Analysis Of What Plants Talk About By Dr. Cahill

Improved Essays
The film, What Plants Talk About, starts out with a researcher from the University of Alberta, Dr. James Cahill. He is an Experimental Plant Ecologist trying to find the answer to the question: Do plants behave like animals? Throughout the film, Dr. Cahill observes the research of other scientists who are experimenting with their questions as well. Cahill compares plant behavior to animal behavior. All plants, as well as animals, are complex and have complex feeding behaviors. Every plant on earth is on the constant hunt for food and nutrients—just like animals. To test his theory, Dr. Cahill and his student Pamela at University of Alberta use high tech, time lapse cameras that help to see how plant roots forage for nutrients. The research …show more content…
Ragan Callaway, a professor of Plant Ecology at the University of Montana, researched if plants compete over food and land, like animals. In Montana, spotted knapweed, a weed from Europe, is killing off the native grasses that local cattle love to eat. This destroys farmers’ and ranchers’ livelihoods by not allowing feed to be available for their cattle. There’s a territorial battle that goes on underground between plants and the knapweed. So, how can the ranchers fix this problem? It turns out that sheep are happy to eat knapweed, unlike the cattle. But this still doesn’t solve the knapweed problem, considering that the weed has invaded four and a half million acres of Montana’s rangeland. Dr. Callaway worked to study how the knapweed wages war against the native plants. Knapweed gives off toxic chemicals in its roots that kill off a lot of native grasses at their core roots, which allows knapweed to take over the rangeland. To test the lethalness of the chemicals that knapweed produces, Dr. Callaway planted native grass alone in pots and others in pots of knapweed. The lone grass was healthy and growing perfectly well, but the grass growing with knapweed was half its size. The plant Lupin is Montana native that can fight off knapweed. Lupin gives off a chemical, which acts as a defensive shield to defend itself and the plants around it. Scientists ask, “what does this complex behavior teach us about plants?” I think that this territorial behavior can be related back to …show more content…
Susan Dudley, a Plant Evolutionary Ecologist at McMaster University, devotes her research to finding out what other forms of social interaction are at play in the plant world, such as kin recognition. Animals are able to use kin recognition to avoid mating with their relatives. Plants too have a kind of kin recognition because they somehow avoid mating with themselves. Plants can also sense other plants by using photo or light receptors in their leaves. On the shores of Lake Ontario, Dr. Dudley and student Amanda studied searocket plants for root kin recognition. Their mission was to find out if roots behave differently when growing next to their kin. Searocket produces 2 sea pods, one which clings to its mother which results in the plants growing up side by side. Dr. Dudley and Amanda planted some searockets together and others with unrelated plants. After a few weeks, the research team examined the roots. The searocket siblings growing together restrained their root growth and selflessly shared the soil. The searockets and the stranger’s roots competed against each other. But, how did the searockets identify their kin, perhaps by using chemical signals? To find answers, Dr. Dudley and her research team conducted a second experiment using Arabidopsis as the plant research subject. They placed two Arabidopsis siblings in water, but blocked off their ability to produce chemical signals. The seedlings ramped up root growth and began competing against each other as if they

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Diction In Marigolds

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The author of Marigolds is, Eugenia Collier. Her short story uses many literary devices such as, diction, imagery, flashbacks, juxtaposition and foreshadowing. Collier’s short story is about a young girl called “Lizabeth” and a short memory of her childhood that flashes back to her. An example of diction that Collier used is, “he sobbed, loudly and painfully, and cried helplessly and hopelessly” (21) ,the author was using diction in here to show how upset Lizabeth’s father was.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bean Trees: Book Review The Bean Trees, by Barbara Kingsolver, tells the tale of a simple country girl. A book of realistic fiction, the author builds a story full of bewilderment, travel, heart-wrenching moments and nature. Throughout the novel, Kingsolver repeatedly incorporates nature into her writing, using her knowledge as a biologist. Additionally, the story deals with darker, real-world issues such as prejudice and discrimination.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nature has enslaved people since the beginning of time. As humans have developed they have overcome oceans, plagues, nomadism, and other organisms. Most recently scientists have created means to overcome the biological constraints of agriculture, and the plant that has contributed the most is corn. Pollan stated. “corn has done more than any other species to help the food industry realize the dream of freeing food from nature’s limitations.(91)” thesis Modern corn now is genetically changed to have the qualities wanted in corn commodity.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    n the book, “They Came Before Columbus” Ivan Van Sertima educates us about how the life of a plant is not a simple matter. He states clearly that “It requires the adoption of a whole complex of knowledge about the plant’s ecological requirements, and often also about the human usages of plants.” From early childhood education, we were always taught that the only use of our ancestors were to pick cotton that was previously here. However, we were taught wrong.…

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wild West Research Paper

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The interior of the Wild Wild west is being invaded from all sides. This biological region is generally the expanse from Northern Idaho all the way to the Southern New Mexico with Cascade Range and Rocky Mountains enclosing. The interior of the west contains a vast trove of wildlands that are for the most part not managed by the government or any organizations due to the unpopulated nature of the environment. In the meantime, nonnative species of plants have managed to billow into self-sustaining populations within the regions due to lack of oversight within the region.…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Yucca Moth Lab Report

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages

    It was noted that the presence or absence of predators doesn't seem to have any affect on the plant survivorship, but increase in vapor pressure results in a greater survivorship. She therefore came to the conclusion that the stability of mutualisms can in fact be affected by some extrinsic factors. This proves that just because the yucca-yucca moth relationship exists doesn't mean that their interaction guarantees their survival. In some cases their existence is also hindered by their relationship if it is obligate. She suggests future long-term research into a wider variety of extrinsic sources and larger geographic areas, in order to fully understand the evolution of the symbiosis.…

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hope Jahren's Lab Girl

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The most impactful books are those that bring world inside of them to life in vivid detail. In Hope Jahren’s “Lab Girl,” the world brought to life is our own. However, rather than conveying a human-centric story, Jahren focuses on an often-forgotten character: plants. Jahren is a geochemist and geobiologist, and “Lab Girl” is a cross between a memoir and a textbook explaining the intricacies of plant life. The most memorable excerpts are those where plants are personified, from the stories ingrained in wood to the miracles of the resurrection plant.…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Knigge Ranch Case Study

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Knigge Ranch is a 800-acre ranch located 10 miles west and 7 miles north of Verdigre, Nebraska. This ranch has been in the Kreycik name since July 11, 1898. Lance and Lorie (Kreycik) Knigge have been the owners since October 23, 1998. Currently, there are three major management concerns throughout the property which are identified below.…

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kingsolver’s short essay “Called Out” portrays her fascination with how species of wildflowers managed to withstand Arizona’s harsh desert climate. The Sonoran Desert, usually a rather barren land consisting of dull, lifeless, monochromes, underwent a major transformation as El Nino’s downpours sparked the blossoming of vibrant, ephemeral flowers. Due to the short-lived nature of these plants, they are genetically programed to only blossom under rainy seasons. Unfortunately, Arizona’s deceitful feminine and masculine rains served as a means of trickery into premature blooming among these seeds for the longest time. However, after a millennia of having endured the misleading weather patterns, the seeds began to program for longer dormancy, which…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sam Weston Sociology

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Weston is an ecology and evolutionary biology major from Mansfield, Connecticut. As a former student at EO Smith High School, he came to UConn with a familiarity of campus and the surrounding area, which made the transition process less daunting for him. While he somewhat feared going to school so close to home, he is really making the most of what UConn has to offer and does not feel the need to head home frequently. He is studying ecology and evolutionary biology in the hopes of being able to pursue a career in horticulture in the future. Plants have always been one of Weston’s strongest interests and passions, and in combination with the agricultural programs and extracurriculars on campus, he really feels that he can pursue his interests…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the ecosystems within the property can be classified, the plant species that make up these ecosystems have yet to be reported. If the plant life on this property can be classified, listed and mapped, future questions can be posed and lead to future research concerning this ecosystem and the greater ecosystems of western Montana in general. This study seeks to identify all plant life in the area by (insert methods here). With identification of plants in this area, thorough studies can be made on the interactions between these plants and their…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Common Crupina has been able to invade so much of the West Coast because it can withstand most climates and soil types. The plant grows in large solid groups that can reduce the amount of other grasses and plants in the area. It is very successful because it grows in grasslands and pastures but is repulsive to livestock. Crupina will take over fields that it grows in, it outcompetes the other wild grasses and plants, lowering the biodiversity and in pastures it can destroy the livestocks source of food. In areas with steep slopes such as the canyons in Idaho, the large stands of Crupina could increase erosion.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Dilcher First Woman

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In "First Flower" a group of botanists and paleobotanists reveal how that "abominable mystery" is starting to move towards a solution. NOVA captures images of how they are continuing to inspire new scientific discoveries today. It all begins in northern China, where amidst the country's rich, volcanic conditions for fossil-finding, Professor Sun Ge and his team first unearth the Archaefructus fossil from an ancient lake in a region where dinosaurs once roamed. Sun Ge brings his amazing find to paleobotanist David Dilcher at the University of Florida, who has been hunting for a fossil like this his entire life. There were many evidence used in the film to determine the evolutionary history of flowering plants.…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What Is Thigmotropism?

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Believe it or not, some plants can feel just like us, but even better, thanks to thigmotropism. Thigmotropism is a plant’s way of touching, or feeling. Thigmotropism is one of the tropisms, in which plants use to react with their environments. “Scientifically defined, it is the directional response of a plant organ to touch or physical contact with a solid object (1).” When a plant comes into contact with an object of a solid state, the response is to curl around it.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Botanical Garden Observations On this Wednesday evening at 1800 on October 05, 2016 I am at one of the most prestigious popular hotels on the Las Vegas, NV strip. I am at the botanical garden where a new world is created with flowers and other natural resources to create wonderment for the current season; each season is changed and every year is different. While inside the botanical gardens I first want to soak up my environment with my eyes closed; I can heighten my senses to the various sounds and smells and get a varying perspective on my area. Once I experience the area with my eyes closed for about ten minutes I then want to touch as much as I can and look around.…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays