Symbolism In Eating Dirt, By Charlotte Gill

Superior Essays
What is it like to be in the middle of nowhere and plant trees for a living? Eating Dirt by Charlotte Gill follows a female tree planter in the vast and remote north. The struggles and hardship these committed workers face is indescribable. This job revolves around a special tribe intertwined around freedom in the wilderness. The delicacy of trees and the environment is brought to life in this book. Even the smallest things are symbolic in the forests. Social commentary is a major theme in this story in which follows gender issues, freedom, roles of individuals, human compassion and the role of nature in our lives. The daily life of a tree planter is different of those of a normal job, dealing with a special type of culture blocked away from …show more content…
There are miles and miles of nothing but trees, “logging routes are like human arteries, main lines branching out into fine traceries” (3). It is easy for anyone to get lost, with no cell reception or connection to the world. But “behind the geographic challenges lay a gold mine in waiting, a superabundance of natural resources” (8). Charlotte is in a dissimilar world than she's used to—“beyond the protection of city walls, the forest concealed dangers: wild animals, darkness, and disorientation. In our fables and folktales the wilderness is an unfriendly realm, a place of deep existential terrors” (169). For example, when people are stressed they might or for a walk to get fresh air. Being a tree planter could be a way to get away from the struggles of your life for a couple months. This job is an escape for all the troubles in the world today, fresh air and independence makes up for the hazards. Nature is a big part of all of …show more content…
But up here in the deep forests, this difficult job is not something for women at first. It is mostly women but then Charlotte watches as more women join and succeed. When we think of lumberjacks or something to do up in the wilderness, we think of men, not women. But why couldn't women do the same as men if they are passionate to do so? “[They’re] unisex guys, the men of mandays. The work wears us down and lifts us up, everyone together, equally” (4). Equality is hopefully something someday all women can have. But until this, the way women are treated shapes how the society is. “If women worked there, they were cooks and custodial staff. The odd forestry professional or summer student. [The women would share] a single tiny bathroom” (188). Women are brave to do this kind of work, but so is everyone else who does

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Emma Marris presents us with a new way of viewing nature in the first chapter of her book, “Rambunctious Garden”. She explains that the definition of nature depicted in our “glossy magazines” describing a place “somewhere distant, wild and free” is incorrect, as it “blinds us” from the truth (Marris 1). Marris argues that we must adjust this definition to also include the nature found in “the bees whizzing down Fifth Avenue in Manhattan” and “the butterfly bushes that grow alongside the urban river” as well as the nature found in “managed national parks” (Marris 2). She uses experiences gained during her time spent in the forests of Hawaii and in Australia’s Scotia Sanctuary as evidence to support her argument. Marris also makes the point…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her 1983 commencement address, “A Left-Handed Commencement Speech,” Ursula K Le Guin offers a very straightforward yet motivational message to graduates of Mills College, an all female school. She states that women are foreigners in an extremely male-dominated society full of aggression and power and emphasizes her argument that women are peaceful compared to men, thus highlighting the difference between the two genders. She encourages her audience to live and succeed on their own terms rather than emulating “Machoman” by creating an emotional connection with her audience, establishing her credibility, and crafting an image of woman’s own country that effectively stresses the separation between men and women but appeals to the need for equality.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dirt, written by David R. Montgomery, is a book that pushes readers to discover the main factor behind the destruction of all civilizations: soil. From prehistory to today, Montgomery emphasizes the importance of soil in a society and how it is much more than just dirt. Dirt has always been the greatest resource that any civilization could possess. Soil has caused societies to blossom out of nowhere, thrive at their peak, and collapse at their weakest point.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To experience nature when all you know is civilization is to learn something new about your world and more importantly how it can make you new again. Cheryl Strayed, the author of the autobiography Wild, decided to embark on what she believed could be her life renewing opportunity. Cheryl's life had fallen apart before her eyes and taking a leap of faith, she hoped that not only did she have the power to hike alone the life threatening Pacific Coast Trail, but also that nature was strong enough to erase the atrocities she had endured. Nature has the ever so desirable ability to rid your life of modern things that creates negative distractions and make things new. Nature is the oldest, purest, and most natural thing in existence and is the basis to all things we have today.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A sense of place is particularly important in Appalachian literature. Place, or home, is where someone belongs. It is the attachment, emotions, and memories associated with a specific area. Oftentimes, it is where one feels most comfortable. For many of the characters in Appalachian literature a sense of place stems from different areas, whether it be the actual land or the people surrounding them.…

    • 1768 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It takes a moment in your life to have a self realization that will impact you for the rest of your life. In the text, “ Chasing Fairy Tales” by Lauren Fulmore she portrays the narrator as a little girl who goes through a moment in her childhood that changed her whole outlook on life. She recounts a series of adventures from her younger days to the accidental discovery of a “magical” truth. The author uses detailed examples to explain her main idea of the story.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the short story "Scar" by Amy Tan, the title is thoroughly complemented to the story. The author creates an organized plot that exhibits the numerous uses of literary devices such as symbolism, figurative language, and progression in order to make it obvious to the reader that the title brings out the entire premise of the story. Amy Tan uses a great deal of symbolism in her novella which stands out in her work and makes her writing more compellingand appealing to the reader. Her symbolism points out precisely how important the scar really is in relation to the title and the story. For example, it is stated that "With her pretty, pale face, my mother appeared to float in the room, like a ghost" (Tan 16-17).…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inequity between both men and women has been quietly acknowledged as commonplace within our society; with the patriarchy and various stereotypical gender roles creating rifts between the two genders. However, for as long as the patriarchy has existed, so have the individuals who choose to stand against it. These people protest this inequity by defying the gender roles of society, and instead deciding to follow their own standards for living. Louise Erdrich’s novel: Tracks, is a story of a Native American Reservation in the 1900s that suffers from the forced presence of white culture in the community. In this story, two narrators named Nanapush and Pauline share their perspectives of the changes within their society; mainly focusing around…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Yellow Wallpaper was Charlotte Perkins Gliman 's reaction to the rest cure that psychiatrist Silas Weir Mitchell had prescribed to her when she became depressed after the birth of her first child. Gilman believed that the cure had not only been ineffective, but had caused her depression to worsen. Gilman wrote the story to challenge Dr. Mitchell to alter his treatment of neurasthenia. Charlotte Perkins Gilman used symbolism within the yellow wallpaper to challenge the effects that the treatment for neurasthenia was having on women. Charlotte Perkins Gilman makes the setting in which the narrator lives symbolic of the oppression of women who were prescribed the rest cure for hysteria in the 1800 's in order to challenge the efficiency of…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She takes a seed of an idea involving historical context where everyone is involved and needed to help others it doesn’t matter who are what you are and turns it into an ecological battle to protect nature. Walker touches on the idea of collective responsibility for others actions on, Walker states “The Earth holds us responsible for our crimes against it, not as individuals but as a species- this was the message of the trees.” (662) it links to a subject that historically many people are aware of and understand it due to its multiple points of view it can take whether it be the enslavement of African Americans and other minorities for profiteering, an issue which did not stop until people came together as a community and rallied to prevent the oppression of minorities and fight for equal rights, just African Americans fighting for equal rights and just women fighting for voting right s would never have gotten anywhere if people didn’t come together from every race and sex and fight for collective equality. The workings of Christopher Manes in his piece Nature and silence helps to solidify this gap and the need for this cultural rift to be fixed, stating “A Tuscarora Indian once remarked that, unlike his people’s experience of the world, for Westerners, “the uncounted voices of nature . .…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are times when life’s situations make us do drastic choices, to help us escape, find ourselves or even to heal the soul within. In the novels “Into the Wild,” and “Wild” both of the characters take an unimaginable trip out into the wilderness to escape everyone and everything that at one point in their life’s was important to them. Both “Into the Wild” and “Wild” are distinctly different from each other, despite wilderness being both of the stories it’s symbol. The distinctions between Chris and Cheryl journeys were their motives, geographic locations, the use of money and food, and being alive at the end of their journey.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blood sucker, dead, predator: These are all words that can describe a vampire. There have been several vampire stories throughout the years. Each author takes and gives them different characteristics but they usually are universally described as a creature that was once human that somehow has returned from the dead and preys on living humans by drinking their blood to stay alive. Dr. John William Polidori, an English writer and physician, is said to have created the first written vampire story in his short story The Vampyre: A Tale.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Many people think that males in our society today are brought up to define who they are as a person through the idealized version of heroics, the glory of competition, and, above all else, the idea that only winners are successful. Females, on the other hand, are brought up to define their identities through assembly, collaboration, unselfishness, home life, and community. This view of different male and female roles can be seen throughout literature. However, though both men and women have been represented throughout literature there is a clear commentary thread on the roles of women in society.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As children, nature greatly intrigues us and gives us numerous experiences that life at home cannot. Experiencing nature allows children to deepen their connection with the environment that surrounds them and the secret wonders they might discover. In Sara Orne Jewett’s short story “A White Heron”, Sylvia, a child who spends much time in the story-like realm of the woods near her home, meets a charming hunter who is looking for the rare white heron. The hunt for the heron allows Sylvia to explore the woods deeply and climb the great pine tree of the forest. Before encountering the hunter, the woods near Sylvia’s home provided her an escape to a parallel universe where she could enjoy and observe nature’s many wonders.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women And Equality In The Workplace Gender Equality is the most common issue which has come across at the workplace in which women are treated inferior than the other men employees. It has been noticed than women are being paid less than men, and there is a male-dominant crowd in the workplaces. For no reason women are set apart when they are equally intelligent as men. It is very casual that women are also capable of doing a particular job as men. Gender discrimination in workplaces are fallacious assumptions and must be stopped because women are just as productive as a male employee is in doing an allotted task.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays