Determinist's Theory On Gender Identity

Improved Essays
Are women and men born or are they made by society’s values and expectations? The terms of sex and gender are often confused or interchanged mistakeably by people and most people think they are the same (Woolfolk and Margets, 2013, p. 4). Sex refers to the biological form of male and female to which you were born with the accompanying internal and external attributes but gender is to reference ‘male’ or ‘masculine’ and ‘female’ or ‘feminine’ qualities as defined by cultural, psychological, social values, attitudes and sexual identity (Bessant and Watts, 2007, p. 212).

Perhaps the question can be answered from a nature –vs- nurture viewpoint. Research by Dr John Money (Bader, 2014) suggested that children are born gender neutral regardless
…show more content…
Determinist’s theory on gender identity is that hormones, chemicals and complex brain message systems are what shapes a person and what they will become (Bessant and Watts 2007, pp. 213-217). One such famous biological determinist was Charles Darwin. To this day his theories are still openly discussed as correct even though people can now chose the sex of their child using I.V.F. processes and alter genes to remove disease or disability, which ultimately changes the persons’ fate and their roles in society as medical science allows people to play God and not biology with each generation …show more content…
Children are aware of their biological sexual differences from around 6 years of age but gender differences are reinforced by society, family and schools from birth (Cole & Cole, 1993, p.367). Sociocultural factors are more likely to be presented in schools which is where children first learn negative stereotyping, gender bias and discrimination which carries to adulthood and to society (Woolfolk & Margetts, 2013, p. 43). Educators need to be aware of their own biases to ensure they make an effort to reinforce positive gender stereotypes whilst children are learning their values and morals expected of them. With each new generation gender stereotypes and biases are slowly being modified, accepted or removed entirely from most societies and cultures. This again argues that society is the basis for gender identification and making men and women into what society requests they are and not biological

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Unit 5, Activity 4: ISP Essay Gender Inequality in Water for Elephants In today’s society, there is a common misconception between “gender” and “sex”. Although many believe these two identities to be similar in context, they have two different meanings: One’s “sex” refers to their genetic make-up (in terms of hormonal profile, sex organs etc.), while gender describes the characteristics that are classified as feminine or masculine by a culture or society. For example, in western cultures, women are usually seen as “more delicate and compassionate than men...have expectations to be domestic, warm, pretty, emotional, dependent, physically weak, and passive.”…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    What is gender? Is it whether we are born with a girl’s body or a boy’s or does it have to do with how we are raised? Many people have weighed in on this discussion and in his article, “Becoming Members of Society: Learning the Social Meanings of Gender”, Aaron H. Devor discusses how he believes that society is what shapes what we believe about gender. What we are told about what makes us male or female, according to Devor, is what determines what gender we determine ourselves to be.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When a baby is born, its body determines its gender. Doctors assign each infant to a category based on genitalia, and when a child does not cleanly fit into one of two boxes—male or female—confusion ensues. What color do I paint the nursery? Should I buy my child trucks or dolls? These questions may be the silly ones, but until quite recently, gender and sex have been nearly inseparable in the minds of the majority.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although this is true, Devor states, with a scientific study, that “children . . . understand gender as a function of role rather than as a function of anatomy.” This shows the degree to which children have an understanding of the difference between the two categories of masculinity and femininity, but it also represents the claim of which Devor speaks of. Devor’s formal judgement upon the social meanings of gender is critically, if not most significantly, expressed through his language. His interminable use of terms that are associated with his accordance of “socially directed hormonal instructions” exemplifies the unsuitable perception of a specific gender and is depicted as “dominance”, “communication”, and “identity” (53).…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gender vs. Sexuality is the most controversial issue that exists in society. Before an individual can choose their sexuality they must have a specific gender to distinguish them in society. Since the beginning of this class we learn different perspective on social constructionist vs. essentialism, which explains different stance on how society is socially constructed. The fact that society requires us to follow gender role create problems for individuals from being there true self. By society definition sex is based on chromosomes, meaning to be a female you must have XX chromosome and a male is XY.…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Almost immediately children become gender aware. They start creating generalizations, which they apply to themselves as well as other people, slowly forming their personalities. (Martin and Ruble, 2004). The role of schools has become major in the lives of children younger than 5 years old (Sales, Spjeldnes, and Koeshe, 2010). Two fundamental parts of the early childhood environment influence perceptions of young children’s gender and gender stereotypes: classroom materials and the instructions of EYPs (Well and Hmm, 2005).…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The outcomes of the study suggest that nature is stronger than nurture when it comes to gender identity. 2. I…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Summary Of Leaning Gender

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One of the main points that I found to be interesting in Chapter 3, Leaning Gender, is that “sex is a biological fact and gender is the societal interpretation of that fact” (117). This idea is so complicated and ambiguous that the topic of gender is always a hot issue. The book goes on to talk about how things in nature can be male and female. That being said, it is true for people too. We have been told or shown what we should be (male or female) since we were born.…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender is constructed by the society. Although individuals are born sexed, they are not born gendered. Learning is required for individuals to become masculine or feminine. Children learn to talk, walk and gesture according to their social group’s beliefs of how boys and girls should act (Lorber, 1991). Gender is a human production which relies on everyone continual “doing gender” (West & Zimmerman, 1987).…

    • 1922 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While many today agree that gender can be expressed in a variety of ways which need not conform to particular physiologies, sex is still often conceived as some sort of natural, essential truth about a person's body. However, just as “gender” is defined by sociologists as a socially constructed set of meanings given to the identities and behaviours that individuals perform, the concept of “sex” cannot be divorced from cultural context. Sociologists reject that biology and science are not informed by social interactions and meanings. Biologists attempt to define sex in solely physical terms, as the presence of proper organs, hormones, brains, chromosomes, and other physical characteristics that neatly conform to one branch of the sex dichotomy…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Sexism

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In our society today, there are still many techniques of discrimination that one would think had been eradicated years ago. One of these techniques is sexism, which is the act of prejudice, stereotyping, and/or intolerance on the basis of gender. Sexism has taken control over the way people think and it affects the job industry, government decisions, the media, and unfortunately, education. Children begin to experience sexism at a young age, typically in elementary school. An example of a subliminal sexist message that they might experience would be a teacher scolding a female student for acting in an unorthodox fashion that does not fit the ‘calm, respectful, and neat’ stereotype for girls, but then excusing the same actions of a male student, using the overused, disgusting statement ‘boys will be boys.’…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1. In interpreting gender, our ability to identify gender contributes and is crucial to if and how we chose to interact with these people. There are signals that we perceive when determining if a person is a man or female; we put them in these categories to make sense of what type of person they are. Sut Jhally claims that when we become confused about our signals in identifying if a person is a man or a woman, than it is impossible to interact with that person.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Night To His Day Summary

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Night to his Day” by Judith Lorber addresses the idea that gender is not a biological distinction but is a socially constructed system. We are not born with a masculine or feminine identity just with male and female genitalia; hence gender roles are constructed by humans. Lorber explains that gender construction starts at birth where we are assigned a gender based on our genetaila, and then parents dress the child as the assigned gender to alleviate questions of their child’s sex. From the day that we are born society tells us what a “real girls/boy should looks like, how one acts and how one talks. We are then only recognized by those roles and when we do the opposite we have broken some cardinal rule.…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    What Is It to be Considered a Specific Gender While Judith Butler’s claim in her essay “From Undoing Gender” is challenging, complex, and comprehensible, she provides somewhat enough evidence and analysis of David Reimer’s case to prove her claim that society uses language to set the norms of what a gender should be and how one should act in accordance with one’s gender. First, Butler’s use of David Reimer’s case, known as “the John/Joan case” ("Interview: John Colapinto”), “a boy who accidentally had his penis burned and subsequently amputated at the age of eight months” (740-741), is somewhat sufficient to prove a claim that most people would resist accepting. William and Colomb have expounded that, “The more readers resist a claim, the…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Judith Lorber (1994) describes gender as a type of institution that has established patterns of expectations for individuals based on whether they are male or female. She believes that gender affects individuals and their social interaction, gender is traceable, can be researched and examined. Gender establishes a set of expectations for us to follow and has a huge impact on social processes and its organization. This institution is purely based on a set of learned ideas that have shaped the way our society thinks and has nothing to do with our actual biology.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays