Analysis Of Yali's Question By Jared Diamond

Great Essays
1.One of the most commonly espoused answers to “Yali’s Question” is that there is a biological difference among different groups of people, or that Europeans are just superior to other races. Jared Diamond proves this wrong by stating that human differences in intelligence is caused by the difference in technology, that on average modern day people who live in the “Stone Age” are probably more intelligent than industrialized people. Another common answer to “Yali’s Question” is that Europeans were able to use technology. Jared Diamond addresses this by explaining the difference in technology between Yali’s people and Europeans. He refutes this by saying that when given the chance or opportunity primitive people are able to master technology. …show more content…
The first advantage is the perfect climate that the Fertile Crescent has. Another advantage of the fertile crescent is that is was already abundant in crops that were highly productive. The final advantage of the Fertile Crescent is that it was one of the first sights that developed writing. Jared Diamond explains that it was europe spreading culture rather than Southeast Asia by stating that Southeast Asia didn’t have great communication with the outside world. Europeans on the other hand spreaded crops in the New …show more content…
He explains that only a specific number of animals can be domesticated because they are the best animals to use. He also explains how the number of animals that were domesticable was different among different groups of people. The modern failure to domesticate the Eland show us that sometimes it’s the species shortcoming rather than the humans trying to domesticate them.

13.The Anna karenina principle is that it helps explain how domestication works by using the concept of marriage. It explains that there are 6 factors that determine if an animal is domesticable: Diet, Growth rate, Problems of captive breeding, Common panic attacks, and social order. The Anna karenina also helps explain why some regions had better advantages than others. For example it helps explain why Eurasia was able to domesticate the cow, while South Africa couldn’t domesticate the buffalo. Or why the cheetah the fastest land mammal was unable to be

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the book, Diamond states his beliefs that the success of a society is not based on intelligence and ingenuity but instead on geography, food production, germs and immunity, the domestication of animals, and the discovery and use of steel. He successfully demonstrates this by comparing the different societies that come from the same ancestand explaining the characteristics that made the Europeans more successful. Diamond explains that it has nothing to do with Europeans genes or being more intellectual but instead it…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mesopotamia DBQ

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages

    1. In the Old Stone Age animals were hunted and fished for food and the skins were used for clothing. In the Middle Stone Age animals were domesticated. In the New Stone Age they raised animals and learned to weave baskets, make clothing from plant fibers and wool, and make clay pots. 2.…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mesopotamia Dbq

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Mesopotamia and Egypt Essay From 3500 BC-2000 AC, agriculture and civilization changed in ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia. Advantages in agriculture allowed early civilizations to develop and sustain themselves over long periods of time. These advantages resulted from the use of different tools, their location and civilization. Tools drastically changed in Mesopotamia and Egypt from 3500 BC-2000 AD. An example of this change, is the sickle (Picture to the right from document 1 in DBQ).…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Guns, Germs and Steel Essay There is a technological disparity between different countries and civilizations because of what their geography and what type of climate they have. The climate and natural resources determine how the civilization developed. The Europeans geography controlled their agriculture giving them abundant crops, the ability to domesticate animals to increase productive development, immunity to deadly germs as a result of their exposure to their animals, and the ability to make steel which then led to decimation to other civilizations. Geographic location has a big effect on a civilations development and plant-lives ability to produce and thrive.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When an organism is domesticated, it loses its ability to live in the wild. Animals may be domesticated to be a pet or to be used for work. For example, horses are domesticated to work on farms and cats are domesticated to be…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond’s popular book , Guns, Germs and Steel, argues that Eurasians were blessed with superior environmental conditions. Eurasians were able to utilize this advantage to dominate and colonize other parts of the world. According to Diamond, this environmental theory explains the inequality that has occurred in our world in the past 500 years and is the main reason that our world is the way it is today. Although Diamond’s argument looks to be valid on the surface, when examined, it turns out to be full of fallacies and holes. By only looking at this issue from an environmental perspective, Diamond’s conclusion is inaccurate and incomplete; he has left moral, intellectual and biological factors out and as a result, he has had to modify and twist facts to serve his purpose.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author’s main purpose about defending the rights of the animals is that they are living creatures. His strong claim determines that researchers are finding animals are more like humans than we ever realized. However, defying by Rifkin’s statement’s and the reason he points out the connection is because us people have not really payed attention to be able to realize the similarity. Animals pass on learning or skills to their young ones which goes the same exact way with humans, most likely why many children look up to or choose to follow their parents footsteps.…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In his article News Flash: Negative Evidence Convicts Neanderthals of Gross Mental Incompetence, John Speth brings into question the conviction of Neanderthals as mentally incompetent beings due to their alleged lack of certain traits deemed indicative of modern human behaviour. He argues that the overplaying* of negative and missing evidence has resulted in possible misconceptions about the aptitude of our middle stone age (M.S.A) ancestors. He implies that the cognitive ability of neanderthals should be a long running and contentious debate in the anthropological community and instead their supposed unintelligence is almost uniformly written off as fact. Speth’s arguments are not as active in falsifying the opposing argument but more so in…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the Agricultural Revolution came the flourishing of many ancient civilizations. Two of these civilizations, the ancient Mesopotamians and the ancient Egyptians have provided modern day historians to uncover what life was like during these times. While these two have similar beginnings and locations, there are major differences between the two early civilizations. While both civilizations are nested near rivers which allow their agricultural lifestyles to flourish, Egypt has one advantage over ancient Mesopotamia, the sea. Being surrounded by the Red and Mediterranean seas, Egypt is provided with a natural defense from their enemies.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We have sent a man to the moon, we can get to somewhere miles away in minutes, and we can communicate with someone from across the globe almost instantaneously. These are just a few examples of the fantastic technology that we have developed that allows us to do things that our ancestors could never have even dreamed of. Surely, civilization as we know it is far superior to the pre-neolithic people. Well, according to John Lanchester’s article, “A Case Against Civilization,” our perceived achievements is nothing to be proud of. Walter Benjamin, a great German Jewish cultural critic, once said that every complicated and beautiful thing humanity ever made has, if you look at it long enough, shows a shadow, a history of oppression, and Lanchester’s…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Anna Karenina takes place at the biggest shift to modernity in Russian history, the social class theory and treatment of women were at the forefront of the novel.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Given that evolution gap, wild animals evolved to fend for themselves and they had certain features to them in order to help them survive in their wild habitat. If they are captured and trained to act like the domesticated animal that they are not, it would defeat their whole purpose of why they were made and what they were meant to do within their own environment. The Humane Society explains why evolution plays a key role in why exotic animals are unsuitable for being pets: “Wild animals are not domesticated simply by being captive born or hand-raised. Wild animals, by nature, are self-sufficient and fare best without our interference. The instinctive behavior of these animals makes them unsuitable as pets” (Humane Society 2009).…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The geographical features of a land will determine if it is suitable for farming. Humans began with hunting and gathering, which caused them to constantly travel. Traveling took up most of early humans’ time, not allowing them to focus on different aspects of development. Ancient Mesopotamia became one of the first civilizations, due to its geographic features. Mesopotamia was located between two rivers, the Euphrates and Tigris River.…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Nile and Indus River Valley were both life lines for the people who settled near them. The Nile and Indus River Valley had provided a barrier from war and disease, while providing them with rich soil to grow their crops. Without the help of these two rivers, the people would have had a difficult time making a living. Not only did the Nile and Indus Rivers give the people a way of life, it had helped make them the first known cities in the middle east.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ever since man, we wondered about our origin, so our advances in technology allows Anthropologist to answer this lingering question. Early civilizations, discovered in the 1800’s, were found along the Nile River and other areas just northeast of Africa. The early civilizations were diverse in particular ways, but had similarities too. The political, social, and institutions of these areas will be analyzed further, because ideas eventually developed to form better civilizations in the future.…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays