Why I Amend The Electoral College

Improved Essays
Over the course of this semester in Poli 130A /Amer 130A class, the main focus of the class is the American political system. During class, the students learn about government institutions in regards to the ideals of the founding fathers and the workings of contemporary national politics. In doing so, the students also examine critiques of various institutional arrangements. However, now that the semester is coming to an end, the students are required to think critically about government and how it relates to the Constitution of the United States. This paper provides the opportunity for me to think about the various discussions from class. I need to determine what I would want to amend in the Constitution and how that would alter the operation …show more content…
This is because over the course of time, popular votes have been lost along the process of the electoral system. Presidents such as Rutherford B. Hayes did not receive a majority of the popular vote. Hayes won 47.9% whereas Tilden received 50.9%, but Hayes still became president through a 185 to 184 vote in the electoral college. (Longley and Neal, 32) Another reason I believe why the Electoral College should be eliminated is because there is a possibility to increase the overall voter turnout. There is a possibility that more citizens would use their right to vote if they know for certain that their vote matters and makes an impact. If people know that the president becomes elected based off of the popular vote rather than only a small elite number of people, then they may want to go out and vote so that the person they view as most qualified will be elected into office. Therefore, I believe that the electoral college should not exist because it provides an opportunity for presidents to be elected who did not receive the overall majority from the popular vote. This means that in a democratic society, the nominee who the people want to be their representative may lose due to the number of electoral college …show more content…
One other concern they had when establishing the executive branch was giving the president too much power. They feared the possibility of absolute power in the executive branch such as during the reign of King George the Third occurring again. That is why they put into place both limitations on the executive branch and an Electoral College system, which would make it so that a small elite group of the population would have the overall say in who becomes elected the next president. Therefore, if the Electoral College would be eliminated, the founders would probably not react too well. All the effort that they went to in order to make sure that the president would not be elected based off of just popular votes would have gone to waste. They would probably fear that uneducated voters would be a large portion of the voter turnout. This may end up resulting in a president who may not have the best qualifications to serve as a leader for the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A candidate can win the popular vote but still not win the election, because that candidate has more votes from the Electoral College. Some believe that the larger states have too much power. When you have too many electoral votes, the voice of the individual decreases, therefore, leaving little influence in the presidential election. This amount of power makes the voting unequal. Another criticism is the Winner Takes All process.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Citizens make up the state, so if you do not have citizens you would not have states. Then if we were to get rid of the Electoral College; then the candidates would pay attention to other states more than they do now. They are more worried about the winner take all system that they ignore the state they already know their vote for them. Which disenfranchises voter who supported the losing candidates. This system favors some citizens over others, which denies some people their choice of president.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Livonia Case Study

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The long presidential term may cause a president to eventually become corrupt and maybe even a dictator. The lack of term limits also makes it possible for a president to constantly be reelected which may end up hurting the country even though the country voted for that president in the first place because the unlimited time in power may cause presidents to use the seat of power for their own uses rather than to improve the country. The only way of ending a President’s term in office is to prove him/her guilty of “committing severe crimes” which are terms that I find too vague because it is up to interpretation rather than strict guidelines that the President cannot talk his/her way out of. The system is also inefficient when it comes to the topic of…

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How would you feel if your vote in deciding the next president of our country didn’t matter? Well, this is true for many people due to our broken Electoral College system of voting. I strongly feel that we should get rid of it for many reasons. My first reason is that it doesn’t give equal representation to certain states. My second reason is that it doesn’t match up with the popular votes that were taken by the people.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    More people would be encouraged to vote if their votes mattered and had a larger impact in the goings-on in their country. Our current system also encourages a two-party system that stops any third-party candidate from having a chance. It is extremely difficult for a new or minority party to have a chance at winning the presidential election. This system forces those candidates to either join the two main parties or give up (Kimberling). Even though some third-party…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College is in place to decide the president of the United States. There are people that agree on it and people that do not. The Electoral College System is an inadequate form of electing the president of the United States, there are better ways to go about choosing a president in a more Democratic way. Having a popular vote, or by deciding by congressional districts would be other options that Congress has thought about, and even states have signed in on being for a National Popular Vote. The Electoral College is a representation of the popular vote, on the other hand it makes it unfair at the same time.…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Electoral College Faulty

    • 1346 Words
    • 5 Pages

    What would have happened if four presidents that have long since been entered into the history books had not been the ones elected? In 1876, 1888, 1960, and 2000, the popular vote and the Electoral College did not elect the same candidate. However, the Electoral College had the final decision. The latest discrepeancy between the two voting systems revived the debate about the best election method. George C. Edwards develops the argument about how the Electoral College, with a faulty system detrimental to democracy, should be replaced with direct election.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One reason among many is that the system does not promise victory to the presidential candidate who wins the majority of the popular vote, which is voted on by the American citizens. To many, an effective resolution would be the alignment of the electoral vote with the popular vote in some way. Many polls have indicated that“…majorities of adult Americans would dump the electoral college “system” in favor of a direct one-person-one-vote system to elect American presidents.” (Cronin) On the other hand some “believe there must be a better way to select a president than by popular vote alone.” (Bosnor and…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many Americans are requesting that the Electoral College be abolished due to inconsistencies, for example: The Electoral College votes are not equally dispersed for each state, or someone could become President by winning only 21.8% of the popular vote, and the swing states vs the safe states which can favor one candidate over the…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    common interests. This is one of the reasons why Madison wanted more territories, more states, and more districts in the United States to prevent having a majority and separate powers. Furthermore, he did not think democracy would efficiently work in such a large country like the United States since the territory is overly large to keep all men in politics. Democracy only efficiently worked in small states because everyone was able to participate in politics such as Athena in ancient Greece. Also, he did not agree with the fact that majority would settle wise decision for the public.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays