What Is The Similarities Between Primary And Secondary Components?

Analogy is greatly related to legal reasoning on many levels. The first being "The more relevant the similarities between primary and secondary analogues, the stronger the argument." (pg 527) As with legal reasoning, cases are based upon similarities. Let 's say Pole, a non-organic strawberry company, is being sued for claiming their product is "just as healthy as organic strawberries." Pole 's defense is that their strawberries look the same, smell the same and most importantly are the same species, so they must be just as healthy as any organic brand.
Not only for the purpose of the case, but also for the verdict "According to the requirement of precedent, similar cases must be decided similarly." (pg 527) By having two or more cases with similar evidence and circumstances it makes the case stronger and increases the chances of winning. "The greater number of similarities between primary and secondary analogues, the stronger the argument." (pg 527) In this case, the client is suing for misrepresentation of the product because, although the product looks the same, smells the same and is the same species, there are adverse effects of non-organic strawberries. Since other cases have been won for the misrepresentation of a product, …show more content…
If, on the other hand, the client is simply asking for the company to remove their label "Our strawberries are just as healthy organic!" the client will most likely win, as the company probably can 't prove that their strawberries are truly better for your health than