Difference Between Traditional Student And Disciplinary Expert

Superior Essays
1.) The differences between a “traditional student” and a “disciplinary expert,” according to Howard Gardner is, a “traditional student”, or someone who has an inherited or long-established way of thinking or learning is defined by Gardner as a scholastic learner or a “youngster from age seven to age twenty, who seeks to master the literacies, concepts, and disciplinary forms of the school”, and one who Gardner explain “respond in ways similar to preschool or primary school youngsters” exhibited outside of the classroom (Gardner p. 7). A “disciplinary expert”, or someone who is involved in a regimen that improves or develops their skills. According to Gardner that expert is a skilled person or, “an individual of any age who has mastered the concepts and skills of a discipline or domain and can apply such knowledge appropriately in new situations”, and these experts have the ability to use the knowledge learned in classrooms, and apply it to real world …show more content…
Gardner summarizes the differences between a “traditional student” and a “disciplinary expert” as the disciplinary expert truly understands the knowledge of what they read and are tested on. On the other hand, Garder says a “traditional student” is one who respond with atypical responses, and their knowledge is general instead of having an in-depth understanding like the “disciplinary expert”. Gardner emphasizes tremendous problems in learning, or the gap between the disciplinary expert and the traditional expert by citing cognitive research that reveals students of the traditional background and those who are esteemed, “do not successfully transfer their knowledge to new settings”, and therefore lack the understanding to realize their knowledge is naïve in that their understandings are preconceived ideas of what they learned during early childhood. Experts as Gardner put it “amassed evidence” to understand the Flat Earth Theory, while a traditional student would assume without analyzing what the evidence

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    "I began to learn the rudiments, weigh different kinds of evidence, move between particulars and generalization, summarize the views of others, and enter a conversation about ideas” (Graff 201). The reasoning here being that through his own “street smart” experience, Graff benefited and acquired enough communication skills to enter a conversation and keep his argument throughout. As a result of these conversations with his friends, Graff believes that “street smart” get the better of “books smart”, in the sense that being “street smart” the student is the center of the knowledge rather than the “book smart” where the student is trying to absorb the subject’s point of view on a certain issue. A “street smart” student will have the advantage for being through arguments and tested his idea and can bank on it if needed in the future; instead the “book smart” student will have to keep referring to someone else’s…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    John Scopes Case Study

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Parties Involved in the Case The parties involved in the case were John Scopes, Clarence Darrow, William Jennings Bryan, and John Raulston (Linder, 2008). John Scopes was a young high school biology who was found to be guilty of violation. Clarence Darrow was a successful lawyer who defended scopes (Linder, 2008).…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A college education is an important stepping stone in many students lives. What is a college education though, and how do you get one? In the article “How to Get a College Education” Jeffrey Hart, Professor at Dartmouth University, he argues his own opinion on the experience and struggle of today's students working to achieve an education after high school. He also goes on to talk about what he believes should be the goal of a further education.…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Science is not a body of facts. Science is a state of mind” (Angier 490). Both essays, “The Canon” by Natalie Angier and “Scientific Literacy and the Habit of Discourse” by Thomas W. Martin, discuss that science is not a set of facts to be learned, but is best practiced through actions. These two articles approach the topic differently by using different rhetorical modes and styles. Even though the article’s main points have similarities, the essays contain many differences through their rhetorical modes, approaches, and writing styles.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Highly unlikely, but not outside the realm of possibility”-David Duchovny. This familiar phrase from the popular nineties television show “The X-Files” manifested itself in my mind when reading the article that profoundly influenced the University of Central Arkansas’ Honors Program, Peter Elbow’s abridged version of “The Doubting Game and the Believing Game—An Analysis of the Intellectual Enterprise (Excerpts)”. Though on a much more theatrical and improbable level, this show relates to the Honors curriculum and Elbow’s paper with the same basic, parallel theme: doubt verses belief. In keeping this mindset, we can see: how Elbow’s proposal differs from “critical thinking” today, what can be assumed about the nature of truth and human intellectual…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a 2007 article for Educational Leadership, “The Essential Cognitive backpack” Mel Levine argues that high school graduates are missing the necessary “gear that ought to find its way into every graduates cognitive backpack”(17). In his article, Levine explains in four main sections what he calls “The four I’s [of his essential cognitive backpack…] Interpretation, Instrumentation, Interaction, and Inner Direction.”(17). In Levine’s first section of the article “Interpretation”, Levine begins his argument with an anecdote about a student who is struggling in college because in high school she depended on her good memorization skills rather than understanding concepts as a whole.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whether at a job, at home, or in between, any experience can be just as educational as a class at a university. In “Blue Collar Brilliance”, the author, Mike Rose, uses anecdotes from his family’s experiences to prove how although his family members might not have had much formal education, they all were “intelligent” due to the lessons they learned at work. Given my family’s own experience, I can attest to that. Throughout all of the generations of my family, half have attended a traditional university, while the others went to work or had a different experience, some even had both.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 2014 article, “Why Scientists Should Embrace the Liberal Arts,” former Cornell president, David J. Skorton, argues that scientists need to find a better way to communicate their knowledge with the public. Skorton mentions that the general public often has a difficult time believing what scientists try to tell them because they cannot comprehend their jargon. He believes this is happening because scientists lack the skills and education needed to effectively communicate their ideas to the public. Overall, the main goal of Skorton’s article is to display the disconnect between the public and scientists. Based on the content of the paper we can infer that Skorton’s targeted audience is not only educators and scientists, but also the general…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tom Nichols, author of The Death of Expertise, effectively conveys his view that the blatant excuses and mindsets of citizens made to ignore the experts of today can have negative impacts on the American culture, as well as touches on how it is impossible to continue this structure without disasters to follow (15). Nichols does this by giving examples of the characteristics of the people who are creating this influence, deeming them “explainers” to which a reader could relate to by thinking of examples in their own lives. (13). He also gives historic context of the problem throughout time to set a foundation of his argument while also touching on how the it has changed to the point where it becomes dangerous. Nichols argument especially becomes…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gerald Graff's work, Hidden Intellectualism, is a display of hidden intellectualism in everyday life. In other words, education does not always come from schooling but is also taught from the world around us on the smallest level. In the article, Graff draws attention to what the typical view of what intelligence is often considered to be and why this is wrong throughout several repeated forms. A key strength of this article is presented right away through the debut.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Within the book, “Doing School” by Denise Pope (Pope, 2001), throughout the students’ years in the education system, all of them learned how to do school, in one form or another. Each student developed their own tricks and trades to deal with issues they were personally facing and to help deal with issues that developed because of their school’s curriculum. As Egan (2001) stated “We all recognize the difference between genuine knowledge and accumulated codes – we talk of education as against training, wisdom as against “book learning”… But our schools are not good either at recognizing the difference or, consequently, promoting the genuine article rather than the counterfeit” (p 930).…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An intellectual is defined as a person who places a high value on or pursues things of interest to the intellect or the more complex forms and fields of knowledge. This definition of an intellectual has been restricted by an educational system to mean indoctrinate students into what the system believes to be “academic”. Gerald Graff’s essay “Hidden Intellectualism” argues that there is knowledge and intelligence beyond what the traditional education system is practicing. Graff contends that incorporating the interests of students into the lesson will help students think more effectively and logically. “Intellectualism” is seen by how well a student does in traditional subjects.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is the issue of students being tied to one way of thinking, and he wants a mixture of both “smarts” to be presented throughout the students academic career. The mixture of book and street smarts has allowed me to graduate highs cool, attend college, maintain a job, and beat the low expectations of those who doubted me. I am surviving both of my…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I. John Dewey’s response to Zuriff Learners do not require a special treatment, but instead, they need to be actively exposed to experimentation (Dewey, 1968). This is because, according to Dewey (1986), the experimentation method does not follow the old education system which is based on the built of a ready-made process, and instead is developed by discovering knowledge on experience (Dewey, 1968). II. John Dewey’s response to Terzi Dewey would respond by supporting the argument of Terzi in that equality should be the term that governs the progression of skills (Dewey, 1968).…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Teach Knowledge, Not “Mental Skills,” author E.D. Hirsch bases his argument on an experience he went through when he was a teacher in public school. He worked with two different principals in the same school. Comparing these two principal, the first principal did not care about what students acquired from their lessons, and the students’ academic performance was really bad. The second principal was more worried about the knowledge and his students’ academic performance. Hirsch argues that school should teach more knowledge instead of mental skills, and American should learning the teaching method of Europe and Asia which have a similar method of core-knowledge; problem-solving skill is important but depend on pertinent knowledge.…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays