctrine by using two middle-class Harlem projects, Lenox Terrace and Delano Village, to meet federal fair-housing requirements (p.822). With this statement, it is clear that Moses took account for separating the wealthy classes from less wealthier

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Skill: Infer and Support the Main Idea PILSEN 7th Grade Nonfiction Center for Urban Education ©2007 Pilsen is an old community in Chicago with a long history. This part of Chicago started small and got bigger, as most neighborhoods in the city did.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Rhetorical Analysis on “Suburb or Nothing” in the Memphis Flyer What should the relationship be between the suburbs and the city? The very small editorial in the Memphis Flyer gives somewhat efficient details on the term “Suburb of Nothing” originated and quoted by Mayor Mick Cornett. The writer of the article in the Commercial Appeal’s, “Suburb of Nothing”, effectively argues his/her point via the use of organization, formal tone and appeals to authority. Doing so, the writer gives history, use of words like “Summons” (in quotation in his/her own words) to illustrate a dire need of attention, and uses statistics and citations when appealing to authority such as a political magazine.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Harland Bartholomew is one of the original municipal planners that influenced the city planning profession from 1914 to present day. Bartholomew’s influence and notability in city planning has three distinct areas (Lovelace, 1993). These three areas include the education of planning professionals, civil service at both the city and national level, and his private practice and advancement of a systematic comprehensive plan (Lovelace, 1993). These three areas tell a story of an individual that had a profound impact on the city planning profession beginning from the start of his planning career in 1912 and still continues today (Lovelace, 1993). Harland Bartholomew was born in 1889 near Boston, Massachusetts and moved to Brooklyn, New York (Lovelace,…

    • 1330 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the great country of the United States, most citizens of this society see what they want to see but never the reality of the criminal justice system. Bryan Stevenson’s book, “Just Mercy”, is his own perspective of what it is really like being a lawyer for wrongly convicted people in hopes of reform in the criminal justice system. After the shooting of Trayvon Martin by George Zimmerman in 2012, many citizens countrywide was outraged at the fact that Zimmerman was not imprisoned for murdering an innocent seventeen year old. This sparked the hashtag #BlackLivesMatter movement. This movement alone brought attention to the inequality and violence against African-Americans internationally.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Los Angeles has the reputation of having the worst traffic in the world, and of course, everyone would spend more time tapping brakes on freeways if it was Thanksgiving. The picture of the jammed 405 Freeway depicts the Thanksgiving rush in Los Angeles well, and people make fun by saying that the freeway 405 has the name because “it takes you '4 o' 5' hours to get anywhere.” () Driving on Freeway 405 is infuriating not only because drivers have to drive slowly, but also because when everyone wanted to get back home as soon as possible, some people would change lanes, and lead to car accidents. In addition, since families want everyone to be back home around dinner time, they can get mad at a member who arrives late and claims that he or she could leave from work earlier. Yes, having to drive slowly is annoying, but what really touches people’s nerves is that people act upon their interests without trying to understand each other.…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The three articles provided, “Do Artifacts Have Politics” by Langdon Winner, “The Engineer as Social Radical” by J.C. Mathes and Donald H. Gray, and “Slums and City Planning” by Robert Moses, had several different parts that stood out to me as interesting. Each article had their own main focuses, Winner speaking about how objects and technologies in society having politics, Mathes and Gray about engineers being radicals or conservatives and technologies advancing in our society, and Robert Moses spoke about slums and how he would work towards the removal of slums in New York City. In “Do Artifacts Have Politics” by Langdon Winner first opens up his piece by speaking about how it is controversial to say that objects have political qualities.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Western Migration After the Civil War, people migrated west giving up all that they had for many different reasons, and to do many different things; one reason in particular was to gain a better life. The Civil War caused economic problems in the south, for this reason people migrated west to gain economically. Moving west meant better job opportunities, land ownership, and agriculture. Different groups of people picked up and moved west and in doing so, they encountered major barriers. These groups of people included African- Americans, Mexicans, and Native American to name a few with the hopes to become landowners.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Black On The Block Summary

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Jacklin Jones Urban Society Book Report Fall ‘15 Black on the Block: The Politics of Race and Class in the City History is always changing and repeating itself. According to the Housing Act of 1954, it changed urban “redevelopment” into urban “renewal” and “conservation”. Therefore, this had shifted the focus to areas that is threatened by diseases and enlarged the constructions of the federal government to support beyond residential (Pattillo, 310).…

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Urbanization In The 1800's

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Urbanization, by definition, is the movement from rural areas to urban areas and the ways society adapts to this change. In the late 1800’s, this is exactly what happened, with rural living people moving to urban areas. This movement not only caused more people in the urban areas, but a huge influx of people,mainly immigrants, into the cities. Due to that, many discrepancies were made in how society worked in the time, which led to people having to adapt into the new way of life that they were offered.…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chavez Ravine Essay

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Federal Housing Act of 1949 “granted money to cities from the federal government to build public housing projects,” and Los Angeles Mayor, Fletcher Bowron, “voted and approved a housing project containing 10,000 new units—thousands of which would be located in Chavez Ravine” (PBS, 2017). Chavez Ravine was seen as a “vacant shantytown” and an “eyesore” by outsiders, and the 300-plus acres were “reserved by the Los Angeles city of Housing as a prime location for re-development’ (PBS, 2017). Frank Wilkinson, the assistant director of the Los Angeles City Housing Authority, was one of the main supporters behind Elysian Park Heights. In 1952, Wilkinson “faced questioning by the House Un-American Activities Committee…was fired from his job and sentenced to one year in jail” (PBS, 2017). Bowron and Wilkinson had an effect on Chavez Ravine because their actions made way for the tear down of the small town.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The displacement of BME and low-income groups leads to the issues of environmental gentrification. If city planners are working to increase green infrastructure within an impoverished community, will they find success in creating a healthier, “greener” space or in a wealthier, “whiter” space? Although plans for city green space include sustainable initiatives, they oftentimes lack the advocacy for environmental justice. This inadequacy depicts the concepts of sustainability and going green with a political intent rather than an environmental intent. Looking further into past environmental programs by the government of New York City, a common hypocritical theme is found.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    What are the goals of the “orthodox” urban planners (Garden Cities” theorists, Le Corbusier etc.) whom Jacob criticizes? Jane Jacobs throughout Chapter 1 of “The Death and Life of Great American Cities” explains her philosophy regarding urban planning that is centered around using the successes and failures of existing cities as a paradigm for urban planning and design. Jacobs claims that cities “are an immense laboratory of trial and error” in which city planning should be based off of “learning, forming and testing” various urban theories. City planning must therefore take after the failures and successes of different types of urban design and not be rooted from utopian idealism. She often criticizes “orthodox” urban planning theory because they are “guided by principles derived from the behavior and appearance of towns, suburbs, tuberculosis sanatoria, fairs and imaginary dream cities” (9).…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Public Housing Failure

    • 1807 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Moreover, in addition to the segregation of public housing black peoples’ poor economic status at the time led to many blacks being crowded into segregated urban slums, due to a combination of economics, migration patterns from the south, and racist practices like redlining. When these slums began to be cleared black residents were displaced at high rates, leaving many with few options in terms of housing. Ultimately “they had the choice of either moving into public housing projects or to other slum areas, where they paid higher rents because the overall supply of low rent housing units was rapidly dwindling,” (Judd, Swanstorm 184) leaving the black community segregated, poor, and unaccepted by society. Even after the failure to integrate public housing, and the relocation of many black people into public housing, racism and stereotyping of black people continued to be pushed on by Republican administrations.…

    • 1807 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her article, “The Minority-Race Planner in the Quest for a Just City”, June Manning Thomas (2016) sheds light on the ongoing battle for social equity, with a major focus on the U.S context, and its links with developing a just city and the role of professional planners from racial groups in a transition to this ideal city realm. In her opinion, Race still remains a predominant force in the U.S social context and public behavior starts to deviate from its norms when it comes to minority groups in the society. Wilson (2003) argues that “centuries of different treatment, by individuals and by institutions, have left a lasting mark on the urban landscape, with far different circumstances for people perceived to be of minority race or ethnicity…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many commentators have claimed that this concentration of poverty has produced enormously negative societal consequences.” Written by Michael R. Diamond, these two sentences describe perfectly how public housing was used as a tool for segregation and aided in the failure of…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays