Argumentative Essay: Disappearing Native Languages

Superior Essays
Disappearing Native Languages
The Native community also faces the problem of their languages nearing extinction. Researchers have predicted that all 150 remaining Native American languages will go extinct within 50 to 100 years (Krauss pp.12). However, it is not too late to counteract this prediction. The United States is the “motherland” for these languages, so if they disappear from the United States they are gone forever. When a language disappears, it takes an unsalvageable chunk of the culture along with it. In Native American Language Immersion, Janine Top notes that “Every language loss causes serious damage to individual and group identity, for it destroys a sense of self-worth, limits human potential and complicates efforts to solve
…show more content…
Until recently, the general population viewed bilingualism negatively due to misconceptions and misleading studies. For example, in the 1950s, N.T Darcy conducted an experiment, which concluded that being bilingual resulted in lower IQ scores and a “language handicap.” The study was majorly flawed; for example, it did not take into account the socioeconomic status of the participants, and it based a participant’s bilingual status on their parents’ birth countries rather than their language proficiency (Hakuta, K pp320). Unfortunately, as a result, bilingualism became attached with negative connotations around the United States. Many people attributed the Native peoples’ poor performance in school with the fact that they were bilingual (Luning, 9). Due to these studies, the English language began to dominate in the United States.
Anti-bilingualism mind-sets along with anti-immigrant movements, pushed for propositions such as California’s prop 227 and Arizona’s prop 203 which severely restricted bilingual education and encouraged English only education **cite maybe. The state of Native languages today is due to the deliberate restrictions and efforts taken to strip Native Americans of their languages and not any fault of the Native Americans
…show more content…
The target language is approached as a medium of instruction rather than as subject matter. Even when the students finally begin learning English, their English class is taught in the Native language. A common misconception about immersion language programs is that the students learn a new language at the expense of English, however, that is a different concept called submersion. In submersion programs, students attend classes in a foreign language with students already fluent in that language, while in immersion programs all the students are new to the language and because of this the curriculum is adjusted accordingly. Immersion programs are a unique yet effective approach to teaching students a heritage

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    General racism, environmental devastation, and poverty on Indian reservations makes it burdensome for many Native people to live according to their traditions. As many are simply trying to survive daily life, they do not have the energy, money, or time to be taught and teach their indigenous languages and cultures. For some Native peoples, their very survival is dependent on preserving their language and particular ways of life. While it does seem that some languages and cultures are in danger of being exclusive to history, it is a surprising fact to many that many Native groups have a very diverse original language and many cultural customs. With the supremacy of European-American cultural and economic identities, it is astounding to see the perseverance of these sustained livelihoods adapt and remain feasible in the middle of constantly-changing social change.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Suddenly, America has become extremely diverse, and with the array of languages forming from that, it would be unprecedented to think that every person can speak English. Two authors, Martin Espada and Richard Rodriguez discuss the issues and challenges towards bilingualism. “The new bathroom policy at english high school “ by Martin Espada and “Hunger of Memory” by Richard Rodriguez, each have opposing views on the same topics involving languages. Ranging from political issues to social/ family issues, these essays cover them all.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many Americans ascribe to the belief that America represents a “melting pot” of cultures. With so many differing cultures in this country, America would be expected to have a high bilingual population and large support for bilinguals’ rights. However, America is only about 20% bilingual (source). This low bilingual percentage accounts for Americans’ general lack of empathy for bilingual people and their rights. Two bilingual authors, Martin Espada and Richard Rodriguez, portray contrasting perspectives about the issue of bilingualism in America by addressing the meaning of bilingualism, bilingual education, and discrimination against bilinguals.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Learning others’ languages and becoming one with nature could bring us together. I believe it is important that we as a society acknowledge native languages; the native dialect is more important than people think. For native tribes, language is everything to them. It’s a way of communication, and a huge part of their culture. Without it, future generations will lose connectivity to their ancestors.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All students of the American education system should be fluent English speakers. Martin Espada and Richard Rodriguez, two revered essay writers both possess conflicting opinions about how bilingualism should be handled. Espada believes that language has ties to culture, and they should all be preserved; however, Rodriguez’s view of bilingualism is more methodical, he thinks learning the language used for public communication is the most beneficial method, regardless of any cultural ties that may be abandoned. Martin Espada’s view of bilingualism can be explained through his usage of a metaphorical analogy, wherein his essay he wrote, “English and Spanish are like two dogs I love. English is an obedient dog.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ethnicity plays a long part in the worlds history and contentiously has negative effects our society. Everyone in their culture group has some kind of viewpoint on a different culture group from theirs. Which could cause some problems for both sides getting the wrong idea on how one ethnic group acts different than the other ethnic group. The way most people see how a few, or a couple of people from the a different culture act, say in a negative way, then they my start to think that is how that ethnic group act as a whole. Though that may not be the case.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Creole Lens

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages

    While there is no official language in the United States, English is used throughout the country. This leads nearly every American down a path that requires them to learn and speak at least some English. However, the roots of America lie in immigrants coming to the country for a chance at a new start. Therefore, multiple languages, whether dominant or minor, should be viewed as an example of what makes America what it is. These languages should not be purged in favor of English, but preserved in order for future generations to garner an understanding of the various cultures and ideologies that go along with different languages.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Language is much more than a means of communication, it is something that not only contains the understandings of a person’s culture and connection to the land, but it also plays an essential role in maintaining one’s well-being, self-esteem and more importantly, their sense of identity. In addition, with regard to Indigenous Australians, language plays a significant role in their culture and history; however, since colonization there has been a significant decline in indigenous languages. This issue will be further discussed through examining the causes and background factors to this issue, looking at the various stakeholder perspectives, analysing the current strategies and options in place to resolve this issue and finally, formulating recommendations that could further improve this issue.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indian Boarding Schools

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In six hundred years only traces of three languages in the world as we know it will remain. Everyone will be forced to learn a new, alien language, and be punished for using any language of the old world. Individual cultures will be lost, and generalized, as the world’s languages die out one by one. This is what happened to most Native languages through colonization and westward expansion. Three native languages are “expected to survive into the middle of this Century”3.…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the 1960’s several factors allowed very little opportunities to bring back bilingual education (Baker,2001). The Bilingual Education Act of 1968, has been one of the most important act throughout the history of Bilingual Education. (Mazanares, 1988), stated that the act is seen as one of the first official federal recognition of the needs and rights of students with limited English speaking abilities. The act has gone through four reauthorizations, 1974,1978,1984 and 1988, with amendments based on a change for students and society. Senator Ralph Yarborough introduced a bill in 1967, the bill proposed to assist schools with the incorporation of Educational programs for LESA students.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disadvantages Of Latinos

    • 178 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Hispanic faces similar disadvantages as other minorities in America. Hispanic face similar issues like quality of schools, funding, and completion of schools. According to the Office of Civil Rights Data Collection for 2006 (Civil Rights Data Collection 2012), racial and ethnic minority students composed the following percentages of the school-aged population Hispanic make up 17 %. Educational disparities are the result of structural, cultural, and individual factors.…

    • 178 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    is so far behind in advancements academically and socially. Every other country encourages and supports bilingual education. In each claim and argument Rodriguez presents there are harmful consequences that the reader takes away from them. He believes that one’s native language and the public language are unable to coincide, not based on research or statistics, merely based on his own personal experience with not being able to handle the two. The takeaway from this belief is that there should only be one language in America, the public language.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Oftentimes, people who speak more than one language are seen as intelligent and resourceful. They may receive comments such as, “Wow, that’s so difficult! I could never do that!” But to bilingual individuals, the ability to speak two languages is barely scraping the bottom of the barrel. Two bilingual authors by the names of Martín Espada and Richard Rodriguez have plenty to say about their definition of what bilingualism truly is.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Richard Rodriguez believes that the Americanization of a bilingual child will result in their public gain. “Aria” by Richard Rodriguez is a heart-wrenching piece of writing about the full Americanization of Rodriguez resulting in his native language of Spanish being forgotten and the full submersion into the English language. Many of the events Rodriguez faced in his life are present to many other bilingual students’ today. These events that bilingual students’ are facing will strongly influence their decision on struggling to learn two languages at a young age, stalling the development of one of their languages, or being forced to choose one language or the other in a full assimilation. Rodriguez’s viewpoint is that if you want to make a full…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Language immersion is a method of teaching language, usually a second language, in which the target language is used as both the content of the curriculum and the medium of instruction. According to Baker (2006; cited by: Pacific Policy Research Center, 2010), there are three major levels of language immersion education divided according to age: • early immersion, from age 5 or 6, • middle immersion, from age 9 or 10, and • late immersion, from ages 11 and 14. In programs that make use of immersion language education, learners may enter and commence studies at different ages and different levels. Research (cited by: Pacific Policy Research Center, 2010) shows that early immersion in a second language yields better results than late…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays