Comparing Night And C. S. Lewis A Grief Observed

Superior Essays
In this world, where it is a constant battle between good and evil, it is difficult to figure out why bad things happen. Many say God causes pain and suffering for no reason, but others consider everything to be a part of God’s predetermined plan for mankind. Differences in opinion for this dilemma are illustrated by the stark differences between the feelings of authors Elie Wiesel in Night and C.S. Lewis in A Grief Observed. Wiesel lost his faith in a good God, and he believed that there could be no plan in place that would permit the great evils and human suffering that he witnessed during the Holocaust. Then, there is Lewis who questioned God at the beginning of his grieving process, but he came to believe in the necessity of suffering caused …show more content…
I believe that the Genesis answer is very accurate because it touches on the pertinent point of human beings having free will. We were given the freedom to choose to tap into the good and/or evil that is within all of us. Our creation reason was to obey the will of God, though we still act out and decide to go against the one that gave us so much freedom and power. Free will is something that I firmly believe in because without it, there would be no reason for us to choose to turn to God, and that is the most important decision to make in life. When Lewis mentions the lilies, it is to show why he thinks God gave is free will despite the disadvantages. It is so that we are able to almost be our own gods, and so we can be unique, special creations. Disadvantages include wondering if having free will is worth the evil and the issue that, since God has so much power and intervenes at times, how much free will do we actually have? At times, we need God to intervene and that outweighs losing a little bit of our freedom to decide. Having free will gives us much power, but it also weakens us greatly. It brings about so much good, along with the evil, that we need it to have the positive things in this world as well. Lastly, the disadvantages are manageable because free will makes us able to choose God and gives us the great feeling of knowing that …show more content…
Despite this, nothing will separate us from God’s love, and we are supposed to continue and trust that God is with us, not against us. Disadvantages are that this response does not offer anything that is going to stop the evil, and it does not offer an option that will help us to live again. Nothing is more true than the fact that there is evil in the world that is unstoppable and happens to everyone. Whether it comes from inside us, from God, or from some outside evil source, the evil still happens without any end in sight. This is a livable disadvantage it is something we can accept. If there was no bad, then we could not enjoy the good or ever learn a lesson from our choices. There may be no end to the evil, but Romans says we will always have God by our side through it all. Thanks to this, we do not have much to worry about because we trust that God is for us. Jesus and God will always be there, and that is the greatest comfort in this response. Nothing else can provide as much protection as that never-ending love that comes to those who accept and repent for it. So, I believe those reasons greatly trump the disadvantages because we have the greatest protectors from the constant evil around us. Wiesel never stops proving that evil never quits, but that God (may it be positive or negative) is there throughout it

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The first communicable attribute I will be looking at is goodness. Humans can be good in relation to one another, but their standard is subjective. Therefore, true goodness is understood in light of the revelation of God in his Word. We can emulate the goodness of God, but we can never be perfectly good. We often hate, as the Lord does, but we do it unrighteously and in ignorance; God utilizes righteous hate and uses perfect judgment.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being free means that we have the choice to do evil things, a choice which some of us choose to exercise. This theodicy gains so many followers because it states that God does not create evil, yet evil can not be avoided without depriving us of our fundamental freedom of will. Moreover, the world without freedom would be an overall worse place. Through an examination of this explanation, it seems to preserve God 's goodness, because he created the best possible world. It also preserves his omnipotence and omniscience, because although he does know about evil and could stop it, the reason he chooses not to interfere is to ensure our freedom.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Book Of Job Essay

    • 1621 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Job wasn’t hiding anything and was innocent. Job’s friends wanted something to be wrong with Job. “want reason, they want justice, they want someone to be responsible…The book of Job is a story of undeserved suffering and the unrequited search for answers.” Job himself, wanted answers “He will not admit guilt that does not belong to him, but rails against God, asking for answers, asking for reasons, insisting on a response.” Our human minds can’t comprehend the divine’s justice. This is why everybody concluded that Job had done something wrong, because no follower of God would have to go through this horrible suffering. This story is kind of like Mary’s, Jesus’ birth mom, story.…

    • 1621 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This can be a very difficult question to answer when trying to avoid minimizing problems others could be facing. The Naturalist response to why bad things happen to good people is mostly because they believe the universe to be a purposeless entity that does not care why things happen or who they happen to; they just happen and we are expected to deal with it (Carrier). This is not the case. In a Christian point of view, the universe has a purpose and it was created by God. We are all sinners where even the seemingly “perfect” individuals have done wrong or committed various sins.…

    • 2009 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this think out loud assignment I chose question two. The topic of God’s knowledge and Saint Augustine’s solution has puzzled people from the time these ideas were brought forth into the world. These ideas about God are honestly hard for me to debate since I can see how both sides of God having foreknowledge of everything that is still to happen which makes humans not responsible for sin, and humans being at fault for their own sins. I have in past struggled with the idea that Judas went to hell when Jesus already knew that Judas would betrayed him. Why would he suffer when Judas was all part of a divine plan laid out by God to save mankind?…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The golden rule is simply just about being kind and loving towards everyone you meet. I also agree with the point that there is lots of good in the world, but it is our nature as humans to sin which has created evil in the world that God did not place on this earth. The view that is the least like my own is Martin’s. His pessimistic outlook on life is something I am not fond of and do not agree with. At times we are faced with anxiety or unhappiness, but this is not something that we are forever bound by.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Scripture tells us that as children of God we are going to be persecuted for His name (Matthew 10), but it also assures us that even through our sufferings we should be strong and do not be discourage for God will never leave us nor forsake us (Deuteronomy 31:6). So when we console someone who has been affected with pain? We listen! Our job is not to justify the reason (s), but to give them a listening…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hosea 4:6 says, “My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge: because thou hast rejected knowledge” The Bible also says in Proverbs 14:12 “There is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way of death.” Like our examples showed us, we cannot always rely on our own senses. Sometimes what we perceive is different than what the eyes of someone else has perceived. The only time we should be uncertain of our beliefs is if we cannot prove it or support it. However, our beliefs should never be uncertain because they are supported by the everlasting Word of God. Hebrews 4:12 says, “For the word of God is alive and powerful.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With this comes heaven, we can be welcomed if we are good people, but if God is making choices for us, we all should be good. This statement becomes confusing because, we make our own choices, God has no say in what we do. With that, God is not in control of our choices and Jennings is incorrect with his belief. When tragedy strikes, we find a way to blame God for what happened to us. When considering what we could have done better to change the way God thinks of us.…

    • 2055 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    I know that it may not seem true at times that God eliminates evil, but I feel that it is true that God eliminate evil. The evil that God permits is justified because allowing that evil make possible the achievement of a greater God or the prevention of a worse evil. (Evans and Manis, pp. 160) From what I’ve already learned about free will, is that most theist incorporate their views of the free will theodicy by making a souls making theodicy. We as humans make bad choices when it comes to their freedom.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays