Strategy plays a crucial role in determining the success or failure of a battle. Allied soldiers were thrown into the middle of a battlefield with the purpose of failure on their minds. Brigadier General Forbes West, who was taken and held prisoner during the raid once stated "I feel that from the day planning began, it was intended to be a failure." Unfortunately, West was not the only troop from this operation that went into it knowing that it would fail. The Generals left in charge of planning the raid had only declared it with the motive of gaining knowledge for the future battle of D-day in 1944. In Arthur Kelly's article, it is stated that "the brutality of August 19, 1942 is contrasted by the kindness bestowed upon the raid since, namely its designation as 'a rehearsal' for D-Day. The lessons supposedly learned from the disastrous attack are easily refuted, yet are routinely used as justification for the raid." It therefore appears that it was widely accepted that Dieppe was clearly a suicide mission, and the only way to somehow justify the doomed raid, was to claim it yielded valuable information which led to the
Strategy plays a crucial role in determining the success or failure of a battle. Allied soldiers were thrown into the middle of a battlefield with the purpose of failure on their minds. Brigadier General Forbes West, who was taken and held prisoner during the raid once stated "I feel that from the day planning began, it was intended to be a failure." Unfortunately, West was not the only troop from this operation that went into it knowing that it would fail. The Generals left in charge of planning the raid had only declared it with the motive of gaining knowledge for the future battle of D-day in 1944. In Arthur Kelly's article, it is stated that "the brutality of August 19, 1942 is contrasted by the kindness bestowed upon the raid since, namely its designation as 'a rehearsal' for D-Day. The lessons supposedly learned from the disastrous attack are easily refuted, yet are routinely used as justification for the raid." It therefore appears that it was widely accepted that Dieppe was clearly a suicide mission, and the only way to somehow justify the doomed raid, was to claim it yielded valuable information which led to the