The Designed Player By Peter F. Martin: Article Analysis

Great Essays
Both the articles “Destroyed” by Peter F Martin and “The Designed Player” by Rodrigo Villagomez discuss the presence of having steroids in sports. Martin explains in his article how he thinks it is a form of “cheating,” and steroids should not be allowed. However, Villagomez portrays how he thinks steroids are increasing the popularity of sports and should be authorized. Although the articles “Destroyed” and “The Designed Player” bear minor similarities, the differences of author’s craft and author’s point of view are much more pronounced. In Peter Martin’s article “Destroyed,” Martin emphasizes that steroids are a negative factor in sports. Martin is very strict about his thoughts when discussing his point of view. He discusses how there …show more content…
One of the ways Villagomez shows this is through point of view. Villagomez talks about how baseball players are just people, not necessarily perfect. These players showcase their skills for us; should we really care if they are being a little shady about their talent? He says, “They should thank them. Without those players, they might not even have a game to watch” (Villagomez). Villagomez explains how he thinks baseball players are amazing; they go onto the field and specially perform their special talent for thousands and thousands of people. He is also implying that steroids help to make the game more exciting by saying “they might not even have a game to watch.” Villagomez’s point of view is clear that baseball players are inspiring people, and that people should not think that something as small as steroids should stop them from enjoying the game. Villagomez also has a different author’s craft that helps to present his argument. He crafts his essay through facts and quotes. For example, Villagomez explains the dictionary definition of steroid; “Let’s first look at the clinical definition of a steroid. A steroid is “any group of organic compounds belonging to the general class of biochemicals called lipids, which are easily soluble in organic solvents and slightly soluble in water”(Dempsey)” (Villagomez). Villagomez incorporates this into …show more content…
A similarity between these 2 articles is that they both try to put the reader into a specific mood. For example, in “Destroyed,” Martin uses an analogy to amp up the idea of steroids being a form of cheating. He says, “Head to Vegas and you can drop money on your guesses. Just make sure you cover the spread, because it’s not enough to say slammin’ Sammy Sosa’s been hitting the juice” (Martin). Martin does this to really bring out that so many athletes are cheating that you can go to Las Vegas and bet on if they are or not. This puts the reader in a bias sort of mood against the other side, so they could side with the idea that steroids are a form of cheating. Similarly, in “the Designed Player,” Villagomez puts the reader in a similar mood when talking about the success of steroid-using athletes; “But if it were not for the small percentage of players who have recently been found to use steroids, baseball would not be enjoying the success it does today. We should be thanking these players for keeping the game popular” (Villagomez). Once again, Villagomez mentions how we should thank the players for using steroids and keeping the game popular. He says this to put the readers into a similar mood. He wants the reader to feel that steroids are a beneficial factor in sports’ success, and we should be pro-steroids in sports. Martin and Villagomez both put the reader into a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The essay “Let Steroids Into the Hall of Fame” written by Zev Chafets was written for the New York Times shortly after the Major League Baseball Association had placed a ban on the use of steroids or any performance enhancement drugs. Chafets depicts how the use of steroids and performance enhancements are viewed by the league and how it pertains to the integrity, honesty, or professionalism within the game. The content is viable to any sports enthusiast or fanatic that could possible get their hands on the sports section of the Times (Kirszner and Mandell 253). Chafets uses several different writing techniques and patterns to validate his persuasive argument. He state that Major League Baseball should not place a ban on the use of steroids,…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His opinions on the idea that athletes, who show extraordinary skills and use performance-enhancing drugs, should be given a place in the Hall of Fame, are logical and easy to understand. The author uses historical background to backup his idea and uses cause and effect structures in his sentences. To begin with, baseball is constantly changing. In his article, Chafets mentions: “But since the hall opened its doors, baseball has never stopped changing” (8). This quote says that baseball, as any other sport, is not standing in one place, but is evolving.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Steroids can change the game in all of sports. Bigger, Stronger, Faster* is a 2008 documentary about steroids by someone with intimate knowledge. It examines the use of steroids of director Christopher Bell and his two brothers named Mike Bell and Mark Bell. Christopher Bell and his two brothers were enamored of the powerful superheroes they grew up watching. Christopher Bell is professional bodybuilder.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He makes a valid point, stating that although several professional players are caught using drugs, that does not make all athletes bad, nor should we discriminate against all athletes. Although some athletes may cheat and use PEDs or human growth, that does not make all players in Major League Baseball…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In a time when many of the MLB’s stars were getting busted for steroid use, the media, especially at the time that this book was written in 2005, hated steroids. Canseco, however, believed that steroids can make sports better. This clash of ideas had Canseco disliked by the media throughout his career. Canseco was unhappy with the media because he felt that the media was racist towards him. Players such as Mark McGwire were caught using PEDs, and the media still liked him, where Canseco did the same thing, yet people hated him for it.…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Baseball Steroid Era

    • 2844 Words
    • 12 Pages

    In the baseball steroid era, we come to think if the baseball players were really playing the games or if the steroids kept the game alive. In my search to find the authenticity to the game of baseball, I came across the findings of historical significance. Not only the historical significance, but also the social consequences of political disruption. All these demonstrate the possible impact throughout the baseball “steroid era”. Baseball's "steroid era" had an important impact on the game and in American sports, causing many players to take performance-enhancing drugs, damaging the sport's reputation, and raising discussions about the ethical issues of steroid use in professional sports.…

    • 2844 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Baseball is everyone’s game; the young and the old, men and women alike, hold onto the hope of victory until the last strike. In many ways, baseball mirrors life—it spans the generations and connects us in ways not fully understood. Yes, baseball is America’s pastime and obsession where hope springs eternal with the determination of “Just wait until next…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Steroids In Baseball

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Analytical Interpretation of a Political Cartoon Most Americans work hard for what they have, yet, it is baseball, America’s pastime, where the players cheat their way to the top of the game. The evolution of steroids in baseball has evolved rapidly in the past two decades. The lack of routine drug tests in baseball, combined with the less than harsh suspensions has created a league unlike that of the previous century. This juiced up league has created new records as players become stronger and don’t fatigue as quickly.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Usage of Steroids Within the NFL and the MLB Steroids and performance enhancement drugs, PEDS, have been banned in the National Football League and in Major League Baseball since the early 1980’s and readjusted in the early 2000’s (Kelley). Players’ know about the stipulations of which exact drugs are allowed and which are banned within their league, but still ten NFL players were banned within the 2015 season for the use of PEDS (Performance Enhancing Drugs in Sports Fast Facts). Recently, allegations from outside sources have been leading to many of the suspensions today compared to just the league’s drug testing and busting these athletes. The most recent allegation is against Peyton Manning who is a first ballot Hall of Famer…

    • 1638 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Players might use steroids as a rehabilitative method, or simply to gain a competitive edge over other players. However, the media negatively emphasizes players using steroids to gain a competitive edge, whereas taking steroids for rehabilitation is portrayed more positively by the news. Given Bonds’ negative…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Baseball Hall Of Fame

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Baseball has long been seen as an integritous union in a world of flawed sports, being dubbed by some as a “gentlemen’s game”. However baseball has a somewhat troubling past, including many people who have cheated the game and even been celebrated for it. In fact, the Hall of Fame is riddled with players who have blatantly circumvented the rules. From Gaylord Perry’s spitball to Mickey Mantle’s amphetamines players have tried to gain a competitive edge on others for decades. These players are perennial all stars and in baseball circles it is considered blasphemous to discuss them in the same sentence as the Steroid users of the 1990’s.…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Steroids Be Banned Essay

    • 1234 Words
    • 5 Pages

    I agree to this because because it proves how it shows the skill of the player and it is not just the steroids working to hit the ball. The steroids are not gonna just slow the ball down and make it stop, you may hit it harder but it is not gonna stop the ball right in front of you so you can hit a homerun. Baseball players have gains and losses by using them; yes, it will give them a little more of an edge but it kicks back a little of their health edge. It will maybe make them stronger on the outside but not on the inside, it could stunt their growth, they could gain aggression, or it could increase your rate at developing heart disease. On the contrast, you can also gain from using steroids, you can gain muscles, your endurance to work out is longer, and your body also creates more adrenaline.…

    • 1234 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. How widespread is the use of steroids? In today’s time many people are constantly looking for ways to excel in sports or perform better in their normal jobs. Furthermore, we live in a society where people are judge by their physical appearance.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Salvulescu and his fellow colleagues further push the issue that these drugs should be allowed, but if and only if those who partake of it are safe with it. Only drugs that will not cause any bodily harm should be allowed, restating their view that “We should permit drugs that are safe, and continue to ban and monitor drugs that are unsafe…for example anabolic steroids” (Savulescu et al. 5). By monitoring the use of these drugs and putting the safety of the athletes first, the use of these drugs should be permitted in sports, but this issue goes farther than the health of athletes and leads to the realm of…

    • 2223 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This has been a big focus on leagues today because they know many kids look up to these athletes and want to be like them. The steroids or other drugs that they take, help them put up big numbers and become bigger stars in the face of the media. People want success,”Fans just want to be in attendance when Bonds breaks the record. ”(McCallum 36). This if referring to the controversy regarding Barry Bonds becoming the home run king while under investigation for steroids.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays