How To Fong's Identity Struggle In Kominka

Improved Essays
Doka, Kominka, and Colonial Identity The year 1919 witnessed a turning point in the Japanese colonial policies on its formal colonies, Korea and Taiwan. It was at the apex of Woodrow Wilson’s call for national self-determination that several national independence movements were seen in colonies around the world, among which the March 1 Independent movement in Korea was one of the most fierce and brutal. Although the nature of colonialism in Korea remained the same, the propaganda was indeed changed, if only superficially, by calling for the unity of the Japan metropole and Korea colony as naisei ittai. In the case of Taiwan, the colonial policy also became assimilation-oriented, seen in the abolition of segregated educational system and …show more content…
Fong’s binary perspective in asserting the intellectuals’ embracing Japanese identity and their unaffected underclass counterparts in kominka literature suffers the oversight of reducing literature to a mere medium of political or moral judgment “according to the manner in which certain identities are either confirmed or refuted.” On the other hand, in interpreting Wu Zhuoliu’s The Orphan of Asia, which Fong curiously leaves out from his discussion of literature of the 1930s colonial Taiwan, Ching refuses to make a dichotomous interpretation and regards “identity struggle as a historically colonial condition.” The identity struggle of the protagonist, Hu Taiming, actually implies the formation of consciousness against the backdrop of the kominka movement that conditioned colonial subjectivities and …show more content…
As elaborated in depth by the authors reviewed, it is revealed that the discussion of such identity cannot be separated from how Japanese colonialism worked and how the continuity and discontinuity of today is conditioned by the history that formed the identity. By combining the institutional and ideological perspectives in colonial administration, identity of the colonial subjects is seen unstable and requires constant negotiation because of the macro-politics of the empire. The emergence of Taiwanese identity and its tension with Chinese identity is complicated and circumscribed by the colonial condition in the 1920s and 1930s. Colonial legacy is detected in today’s Taiwanese identity in various discourses of nationalism and its content as well as history have been reinvented and redefined for different purposes. On the issue of colonial legacy, it would be interesting to complement the discussion by a more systematic study that historicizes the transformation in the post-war period, for example, through a study that combines both hard facts and literary representations. By doing so, hopefully, the conundrum of Taiwanese identity could be solved in the near future.

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In “What Did the Internment of Japanese Americans Mean?” originally published in 2000 by St. Martin’s Press, University of California’s assistant professor of history Alice Yang Murray illuminates the travesty of internment set upon Japanese Americans by the United States. Alice Yang Murray is a passionate humanitarian, historian and while her surname Yang tells us she is she is of Asian or more specifically Chinese decent she does not allow this supposed bias to detract from her factual analysis. If there is anything is to be said regarding the bias of Murray it that she has done a great deal of research to forgo it. This omitted bias is in stark contrast to the historians whom have covered the subject of internment in the past. According to Alice Yang Murray “..even as these works recount a history of strikes, riots, and mass demonstrations, they present resistance as an unfortunate product of miscommunication and misunderstanding rather than a legitimate response to incarceration”(21).…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Li Ang’s “The lost Garden” and Ang Lee’s “Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon” are both stories with love as a central theme, both these works however touch on more than just that. Gender issues are addressed in both works; while they may differ in representation both show the inner workings of the male and female roles in Asian culture. With a strong patriarchal figure in Li Ang’s novel, compared to the strong female charters in Ang Lee’s film. The use of class systems is also represented in both works. An example being the contrast of the newly rich construction developers, versus the prestigious families that date back centuries.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Causes Of Ww2

