Animal Liberation By Singer Analysis

Improved Essays
What is the purpose of eating? Is it to enjoy the umami of the food? Is it to become morally correct? Or is it just to satisfy the basic body needs to survive? Singer’s “Animal Liberation” seeks to end the discrimination of nonhuman animals, especially the consumption of them, based on the vegan ideal that advocates a diet with no animal suffering and cruelty. Pace to Singer’s belief, Kathryn Paxton George, in her article “Discrimination and Bias in the Vegan Ideal”, argues that the vegan ideal discriminates those who are not in the “male physiological norm” (21). Indeed, human consumption of nonhuman animals undoubtedly causes animal suffering and cruelty, however, labeling humans as moral or immoral based on their food choice is discriminatory …show more content…
Individuals in different stages of life have more limited food sources that further forbid them from being moral. Those individuals consume nonhuman animals not because they want to be cruel or immoral, but rather just to satisfy what their body needs in order to survive and develop. Some could argue that humans can choose to be morally correct, survive, and maintain a healthy body by becoming vegans, however, only a relative group of “adult, middle-class males living in industrialized countries” is suitable for those diets (Singer 8, George 19). Singer has claimed that cultivating soybeans “can produce far more protein per acre,” thus eliminate those physical and economic obstacles (8). While Singer’s claim is debatable, he seems to be neglecting the fact that humans also need other types of nutrient to survive and develop. The vegan ideal would hinder “women, children, the aged, and others” who “have substantially different nutritional requirements” physically (George 19). The Human Energy Requirements lists the different nutrients needed to survive and develop for people in different stages of life; some stages, such as infancy, require more certain nutrients than adults. As a matter of fact, vegan infants and toddler often lack essential nutrients for body development, such as “vitamins D and vitamin B12, iron, calcium, and zinc” (qtd. in George 25). This …show more content…
Animals, including humans, extract energy from food to supply its body with the nutrients to survive and function. While individuals with different body types can find the vegan ideal extremely difficult, those living in some developing countries might not even have the option to be vegan due to limits on food resource, technology, and economy. No matter what diet a person chooses to have, the final goal for the person should be to consume whatever is available that can satisfy his or her nutritional needs in order to survive and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Vegan Lifestyle Essay

    • 1736 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Vegans also may think weight loss will be automatic or will make a person healthier, but that is not the case. A Vegan lifestyle will not be the best because vegans are not getting the nutrients they need, vegans are having to pay close attention to their diet, vegans are not automatically making the body healthier by the diet and vegans are losing the benefits in meat. Vegans are not getting the nutrients they need. There are many nutrients in meat that vegans are…

    • 1736 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Why Is Veganism Wrong

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The vegan diet originated from spiritual values, differing than the reasons of present day people. When people make the change from eating meat to eating plants, some diet plans can become insubstantial for nutrient intake. Nutrients like proteins and vitamins convert to energy, but if the body contains less than average values of nutrients, it will produce less energy. Having less energy throughout the day is bad for the body. Some parents of children and pets convert to Veganism, but if their vegan diet pushes onto their loved ones, they can suffer from malnourishment and expensive medical bills in life.…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To delve more into the controversy of veganism, many people argue that vegan diets do not include enough of the essential nutrients. Vegans diets lack Vitamin B12 which is found in meat products, so it must be supplemented regularly as it may cause megaloblastic anemia. Vitamin B12 is especially vital during pregnancy. It is also difficult for vegans to consume…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Veganism Vs Vegetarianism

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages

    They’re food of course! Vegetarianism and veganism are wrong because meat is necessary for a human’s diet, it is costly and unethical to distribute vegetarian meals, and animals are on the earth for the benefit of humans and it is more than okay to eat them. Although vegetarian diets seem to be an enlightened idea to help the planet and ease suffering worldwide, this just isn’t true. The side effects of this decision outway and counteract the very issues that they try to solve as well as cause a multitude of other problems. A well known medical journal, WebMD, proves that purely vegetarian diets are harmful to all human bodies.…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For instance, high protein foods are present from meat, but vegetarians have to get their essential amino acids from another source to maintain a balanced diet (Anisman-Reiner). Because of the deficiency in certain food groups, one’s health can be negatively impacted. It is extremely difficult for vegetarians to get fuel from food in order for the body to function due the scarce food groups they can choose from. Consumption of necessary nutrients for one 's body is challenging for…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Much like "strict vegan diet is mainly to support their mission of preventing cruel treatment of animals"(Kim), Kim addresses the revelation that outside factors do affect the vegan diet support. This allows for the idea that health is not taken in to consideration when campaigning for a strict vegetarian diet thus providing little basis for changing ones diet. Kim states "will be persuaded to follow a strict vegan diet if they believe it is for their health than if it 's for the welfare of animals"(Kim) in support of the notion that health is not the main focus and leads to the question is the saving of animals worth the detriment to our own…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Research Paper On Veganism

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Veganism is the lifestyle of “health and purity”, or so it is raved to be. But once one takes the strict way of life too far the situation becomes all too dangerous. Over obsessiveness within the diet from recovering patients allows for disorders to be maintained or perhaps, become even worse. Veganism is a variety of vegetarian diet that eliminates meat, eggs, dairy foodstuffs and all additional animal-derived ingredients. Many vegans as well do not eat foods that are processed using animal products, for instance refined white sugar in addition to some wines (vegetarian).…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Would We Be Healthier with a Vegan Diet?” scientist, Nancy Rodriguez, responds to Campbell that vegans lack vital nutrients. She states, “Individuals who stop eating meat and dairy products are at risk of not getting enough calcium, vitamin D, protein, vitamin B12 and iron in their diets.” Her statement implies a biased response because she fails to include people can obtain these nutrients through non-animal food. The vitamin B12 can come in supplement form and also in fortified plant milks, cereals, and even organic fruit lightly covered dirt. Also green vegetables contain excellent sources of calcium, iron, vitamin A, C, and K. Vitamin D easily comes from the sun. Plants provide efficient amounts of nutrients because their composition comes from nature that fuels health and…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A vegan diet is not necessarily healthier because of possible deficiencies, unhealthy vegan lifestyle, and inconsistent data. In the decision to avoid animal products, vegans are narrowing their ability for getting many different nutrients and opening up possibilities for various deficiencies. (Concrete Detail)Vegans were found to have more bone fractures because of the likeliness of calcium and vitamin K deficiencies. Calcium is harder to find and harder to absorb from plants. Also, Vitamin K2 is very hard for vegans to obtain…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ethical reasons behind embracing the veganism culture involve the exploitation of animals. Vegans believe that it is unethical to consume animal body parts or use them for clothing or any other household items. The torture and killing of animals for any reason, be it for research purposes, entertainment, or for its products is against veganism. As such, vegans feel guilt when eating animal products or meat coming from animals that have been killed or tortured. They believe that it is ethically wrong for people to put their welfare or the desire for animal products over the well-being of the animal.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays