Genetically Modified Organisms: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
During the last decade Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) have increasingly become a topic of mixed viewpoints. Do GMOs actually help or are they harming our ecosystem? Scientists and large corporations attempt to persuade consumers to support their conflicting perspectives. Regardless of the studies, the world continues to face a high probability of food scarcity. Companies like Monsanto, lead efforts to industrialize and streamline our food source, but many argue that it is at the expense of safe, healthy food choices for consumers. Additionally, many argue that Monsanto controls almost all seed patents and are pushing small farmers out of business leaving few alternatives to GMO foods. Ultimately, the world continues to populate at …show more content…
He believes that each side has taken an all or nothing stance comparing “apples and oranges.” On the contrary, Joel Edwards, a writer for Natural News, disagrees and believes that studies currently provide information performed by Biotech companies and the industry itself. He doubts Biotech funded research provides reliable information and that independent studies show the conflicting argument and are studied longer than their counterparts. Johnson stresses that GMOS cannot be a monolithic entity, but rather should be evaluated on their specific purpose and use for consumers and animals. Edwards reasons that Biotech companies have enlisted big name celebrity scientists such as, Bill Nye the Science Guy and Neil deGrasse, to subdue society and promote the idea that critics cause “irrational fears” toward GMOs for consumers. Mark Lynas, an environmental activist and journalist, tries to explain that the controversy and “conspiracy theories” lead to large deaths in third world countries due to misinformation produced by anti-GMO supporters. Being an anti-GMO supporter himself in the early nineties, he has watched the US come into an age of “increasingly threatening ecological scarcity.” Lynas believes that “we cannot afford the luxury of romanticized but inefficient agricultural systems,” and would like to see conspiracy theories die and become “the dustbin of history” where they belong. Edwards cannot support an idea system that won’t allow for growth, he wants “to change the way we do agriculture,” and suggests that we need the “overwhelming majority of us demanding change in order for the change to

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Monsanto Pros And Cons

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The reason could be that genetically modified crops and its “dose” of Round-Up Ready do result with many negative effects as well as possibly being the start to all food security problems due to its recent discovery and insubstantial safety verifications. Most consumers are left in the dark when it comes to genetically modified foods, creating a misconception towards these companies as well as the government who support them (Barrett). Obviously, the United States government is left cornered and allows Monsanto and the such to take control and force them into supporting their business with genetic…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gmo Myth Or Fact

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages

    However it does show that modified crops are the lifeline to people in other parts of the world. Many people believe activists, by pushing to outlaw or put stricter laws on modified foods, are trying to protect consumers. That may be the sole reason driving some people to protest. However, the underlying reason some object to genetic engineering is because the technology used to create these organisms is managed by a small number of companies. They are afraid of something so transparent as the food supply being controlled by a trickle of companies.…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Since GMOs (or genetically modified organisms) were introduced in the mid-1990s, allergies and other health problems including reproductive disorders and autism have been escalating. Time and time again, genetically modified foods have been presented as being “the same” as their organic counterparts, so that the labeling of them in unnecessary, but the facts seem to sing a different song. Genetically modifying foods has been praised for the impressive number of crops the practice yields with the use of “harmless” biotechnology. But as you will soon discover, GMOs are anything but harmless. Although it may appear beneficial to some, America should not continue production of genetically modified crops and livestock because of the negative effects…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is hard for the consumers to tell the regular foods and GM foods apart. If they put labels in their food products, people with allergies and who are oppose for GMOs could easier avoid their foods that might put them in jeopardy. For instance, Gary Hirshberg is the chairman of Stonyfield, the organic yogurt company, who think that is not fair and right. On October, he partnered with Just Label It, a national coalition of nearly 450 organizations that currently petitioning the FDA to give consumers a choice. (Mount) Though, after many suggestions and elections to vote on banning GMOs or labelling laws, it is almost impossible to stop the production of GM foods since Genetically Modified Organisms are so widespread in the food industry.…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Genetically Modified Organisms or GMO’s are a huge topic in today’s world. Although GMO’s have been around for the last few decades, it hasn’t been until recently that people are more concerned about the possible negative consequences/effects. GMO’s are organisms that are altered through genetic engineering so the DNA of the organism has one or more new genes when produced. This usually increases the quality and/or quantity of a product/organism and a few other factors. Many people are concerned on whether or not GMOs are actually beneficial for society, and are questioning if big corporations such as Monsanto should continue pushing genetically modified crops and animals to our people.…

    • 1611 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While fossil fuel pollution is becoming an increasing problem, the population of the planet is suffering. GMO farmers are working terrible jobs while not making enough money to live. Similarly, consumers are being affected simply by eating GMO by-products. GMO will never be gone forever, but increasing the amount of GMO crops produced will cause far greater problems than just planting natural, organic plants. Foods may need to travel greater distances to reach their destination while increasing fossil fuel consumption, but it’s a sacrifice we must make in order to keep the population of the planet…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Monsanto is seen as an overbearing monolithic enterprise whose interests include making as much money as possible without any thought to potential consequences. The opponents of genetically modified organisms argue against the use of GMOs using three main assertions: GMOs pose an environmental hazard, there are potential human health risks, and that GMO promoting corporations tend to be the largest recipients of American agricultural subsidies – thus harming society both physically and economically. While many anti-GMO organizations tend to be relatively small and fragmented, at times there are countries that participate in similar anti-GMO sentiment. In 2011, Hungary mandated that all seeds had to be checked for genetic modification before being placed onto the market. From 2011 to 2015, Hungary destroyed thousands of fields of genetically modified corn in order to demonstrate their hostile feelings towards GMOs and Monsanto in particular.…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    GMO brought many problems, such as biotech companies used GMO as a tool to control the market and farmers who brought their seeds, GM farming ignored the complete and round development of agricultural industry, and GMO could not prove itself as an incredible safe product. Even though there have many people said GMO cut the use of pesticide and help to improve the environment, more and more new researches showed that these ideas are all wrong. Thus, consumers who do not know much about GMO should be careful when buying any products that contain GMO. Also, the government should take responsibility to help people know GMO, set more regulation to ensure the safety of GMO, and supervise the process of technology of developing…

    • 1677 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    GM Foods Are Risky “What are GMO’s?” is one question the public should be asking. Most foods people consume on a daily basis consist of at least one GMO ingredient. Genetically modified organisms are foods that have been altered in a science lab and have been manipulated into resisting threats, such as pesticides (Roundup Ready) and certain weather. Scientists do genetic engineering, in which DNA is taken from another organism and placed into the crop they want altered. GMOs are harming people 's health, environment, and bees.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As responsible technological citizens, we can initiate GMF labeling by demanding that large corporations start labeling their genetically modified food. Some ways we could demand labelling of genetically engineered products are through protests, laws and regulations. We could protest GMFs outside the vast corporations that support and fund research on genetically modified foods. We could also petition to get laws and/ or regulations to put an end to genetically engineered foods. These tactics can even result in the end of genetically engineered food because we could argue that GMOs/ GMFs aren’t beneficial to anyone, except for the large corporations that are making millions out of them.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays