Dupin And Holmes: A Comparative Analysis

Good Essays
Our first assigned reading was Poe’s detective story, The Murders in Rue Morgue. In the story, the unconventional detective Dupin and the unnamed narrator solve the murder with the assistance of the police, their own private investigating, and Dupin’s intellect. When we watched The Study in Pink, similarities could be drawn between Poe’s detective, Dupin, and Doyle’s detective, Sherlock Holmes. For example, Sherlock is an unconventional detective. He also does his own private investigating and uses his intellect to solve crimes much like Dupin. In both these works, Dupin and Holmes use unconventional methods and their high intellect to solve the case at hand. As new detectives come onto the TV screen, remakes allow detectives of the past like …show more content…
The detective genre that Poe had created was changed from the gory origins it was to something that could be shown and acceptable to a younger audience. For example, Dora the Explorer was a detective, but she focused more on exploring and finding clues to solve crimes than on the actual crime solving. The Scooby-Doo show catered to younger teens, and showed them that being young detectives and solving crime could be fun, especially if you have the Mystery Machine and a groovy bunch of friends and/or …show more content…
It had returned to its roots with serious and gory shows, like CSI: Miami and Law & Order. These shows displayed what the reality of crime solving is really about. These shows let audiences see that cop teams and their departments help solve crimes by working together to catch the criminal. There isn’t a super genius that can swoop in, have all the answers, solve the crime, and case closed. In CSI, the show focuses on going to the lab, getting DNA samples, investigating the crime scene, and interrogating suspects. In CSI, there is a concentration in how detectives proceed in crime scenes where in novels there aren’t these details like people swabbing for DNA or taking pictures of the body. In Law & Order, the show focuses on getting arrest warrants, asking people to testify, getting judge signatures, and working with attorneys. In Law & Order, there is a concentration on the legal side that detectives and police have to deal with in any case that they are presented

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The fundamentals of criminal investigations are identifying witnesses, offenders, connecting evidence, from the crime scene to the offender or victim but not limited to apprehending the offender. Since crime scene reconstruction is gaining explicit knowledge of the series of events from a crime then I would describe it as getting more in depth with the witnesses, suspects, victims, and looking deeper into the evidence that was previously and newly discovered in order to find out what really happened and to find the…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case Study of Motive: Season 2, Episode 4 Kai Mizuno Motive, a crime show with a unique twist. At the beginning of every episode, the viewer is shown who the killer and victim are. The episode goes on to show detectives trying to solve the crime, while also showing scenes from the past to allow the viewer to decipher what the killer’s motive was. This unique twist of presenting crime also allows viewers to see different angles of how forensics play into solving crimes. Forensic tests performed in the show pave the way for the detectives to solve the case.…

    • 1746 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Criminal Profiling is a technique whereby the probable characteristics of a criminal offender or offenders are predicted based on the behaviors exhibited in the commission of a crime. The job of a criminal profiler is very crucial in homicide cases. It helps the law enforcement to find and arrest the killer by knowing little details that determine possible suspects for the crime. Criminal profilers investigating serial killers have always tried to formulate some idea of the characteristics of unknown culprits as an aid to finding and convicting them. This is not an easy task.…

    • 1603 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This type of science is called forensic science, and this is what the investogators use to figure out: why, where, when, and how the crime took place. The investigators gets evidence from the crime scene, and takes to a labortory and multiple tests on the it. Sometimes science aspects don’t always help solve the…

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Most commonly used and preferred by the FBI is the CSA method which takes details about the crime scene and turns them into personality trait of the perpetrator. For example; a victim with excessive amounts of assault or mutilation points to an attacker who may have a compromised mental status or could be in a rage fueled rampage and with this information, law enforcement can narrow down a suspect pool to those who have anger issues or a history of severe mental illness. There will always be exceptions to the rules but in most cases, the crime scene does not lie. Forensic Psychologist Richard Kocsis states in his article on the history of profiling, “human behavior is in some capacity a reflection of personality.” (“Criminal”). What the suspect leaves behind or purposely doesn’t leave behind, tells law enforcement a lot about their distinct personality.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Criminal Psychology Introduction: Criminal psychology is the study of the intentions and behaviours of criminals. Criminologists apply psychology to crime in order for them to uncover the criminals reasoning for committing the crime. This is not a job that many people know about but I believe that it is a very important job so that the police and other agencies have information about what and who they are dealing with. I had a short limited amount of prior knowledge about this topic but from researching it further I have accumulated much more information and have created 3 key questions that I will be exploring. First I will be analysing the question How can criminal psychology help the criminal justice system and other agencies deal with…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Forensic psychology is a subspecialty of psychology that works within the criminal and civil legal system. This allows forensic psychologists to contribute in different ways to the court. These services including assessing those that are accused of their fitness to stand trial based on their mental health, jury selection and interrogation techniques (Roesch, 2015). The legal system, which regulates our life and society makes perfect sense to depict in television dramas. Law & Order: Special Victims Unit premiered in 1999, and the premise of the show is showing how detectives investigate and convict criminals of sexually based crimes (NBC, 2015).…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Profiling simply defines the use of information from the crime scene to describe the offender’s behaviour while committing the act of crime. (Criminal Psychology: A Beginner’s Guide, p. 6 to 7) Criminal profiling or offender profiling is one of the used techniques in identifying a criminal in several cases besides scouring for physical evidences like blood, murder weapons, and many more. It has already been used in various scenarios when it comes to solving cases pertaining to rape, murder, kidnapping, etc. It is commonly used in narrowing the number of suspects in an investigation, and to also evaluate suspects using psychological means which is profiling. However, it does not identify the main culprit, but on the bright side, it’ll most likely be able to identify the personality and behavioural characteristics the perpetrator possesses.…

    • 2474 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Career As A Police Officer

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages

    They respond to the scene of the incident and see the collection of evidence that is important evidence of fingerprints to objects that are personal that the criminal may have dropped. The FBI develops profiles of the victim and the unidentified attacker to discover the action behind the homicide and slender the search for the murderer. Controversy and danger are the realities of the job. Agents can be in serious problems that can lead to injury or death, even with the best training. Through the federal justice system, the FBI is respected and are relied upon the ultimate resource…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    All they have to go on is the crime scene, evidence from the crime scene, and witnesses that may have information on the victim. They build the profile from the ground up because each serial killer is different. Behavioral profiling is now being used taking basic psychological aspects and turning it something that can help understand and catch the serial…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays