Effects Of Framing On Decision Making

Superior Essays
How Framing Effects Contribute to Decision Making
Decision making is a cognitive process that is guided by a number of strategies, and occurs when making a choice. There are an infinite number of decisions made on a daily basis, most of which are made quickly, based off of previous knowledge of the situation. These strategies should lead to correct decision making but sometimes, when used incorrectly, biased decisions (incorrect decisions) occur. Framing often leads to biased decisions because it manipulates the way a message is received. Two different types of framing that influence a person’s decision are negative and positive framing. Positive framing occurs when presented with a gain, while negative framing occurs when presented with a
…show more content…
In this study they set out to see how rational choices were made. In order to do this they came up with a set of scenario problems. Each set of scenario problems was the same, but they were framed differently. Participants were given two scenarios, one pertaining to human life, the other pertaining to choices about money (similar to the study conducted for this paper). Tversky & Kahneman found that framing impacted the way participants made decisions. When participants were presented with a sure loss they made risk taking decisions, while being presented with a sure gain made them risk aversive. This is important to understand because framing can be used to manipulate a situation in a way that is not beneficial for the consumer of information. It is also important to this study, because the same types of positive and negative framing were used in the scenarios created. While framing can manipulate a decision, there is a set of strategies the people use in order to make decisions when there is a lack of information given about the …show more content…
In his study questions were framed either of mortality or survival, as well as a scenario about pregnancy: either deciding against it or choosing to still go through with it if it involved certain risks. A significant difference between men and women was found in the pregnancy scenario, women were more likely to still favor a pregnancy as well as see it more positively than men did. McNeil et al. believed that showed how “people interpret mixed or ambiguous frames in a selective fashion that is consistent with their values and/or beliefs” (p. 567). It is important to take into account how framing can shape a person’s decision, especially in the medical world. If physicians are biased toward a specific treatment they may not be fully offering all options that the patient may want to explore, and therefore are not allowing the patient to truly take an active role in their own health

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Fundamental attribution effect is one’s tendency to explain other’s behavior based on internal factors like personality and disposition. This theory explains that the impact of situational influences have on other's behavior is often underestimated when considering someone else's behavior. However, the theory also explains that when considering the inverse, our own behavior, situational factors are taken into more consideration. This discrepancy is where the "error" or "bias" or "effect" comes into play. The fundamental attribution effect analyzes how people come to reach dispositional assumptions, which can provide insight as to why there are common tendencies for error or bias in social behavior.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The opposition’s motive against this position would to remove the one or the other, not both. Another issue is determinism failing to explain twists such as someone who seemed very likely to make one choice, but ended up choosing the latter. These types of oddities would make determinism’s faulty nature unappealing while making free will more favorable when both should have equal consideration. Use of determinism also has a negative affect on motivation, causing people to put less effort into difficult tasks (Vohs…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pediatric Family Care

    • 1114 Words
    • 4 Pages

    When the physician and the patient have different expectations about the diagnosis and/or treatment of an illness, conflict may result. The physician may attempt to practice based on their evidence while the patient has their own belief and needs regarding care. This may create undue stress and tension between the physician and their patient, which could possibly result in the patient not following prescribed treatment measures. Evidence based practice and family-centered care can by integrated by considering and incorporating patient perceptions into the treatment trials (Siminoff, 2013). The patient preference treatment trials do not necessarily have to replace randomized trials, but instead, they can complement them and create a better understanding of patient choices in relation to outcomes.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Question Two The two explanations that can be used to examine the unethical behavior of public administrators are (1) the administrator makes “bad” choices that are unethical and (2) the circumstances play an intricate role in the action taken by the administrator. The first explanation argues that the administrator is not a “bad apple” or unethical, but made unethical decisions because of bounded rationality and a limited ethical conduct. The second explanation looks at how different environments and situations can lead administrators to make unethical decisions if they are not deeply rooted in an ethical code of conduct. Likewise, the situation or circumstance may…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Advanced correlational techniques may suggest the cause and effect statistically removing the influence of, for example, but extraneous variables associated. The advantage of correlational research is that it tends to happen in real situations, where we can consider factors such as race, gender and social status. Our fast generalizations are adaptive, but sometimes they are wrong. The common ways that people form or maintains false beliefs. Our preconceptions control our performances; our preconceptions guide how we perceive and interpret the information, influence social judgments, that is, we do not respond to the reality as it is, but the reality as we build on the mind.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An example of is opposition is a physician who is against abortion for personal moral reasons but must perform them them due to a hospital’s ethical requirements Both ethics and integrity can be subject to change. Ethics depend upon others for…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This devil’s advocate has the task of coming up with the potential problems of a proposed decision (Nelson, 2013, p. 373). This is a technique that when used correctly assists in the prevention of groupthink, which is defined by Nelson as “A deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing, and moral judgment resulting from pressures within the group” (Nelson, 2013, p. 369). Highly cohesive groups along with high-ranking groups that make decisions independently help are particularly vulnerable to to groupthink. Appointing a devil’s advocate to question the group’s methodology regularly will assist in the prevention of groupthink. Groupthink can cause an incomplete survey of alternatives, failure in the evaluation of the risks ivolved in the chosen alternative, and the inability to devise contingency plans.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Probability of effective persuation depends on how successful the communication is at bringing to mind, that is; a relevant mental presentation which is the elaboration likelihood. (Elaboration Likelihood Model) According to the Functional theories, Individuals have divergent attitudes towards people, objects or issues in different situations. Attitudes direct the behavior to increase positive external rewards and away from negative rewards/ punishments. (Adjustment Function) Attitudes work to protect the ego of oneself from being thretened by thier own negative impulses or threatening thoughts. (Ego Defensive…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The circumstances surrounding the situation, and the reactions of the individuals involved can impact the office’s decision on what the correct, moral, and ethical response should be. Situations can arise where the right answer is not clear and easy, officers are forced to make the best decision in each circumstance. The task of deciding which cases warrant an investigation, determining the appropriate consequences, and defusing the situation when no action is required is a huge responsibility (Gaines & Kappeler,…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This will help explain why making certain decisions are right or wrong. Moral Theory, which explains certain actions being wrong or why we must act certain ways and dealing with moral issues. This tells us how choices we make depends on the way we act and what we choose to do can no longer be turned over. Our actions define the choice we make in the time of picking. Other viewpoints brought up are principles which in many cases are the situations we face when making a decision.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays