This results, according to the detractors, in both groups of students falling behind academically. While this assessment might be true for the first couple of years, data suggests that “in the long term, the short-term negative effects are more than overturned by the positive effects on test score growth” (Valentino & Reardon, p. 15). This means, if given enough time to develop their language skills, both NES and ELL students have been found to meet or outperform their mainstream peers by fourth or fifth grade. While it might be difficult to usher in a change in perspective to allow students this space to grow, acknowledging the long-term focus of TWI programs is key to recognizing and benefiting from their
This results, according to the detractors, in both groups of students falling behind academically. While this assessment might be true for the first couple of years, data suggests that “in the long term, the short-term negative effects are more than overturned by the positive effects on test score growth” (Valentino & Reardon, p. 15). This means, if given enough time to develop their language skills, both NES and ELL students have been found to meet or outperform their mainstream peers by fourth or fifth grade. While it might be difficult to usher in a change in perspective to allow students this space to grow, acknowledging the long-term focus of TWI programs is key to recognizing and benefiting from their