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The end of the first world war was not as fulfilling as one might have initially thought. The so called “War to end all wars” as stated by Margaret MacMillen, was just a ripple before the tidal wave. World War I was successful only at forming new problems and expanding others. Firstly, WWI was caused by Nationalism, Imperialism, Militarism, Industrialism, and Alliances that were governing powerful countries across the world. These drove the globe into its first World War and in return led to World War II as well.…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Even though this background may make him biased, it makes him a primary source on the struggles of a minority. Takaki’s grandparents were laborers from Japan which places Takaki in the Asian American category and implies that he was at some point the subject of the myth that Asian Americans are the model minority. Takaki’s specialization in ethnic studies and history in Asian Americans establish that he is a reliable source in his argument. He takes facts and knowledge gained from over the years to present a clear argument for both sides of the spectrum. His style and tone do not suggest passion or aggression, but do give the effect of an activist.…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An analysis of contrasting approaches to topics of the Japanese Canadian Internment camps The Japanese internment camps reflect a dark time in Canadian history, where mass fear and racial hatred led to a tragic violation of human rights and liberties. Two articles, “Passing Time, Moving Memories: Interpreting Wartime Narratives of Japanese Canadian Women” by Pamela Sugiman and “British Columbia and the Japanese Evacuation” By Peter Ward, take on contrasting approaches to this issue, with the former noticeably more intimate and in depth in its approach in collecting information about the internment camps. In this article analysis I will provide detail about the key arguments in each article, compare their respective approaches and content,…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The significant accuracy is evident in the extent of casualties of Pearl Harbor and the Battle of Okinawa as well as in the widespread arrest and confinement of Japanese-Americans into internment camps as a result of these battles. Additionally, it is also culturally accurate in the practice of kendo, hard labor, and the picture bride system of the Japanese people. Overall, this novel explores one of the unspoken shames of American history: the struggle of Japanese-Americans to live in a society that was once home but became a prison of discrimination during…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the reading Growing Up Asian in America A. Lin Goodwin study’s the sense of self or identity through the eyes of nine Asian Americans growing up in this country as others and not a part of our social society. The Asian population consumes about 11.3 million people in the United States which is an increase of about 100% since the last US census was conducted. The Asian population has been a part of the United States history and has paved the way for future Americans since the 17th century. The participants that were selected for this study were selected consisted of four Korean Americans, three Chinese American’s and two south Asian or Indian Americans. Five of the nine are school teachers and the last was a college student.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Plague of Progress: Mishima’s Characterization and Views of Westernization A common misconception is that change always equates to progress, yet sometimes change can strip a society of its fundamental characteristics. Japan endured similar events, surrounding World War II that resulted in an increasingly Westernized country that lost it’s integrity and beliefs. In this allegorical novel, The Sailor who fell from Grace with the Sea, Yukio Mishima uses the characters Fusako, Ryuji and Noboru whom symbolize the different states of Japan to illustrate the plague of Westernization and convey the value of tradition in Japan. Primarily, Fusako embodies modern Japan with her obsession with foreign goods and focus on economic growth, which conveys…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    "There is no Japanese `problem' on the Coast ... There is far more danger from Communists and people of the Bridges type on the Coast than there is from Japanese”[Munson Report]. The report broke the Japanese living on the coast into three different categories: The ISSEI -- First generation of Japanese who are considered weaken by their loyalties to the emperor and the motherland. They are still Japanese citizens but do break from their motherland and their culture in order to secure a better future for their children. The NISEI - second generation Americans educated entirely in America and who show an extreme eagerness to be American despite all the racial ignorance directed towards them.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The House Of Lim Analysis

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Margery Wolf’s novel “The House of Lim,” the author recounts her own life experiences of living abroad in rural Taiwan. In 1959, Margery and her anthropologist husband, Arthur P. Wolf, lived with the Lim family in the countryside for several years. During this time, she analyzed their time with the family, who followed traditional Confucian beliefs. For its time, Wolf’s novel was one of the first outside perspectives written about life in this region. A small village, Peihotien, was a perfect example of authentic country life.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many contrary opinions when people mention the Japanese-American Internment Camp. Many people allegedly claim that this action was imperative, others held a differing opinion. In this essay I will be explaining why I believe this extrinsic and racist act was not essential. I agree with the article we read that was against the act of the internment camps because it was really unnecessary and racist. This should have never happened.…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The passage, “A Pair of Tickets” is an excerpt from the book, The Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan. Tan’s book is a narrative that derives from Tan’s life growing up as a Chinese-American. Jing-Mei “June” Woo is a thirty-six year old woman who has always considered herself to be “American” as she was born and raised in San Francisco, California. June finally travels to her motherland as a result of her recently deceased mother’s desire to reconcile with her long lost daughters. Throughout her journey in China, she connects with her paternal side of the family as well as her half-sisters she’s never met and begins to rediscover and acknowledges both sides of her of herself, her “American” identity and her “Chinese” identity.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Goddess Film Analysis

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Goddess (1934) is a silent film made by Wu Yonggang, a well-known Chinese director in the 1930s. Hailed as “a masterpiece of ‘the first golden age of Chinese cinema’”, the film marked not only Wu’s directorial debut, but also “the pinnacle of [Ruan Lingyu’s] career” (Harris, 128). Ruan’s “mature, nuanced performance”, which was “subtle but at the same time powerful and rich”, proved to be a major factor in the movie’s success and lasting impact in Chinese cinema – even inspiring Hong Kong director Stanley Kwan to produce Centre Stage (1992), a biopic of Ruan, over fifty years later (Harris, 128; Rayns, 18). This response will examine and show how the depiction of Ruan Lingyu by male directors in both The Goddess and Centre Stage make use…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes I am curious about what the many different groups of minorities feel like in the United States. For example, their struggles, emotions, and actions they choose to make while trying to adjust to a new environment. Eric Liu’s memoir The Accidental Asian demonstrates just that. It depicts the double consciousness, social structures, instances of identity confusion, and the agency a second-generation Chinese American experiences.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the conclusion of WWII, it was quickly realized that the countries that held such international power were rapidly losing their authority. In the late 18th century decolonization began but by no means had the European expansion reached its uttermost point. Most European statesmen prized their colonies as extensions of power and state power. There is no question that power matters in the international community. While decolonization may have been the favourable option to the ruling powers, it is evident that it did not reach their expectations.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays