Baker kept in mind the age and sophistication of her students, and therefore acted reasonably when she suspended Elizabeth, since Elizabeth impacted the pedagogical purposes of Lincoln Heights. “The determination of what manner of speech in the classroom or in a school assembly is inappropriate properly rests with the school board.” Hazelwood, 484 U.S. at 267. Federal judges should not be the ones deciding whether or not an action is reasonably related to the pedagogical purposes of the school, that power belongs to the school district and their employees. Id. Ms. Baker concedes that gun control is a topic that may be discussed in the classroom, but not unsupervised like Elizabeth’s speech, as the immaturity of the other students may cause an emotional disturbance to them. …show more content…
Baker’s censoring of Elizabeth’s shirt represented viewpoint neutral censoring and therefore allowed under the Hazelwood standard. “A school must also retain the authority to refuse sponsor student speech that…associate[s] the school with any position other than neutrality on matters of political controversy.” Hazelwood Sch. Dist., 484 U.S. at 272. In DeFabio v. East Hampton Union Free Sch. Dist., the court held that a school’s limitation on student speech need only be “reasonable and viewpoint neutral. 623 F.3d 71, 78 (2nd Cir. 2010). That case dealt with a student who was banned from returning to school after threats made against him, due to insulting words he said against the race of another student who had died. The school did not allow DeFabio took present any speech, as that could have been interpreted as taking his side. DeFabio, 523 F.3d at 79. Ms. Baker took a similar approach as she was against any messages that were in favor of, or against, gun ownership. R-48. When in the courtyard she stopped both the anti-gun and pro-gun chants. R-35. She also explained to Elizabeth that any discussion of guns in a school setting, which is not supervised by a teacher, has a lot of potential for disruption. Id. Additionally, Elizabeth agrees that Ms. Baker informed her that any discussion of guns in school could cause a lot of trouble. R-36. Lastly, Elizabeth admits that her shirt was in favor of gun control, and not a viewpoint neutral stance. R-38. Combining