Loyalty John Duska Analysis

Improved Essays
Duska uses John Ladd’s definition of loyalty to best define loyalty. He quoted “Granted that loyalty is the whole-hearted devotion to an object of some kind, what kind of thing is the object”. Loyalty can be a person or a group of persons. You can have a whole-hearted devotion to an either. Two examples would in my life would be I have loyalty to my father. I would never betray him nor would he ever betray me. A form of loyalty within a group is me playing on the football team. I devote a large quantity of my time to football. Practice, meetings, and games all are both mentally and physically exhausting, this proves whole-hearted devotion to not only the team, but everyone within it. In Duska’s terms this would be an example of “the ties that …show more content…
A business’ main priority is to make money. You have no meaning to a business, merely a way to get to its end goal, maximized profit. Duska makes a clear argument for what you should be loyal too and not loyal too. He describes that a business is a different type of group, with weak, insignificant, relationships. Businesses like to make the false argument of working as a team, but Duska states “loyalty to a team is loyalty within the context of sport or a competition. The business world is not a sport though. You have any obligation to your company, you are there for the sole purpose to make money and provide for yourself or your family. It is too easy to leave your company or for them to let you go to be loyal to them. Whistleblowing is a necessity if it is for the benefit of others or yourself. For example if a refinery was pumping its waste into a local reservoir or lake then you have a moral obligation to blow the whistle for the greater good. Duska tells the Bok says that the whistleblower is a violator of loyalty because he blows the whistle on his own team. In my opinion the whistleblower does not have a team. A company is not a team as I previously stated. A team is in context of sport or competition and a company’s objective is not to achieve victory, like a team, but to achieve maximum profit. Duska is correct in his statement that he works because it provides him pay. People are wired to do what is best for them, you don’t work because you want to. You work in order to get paid and make money to provide for yourself. If money was irrelevant than nobody would work. Why waste your time to better someone else’s company if there is no incentive for you? Duska ends his paper by saying “If my analysis is correct, the issue of the permissibility of whistleblowing is not a real issue since there is no obligation of loyalty to a company. He is correct in this statement and his paper give an accurate argument of why loyalty

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Their social purpose is to make profits, grow bigger and make much money as possible for its stakeholders. Individuals who run these corporations do not care about what impact their business have or how they affect the social life of other people. From my point of view, this is the main reason why he claims that the business owners care about the social responsibilities of their social life, but they don't take care of the same social responsibilities when it comes to running their businesses. The way he was proposing was right. Companies and firms should be allowed to make as much profit as they can, but in return, legislations that will demand the benefits created by the businesses to be used to take care of the externalities from their companies should be set.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I think that he just concentrated on earning money and a high profitability business without concern about other people. He must learn and understand more about morality, ethical corporate, and its social responsibility. He seemed to be be an immature adult because he did not know what he did wrong and he blamed for others. I do not think a government authority was able to revoke a business license just because…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As he said, passion, combined with previous experiences, is the key to succeed and the main source of power in that company because, for example, his position is not due to a qualification, because the degree he has is completely different from the job he is doing. By being so passionate, he represents a source of inspiration for his followers. Another aspect that confirms the adoption of a transformational leadership approach in the company is the creativity he and his employees have. The example of selling their products also in boutiques confirms this point because he has the courage to change what it was a good situation, since they were making money…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This could also be detrimental to co-workers or management and employee because rather than working towards a common goal, one will work towards their own interests and workers will end up being competitors. Nonmonetary motivation has a wider variety of rewards as these motivations are generally tailored to personal interests and internal motivation rather than a ‘general’ reward. Different forms of nonmonetary motivation could include flexible working hours, promotions etc. There are fewer problems with nonmonetary motivation compared to monetary motivation because according to personal statuses. It can be assumed that Spectre’s motivation is nonmonetary as he makes no reference to him needing a financial increase but rather a promotion in his position.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite the promotion of society though profit maximisation, the intention of businesses become under scrutiny as their motive is questionable to the point that their beneficiary behaviour is fact selfishness (Mintzberg & Simons, 2002). The only time a business will actively benefit society is when it is in their own self-interest. In other words, they expect society to contribute to their profit maximising scheme whenever they assist the public. But, to popular belief many people think that virtuous behaviour is born by the motivation of selflessness (Fieser, 2012). Our actions deserve praise only when they are done for the goodness of others…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thus, if they are in a team where honor is placed on the whole, they would not try hard because they don’t care about the team but only themselves, which make them hard to get promoted in a company. Twenge asserts that “When individual performance was recognized by putting each person’s name on the board with his or her number of creative uses, narcissists performed very well. When the credit went only to their group, however, narcissists didn’t try very hard and performed fairly poorly” (47). Narcissist, a selfish person, is only concerned about their own success. They like to work independently so that they can get all the credit.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She gives us an example about you working at a company, and you are trying your best to make money for yourself and a profit for your company honestly. Or so you think she says not to get caught up in the everyday work flow with going through the motions. And that you should not only do your work for the money but do it because it also benefits someone…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Employers should trust their employees with any decision that needs to be made; not just decisions about the work that is needed to be done, but they also have to trust them to handle their paid time off and any vacations they take. Trust is very important in this type of work. Oxford stresses that High performance organizations may not hire any family members. The reason for that, he says, is because it is hard to fire family members and the other employees may feel as if they have it easy because they are related to the one in charge. Jobs in these companies are competitive, therefore it is necessary to put in effort everyday and have to earn your spot.…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Again, there is no way for an average executive to know this. If someone ignores these warnings and attempts to give back to the community to gain some goodwill for their company, they would only be acting short sighted. Friedman says that this kind of behavior only reinforces the idea that the pursuit of profit is wrong and immoral, even when fair pursuit of profit is what a business is meant for (Friedman,…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    NSPE rules that, “engineers shall not promote their own interest at the expense of the dignity and integrity of the profession.” In this case, Rob’s interest is monetary. After explaining his solution for complaints, he reveals that the company can expect a net annual profit of $416,000. His calculations are correct in terms of generating a large sum of revenue; however, those numbers overlook ethical barriers. Rob, blinded by greed, is willing to tarnish the honorable name of engineering that serves for the public to gain more financial compensation. Even though adverse affects on the reputation of engineers would occur, a thoughtful response can still avert this…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays