Differences And Similarities Between Miner And Chaugnon

Improved Essays
I found that after reading Miner and Chagnon’s articles, I thought it was eye opening to see how the two authors originally expected the two tribes to behave like they were raised even though the tribes are isolated away from the modern world. “The daily ceremonies, like the rites of the holy-mouth-men, involve discomfort and torture” (Miner, 2013, p. 90). How does Miner know that the tribe sees these practices as a discomfort or as torture? Just because in a more modernized society some would see these the practices of the Nacirema as torturous and those such practices would have stopped, but the Indians continue to go to the holy-mouth-man for rites. Chagnon expected a friendlier welcome than what was actually provided for him and in the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Miccosukee Seminole Indian tribe Over 200 years ago, the Miccosukee tribe have been known by its characteristic way of fighting to protect their territory. First, the Spaniards, and then even worse, the Anglo-American who tried to exterminate the Miccosukee’s Indians almost two centuries ago and who eventually left them no other option than to live in a very small place in ancestral areas of the Everglades in Miami. The Indians seeking for a decent style of life had to adapt themselves to sleep in hammocks. Their houses were called “chickees” and were made of wood, plaster, thatched roofs, and perhaps raised on stilts. After all this battle and years of persecution, they started to establish their permanent home and look for a better life…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nacirema Rituals Summary

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As I read the article, I felt sorrow for the Nacirema people. They seemed so unhappy with their appearance. The rituals they endured seemed so cruel and barbaric. However, I quickly realized that these rituals are some of the same ones that we have here in America.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This book discusses the last few years of Chief Joseph’s life, the white people who he knew at that time, and a generalized look into the history of Chief Joseph and the Nez Perces people from 1750 to 1905. It was very interesting how Gidley organized his book, but it was done in a very nice uniformed way that was easy to follow. After reading, it makes sense as to why it was constructed the way it was. This book not only discusses information about Chief Josephs last years but also the white men that were there with him and Meany.…

    • 1804 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “I have left those that I love as my own life behind and risked everything. I want to live easier and do some good.” (Mr. Shufelt p.1) During the time in which Mr. Shufelt was giving his speech, the gold rush was just starting to happen. Sutter’s Mill and the gold rush is located in Coloma, California.…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Body Ritual Among The Nacirema Analysis I believe that the Nacirema practice magical beliefs because they believe that the human body isn’t strong enough on it’s own, and can help it, by using magic to achieve it. They continue to practice it because it is their tradition, and has been apart of their culture for countless years. The overall, “the fundamental belief underlying the whole system appears to be that the human body is ugly and that its natural tendency is to debility and disease.” Due to the fact that humans are susceptible to sickness, the Nacirema believe that with these potions they have created they can ward off demons and sickness.…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are American Indians Lawfully Sinners or Just Uninformed? In chapter six of Francisco De Vitoria’s book, “Vitoria: Political Writings,” titled, On the Americans Indians, Vitoria considers various arguments regarding the dominion of the “barbaric” American Indians by determining if sinners, unbelievers and children as well irrational and mad men should have dominion over property and over themselves. Although I agree with Vitoria’s conclusion that American Indians should be treated as any other Christian (250), in this paper, I will be exploring what constitutes both a sinner and an unbeliever and determine if they are appropriate labels for the American Indians. I believe this is an important argument for the many religious leaders whispering in the crown’s ear; it would inspire them to fight for the opportunity to send more missionaries way sooner, which would have changed the course of history. Vitoria first and foremost, wishes to establish that without consulting other wise men, one cannot be a wise ruler (237).…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nacirema Research Paper

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Would you live among the Nacirema, according to Horace Miner they are a tribe in North America who live their lives believing “the human body is ugly and that it’s natural tendency is to debility and disease”. In order for them to cope they must perform bizarre rituals. Miner states that these ceremonies take up the majority of their daily lives and that they seems to even range as torturous. Miner first speaks of the shrine in which varies in different household. Those who are rich have stone walled shrines while those who come from a poorer family imitate the rich with pottery plaques.…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Northwest Coast Beliefs

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The Natives of the Northwest Coast beliefs, customs, and history were passed down via word through songs, dances and stories. They told stories about certain things had occurred in their society, such as, changes in the seasons. Also, they addressed via stories how each group had first appeared into this word stories that were passed down from generation to generation subsequently. Believing they were surrounded, at all times, by interference of supernatural beings in the natural world. Spirits were connected to all living things in their culture.…

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the ethnography “Doing Fieldwork among the Yanomamö” by Napoleon Chagnon, it is apparent that these anthropological tools are apparent in his case study of this primitive society. The tool of emic perspective is seen when Chagnon discusses the custom of aggression for the Yanomamö, a key behavior in their interpersonal politics and social interactions. The Yanomamö use aggression constructively, a behavior that we view as being somewhat taboo. Their cultural lens is shaped to encourage aggression, and without it, a person interacting with their culture is viewed as a distinct outsider. The etic perspective behind this aggression is to ensure that male members of their society have the self-confidence and strength to embody this aggressive…

    • 1023 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cabeza De Vaca Analysis

    • 1255 Words
    • 5 Pages

    However, compared to Cabeza de Vaca’s observation, she was fortunate that her wounded daughter was not left behind to die. The Indians were actually being merciful to the child. During Cabeza de Vaca 's captivity, he learned the customs and structure of each tribe while he is their captive. He described the Indian rituals of death as if they are not barbarous, but generous, supportive and sympathetic during their time of mourning.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The etic perspective will help interpret my own culture from an outsider’s point of view. An article that helps as a guide to understanding culture from different perspectives is the article Body Ritual Among the Nacirema by Miner (1956). In this article, he describes the culture and practices of the Nacirema, which is American spelled backwards. While reading this article some might notice that the practices sound familiar but may not be able to put a finger on why. Looking at culture from an etic perspective provides understanding and shows how caught up one can be with thinking that their culture is the norm.…

    • 1947 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some of these rituals include a daily mouth-rite, visits to the holy mouth men, and visits to the latipso if they are sick. Through this essay, the author uses repetition to help get his point across. He uses the word Nacirema to help readers distinguish the culture that these people are from. He also uses this word a large amount of times to help familiarize the readers with it and also help them figure out that Nacirema is actually American spelled backwards.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Power has the ability to overcome and make anyone in its way obsessed with having it. Power can turn even the best, most moral people into people full of greed and hate. In Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe, the Ibo tribe is becoming oppressed and disrespected by the arrival of Christian Missionaries. Achebe shows us through the imprisonment of the tribe leaders and the forcing of the Missionary 's government onto the tribe that a thirst for power can destroy and break things apart. When the Christians first came to Umuofia, they only brought a religion.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The use of specific accounts, while individually could be disregarded as anomalies from the general “ecological Indian”, collectively, describe a variety of cultures each with their own pressures and resources. On the plains, communities revolved around the buffalo because of the abundance and relative ease in hunting it, however, fires, drought, preference for cows as opposed to bulls, competition from horses and the consumer market brought by the colonizers placed strain on the communities and their main resource until it was all but depleted (Krech 138-141). In the south, deer was an important resource similar in value to the plains buffalo alongside agriculture and gathering (Krech, 154). However, similar to the narrative in the plains, with the introduction of the consumer market, hunting outside of basic need became common, reducing population sizes faster than they could recover and forcing longer travel for successful hunts which resulted in increased interactions with other tribes leading to a higher reliance on guns for conflicts meaning the tribes had to collect more hides to purchase these weapons (Krech, 158-161). Even in the example of the Piegan tribe, who “paid little attention to the trade until just before the annual trip to the post” (Krech 142), which the author uses to contend that the consumer market colonizers brought to…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article Body Ritual among the Nacirema by Horace Miner is about culture and rituals. Culture is defined as “a system of ideas, values, beliefs, knowledge, norms, customs, and technology shared by almost everyone in a particular society” (Basirico, Cashion, and Eshleman 99). In other words, it’s a way of life in society or a specific geographical area. According to the author, Nacirema is between the Canadian Cree, the Yaqui, and Tarahumare of Mexico, which offer the readers some insight of the true meaning of the text.…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays