Devil's Arithmetic Book Vs Movie Essay

Improved Essays
The book and movie of The Devil’s Arithmetic have similarities and differences, and each of them benefit the execution of their respective genres.
The movie was released in March 28, 1999. Dustin Hoffman is one of the executive producers, and he introduces the movie. The summary of the movie is as follows; Hannah is a 17, or so, year old girl who doesn’t care about or accept her Jewish heritage. She reluctantly goes to Seder at her Aunt Eva’s house. A custom at the Seder is drinking the wine for the prophet Elijah, and then opening the door for him. Hannah drinks a bit too much wine, and then is asked to open the door. When she does, she is transported to the past. She is with her cousin, Rivka, and Rivka’s mother. Hannah later finds out that Rivka is her Aunt Eva from the present time. Rivka and
…show more content…
It begins with Hannah arguing with her mom about going to the Seder at her Grandpa Will’s apartment. Hannah drinks the wine and opens the door for Elijah. When the door is opened, she goes back to the past. She is at the house of Gitl and Shmuel, sister and brother. They are going to the wedding of Shmuel. Many Jews are gathered for the wedding. They are interrupted by the Nazis, who have come to “relocate” them. Well, instead of relocating the Jews, the Nazis take them to their concentration camp. The women are forced to get new clothes and have their hair cut. They try to put up a little bit of a fight, but to no avail. Hannah meets a girl named Rivka there. Rivka helps Hannah and her friends in the camp, but the time came when they were chosen. All except Hannah. She let Rivka escape, and so Hannah was killed instead. After Hannah went into the gas chambers, she found herself back in the present time at the Seder. She talks to her Aunt Eva, and found out that she was called Rivka in the camp. The book’s theme is to never forget what happened in the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The final climax of the story is when Hannah is sent to Lilith’s Cave to be placed in a gas chamber and ends up back in her grandparents’…

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    She is very beautiful and upbeat person who loves Shmuel very much. She is killed by firing squad at death camp after some of Hannah’s group try to escape. She was not part of the group to be executed however, she could not bear living without Shmuel Aunt Eva/Rikva - In the past she is Rikva, a 10 year-old chatterbox who comes up with an explanation…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She doesn’t want to take part in the traditions of her family. She complains about going to Passover dinner with her family, but she really enjoys spending time with her Aunt Eva, a recurring character throughout the novel. Passover is significant to this part of the novel, because it is a holiday that focuses on remembering those who have come before, and it is not until Hannah is ripped from her modern life and thrown into Holocaust-era Europe that she appreciates her heritage. ‘“It’s about remembering” “All Jewish holidays are about remembering, Mama. I’m tired of remembering.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For decades, popular novels have been published and years later followed with a film. Although the movie tends to portray imagery, the course of events in the book tend to contrast to those of the film. This became abundantly clear when I read the book and watched the movie, The Natural. In both the novel and the film, we learn about the life of a baseball player named Roy Hobbs, who was born with a talent and was given the ability to pursue his goal of life. Although his mindset was determined to break all the records in the game, many obstacles stood in his path ultimately skewing his priorities and driving him towards a path only ending with failure.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In between are stories of her own time there and stories from before she was a prisoner at the camp. Though the time that the stories takes place jumps around, each story points to the same conclusion. The Germans were horribly mistreating human beings and mindlessly slaughtering…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hannah’s motivation sparked with the help of Rivka. After Hannah had gotten out of the dream, she realized the cruelty and suffering that Hitler portrayed to the Jews. Also, the dream caused Hannah became aware of the fact that it was important to remember everything that had happened. Moreover, Cassie had also faced discrimination. This sorrowful trait was shown to her every day since the white people discriminated against the African Americans.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main character, Hannah, was the niece of a survivor of the Holocaust but did not feel that knowing about her own heritage was important till she ended up experiencing it herself. A lot of the youth feel as though their history is irrelevant and should stay history, the issue with that is if we do not know how far we have come we do not appreciate all that we currently have. Once people forget their roots it is like they forget their identity, it is as if they are lost souls and they are unaware. The second question is “Aside from weapons, how did the Nazis have control and power over the Jews in camp?”, in both the novella as well as in the movie The Devil’s Arithmetic the Nazis used a series of tactics to belittle the Jews resulting in control.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consequently, while Hannah tries her best to keep the family together, she actually causes the family to collapse in such a drastic way because she enables the family's problems to build up to a point where she is unable to hold them back alone, causing all the problems to crash down at once. Hannah uses her invisibility to covertly defend the family from itself because she is the only one who can see the defective qualities of the household. During an argument between James and Marilyn, “Hannah squirms… Her parents don't notice, In fact, they act as if she isn't even there” (107).…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hannah chooses to cut her wrists in order to commit suicide, one of the more commonly known methods of self harm. Hannah chooses to end her life in the bathtub of her own home, knowing that she will be found. Hannah seemed to want to be found and get the attention from her peers by killing herself in a common way and in a easily discovered area and does not try to conceal the fact that it was a…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Most Dangerous Game book vs movie contrast In Richard Connell 's best-known work is the short story, first written in 1924, "The Most Dangerous Game. " The story starts when Sanger Rainsford, a celebrated hunter and army veteran from New York, falls off his boat and ends up in the shore of a mysterious island. Walking through the island he finds a mansion on the top of a cliff. When he goes to the mansion he is welcomed by General Zaroff and his frightening deaf-mute servant Ivan. Zaroff is an experienced hunter who has traveled the world looking for the most challenging animals to hunt.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning of both the book and the movie, the protagonist is Hannah Stern. She lives in New Rochelle, New York, and is reluctant to go to the first Passover Seder. Once she is at the Seder, she gets drunk. When she is asked to open the door for Eliahu HaNavi, she is teleported back in time to 1942. There, she meets her family of that time,…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    She says, “It can be very hard to accept how disappointing life is, Harper, because that’s what it is, and you have to accept it. With fair and time and hard work you reach a point where . . . where the disappointment doesn’t hurt as much, and then it gets easy to live with. ”(180). Hannah is referring to her son Joe’s action in this part of the scene.…

    • 2443 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Martin Luther King Jr. show many times of him being a hero of dignity. One especially during his march where he and 50,000 other black and white protestors marched from Salem to Alabama’s capital Montgomery. This march was one of the most violent given the nickname, Bloody Sunday. The protesters were met by state troopers and were sprayed by fire hoses, attacked by vicious dogs and had poisonous gas thrown at them. While all of that was going on Martin Luther King Jr. still stayed calm and did not fight back.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Time and time again people come to the common question of, “Movies vs. books?” Many movies follow their books word for word whether its character development or plot development, whereas other movies change and twist the book’s stories in unimaginable ways, yet people are still faced with the question, “Movies or books?” An example of how books and movies can differ is in the story “The Outsiders” written by S. E. Hinton and produced by Francis Coppola. Although there are many similarities that both the book, The Outsiders, and the movie share, there were many noticeable differences in the appearance and personalities of all the characters. Three of the main characters, Pony, Johnny and Soda, will be reviewed in particular.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both the book Slumdog Millionaire (originally called Q&A) written by Vikas Swarup and the film adaptation of the same name directed by Danny Boyle received mostly positive reviews and critique, which cemented both of these works deep into the area they were apart of. The movie proved that you could make a successful movie using a traditional Bollywood recipe, and the book showed us how devastating and soul-crushing life in an Indian slum could be. The book also garnered an array of good feedback based on how it handled the different areas in India, and how the system was unfair in many of the different places. The book and the film adaptation have the same underlying pillars, but they differ a lot when it comes to plot and characters, and it is fairly unreasonable to say that the movie stays true to the source material of the book.…

    • 2140 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays