Destiny Disrupted Tamim Ansary: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
In both Destiny Disrupted and Persepolis the history of Islam is told but from two different perspectives; a historical text and also from personal accounts. In Destiny Disrupted Tamim Ansary tell the history of Islam through the perspective of a male who grew up in as Muslim Afghanistan that belonged to the upper class. He states in the introduction of Destiny Disrupted “Growing up as a muslim afghanistan, I was exposed early on to a narrative of the world's history quite different from the one that schoolchildren in Europe and Americans routinely hear.”(Ansary xiii). In this statement he explains that at a young age he was exposed to history that wasn't told in school. What he meant by this is that ever since 9/11 history books have frayed away from the history of Middle East. He found that the people who write the history books found it best to resist the topic as a whole to avoid conflict.

In Persepolis, Marji the main character tell her story from the perspective of a Iranian female living in a upper/middle class family; she is also against communism and fundamentalism. Marji had very strong opinions on the revolution. She stated “For a revolution to succeed, the entire population must support it.” (Satrapi 17). At a young age Marji found
…show more content…
Ansary wants to move away from the negative stereotypes of Islam. He doesn't want his religion to be associated with the extremists of it, which sadly most religions are represented from extremists ideas. He did state that “given my personal stake, I could concede that I might be overestimating the importance of islam.”(xvi). He does say that he might be exaggerating about Islam due to his positive experiences that he has with it. This does not make his opinions about Islam false

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    As we may or may not know “Persepolis” is considered a graphic novel and it is written and drawn up by the author,Marjane Satrapi, herself. This form of writing by Marjane Satrapi does in fact enhance the understanding of the novel and the culture because the book is told from her childhood perspective and we can get a glimpse of what was her thoughts during this certain time period. Also, based on how on how the pictures were drawn one can get a certain feel for the book. In the 1980’s, Satrapi was sent to Austria by her parents where she attended the Lycée Français de Vienne. She returned to Iran after graduating high school where she attended university.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The representation of religion in the film Persepolis Persepolis: The story of a child hood is movie made from a graphic novel and autobiography by Marjane Satrapi. The story is told from a first person perspective by young author Marji. She had witnesses the entire Islamic Revolution; including the fall of the pro-western Shah republic in 1979, the rise of Islamic fundamentalism and the Iran-Iraq War in 1980; throughout her childhood.…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout life, there are constant decisions that have to be made, and with each decision one always sacrifices something, whether it is smaller or larger. The sacrifice is always made in order to have a better result in the end, but one may not we always content with the component that is removed from their current standing. In Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis, Marjane sacrifices her sensation of identity in order to fit the standards and avoid trouble with new Islamic government regime that is placed in Iraq when she stays and eventually gives up her home and family in order to move on to a place with more opportunity for her. In the beginning of the novel, which takes setting during the Iraq Revolution, Marjane explains her current whereabouts about her situation, in which she must wear a veil to school because the Islamic government emplaces a new dressing code for all women to follow the religion.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Structure and language Ayaan Hirsi Ali’s novel, Infidel is an autobiography focusing on her struggles as a Muslim woman. It starts of by a detailed recollection of her childhood and life in Somalia leading to her movement to America. Ayaan’s novel focuses on her inner struggle with Religion and human value, which she later on figures out. Ayaan’s profound awakening happens when she moves to the Netherlands where she later on obtains a degree in political science. The structure and language of Infidel elaborates on the idea of Islam and Islamic culture being the opposite of what it stands for, as peaceful and coequal, through the author’s descriptiveness, blunt honesty, and her choice of point of view.…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Osamah Autobiography

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages

    3 ) Paragraph comparing the emigration experiences in Persepolis and Good Muslim Boy Religion plays a major role for both Marjane and Osamah as they both had a religion they followed. Marjane lived a more avant garde lifestyle in the safezone of Iran and Osamah lived in the Iran-Iraqi border as a poor boy. Osamah as a child spend his time under the direct effects of war and boombings, losing a family member first hand and when he moved to Iran he was treated as a lesser kid as people tended to treat him even worse such as the teachers. Marjane on the other hand lived in the middle of Iran safe from most attacks as she was of a higher class and wasn’t majorly affected by the war in contrast to Osamah’s childhood. Osamah’s social context affects…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Persepolis, by Marjane Satrapi, the main character changes in various ways throughout the graphic novel. Marjane is a nice and religious but also naive little girl in the beginning of the book. For example, on pages 6 and 7, Marjane says that at the age of 6, she was sure that she was the last prophet. Furthermore, she had three rules; “everybody should have a car”, “all maids should eat at the table with others” and “no old person should have to suffer.” It is evident that she wants everyone to be equal and that she is values her religion a lot.…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cultural heritage forms part of every human being. From Muslims with the Ramadan, where they abstain from food or drinks, and pray; to Indian arranged marriages, where the families planned the union for their own benefit. The diversity around individuals should be viewed as something that would benefit society, not just to destroy it. In the article, “Why Trump Makes Me Scared for My Family,” Aziz Ansari, an actor, writer and director; gives his opinion as son of Muslim immigrants. Using life experiences, rhetorical devices and tone; the actor, persuades the readers to stop the negativity and hate towards different cultures in America.…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It’s saddening that all of the history, traditions, practices and beliefs of the Muslims are generalized in the report of 9/11 and how most news media reports focused on Muslims when they are involves in crime, security, and other negative viewpoint that they were portrayed. Since that incident, Americans started to link Islam with terrorism, and the fear of terrorism is directly related to Muslims which lead to created surge of negative stereotype report of Muslims. As the news reports defame and oversimplification of Muslims caused for social conflict and division in society, Muslims were continually confronted about cultural and religious aspects, which often were inaccurately related and caused for even more confusion in the…

    • 116 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The women in the novels Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi are a chief example of the theme of matriarchy present throughout the text. The novel has a prevalent feminist air, which is exhibited in the presence of numerous female role models, and the character Marji 's various protests against the men in the Regime. These moments of rebellion on Marji 's part may stem from the influence her matriarchal role models had on her. Examples of these role models include Marji 's mother and grandmother. Both women are very involved in Marji 's life, and both women hold unique qualities that make them role models for Marji.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The imperialism that took place in Marjane’s country, the religion that Marjane strongly believed in, and Marjane’s loss of innocence while she was very young, all affected her perspective throughout the graphic novel, Persepolis. As…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The West appears to have a misconception of Islamic law surround the concept of holy war or jihad to conflict owing to the extended flawed appropriation by Osama bin Laden on Islamic belief to justify his group’s terrorist exploits against unbelievers. Violence is also, paradoxically, advocated in the Qur’an and Old Testament or Hebrew Scriptures, and yet the two latter’s’ passages on combat and conduct of war are overlooked unlike its former religious succession. Jihad (to strive or struggle) is actually the unofficial sixth part for the Five Pillars of Islam or duties to God which is meant to be taken as the dilemma to comprehend God’s will on this planet as nonviolent or violent in a frequently quoted Prophetic tradition. Its community also has never officially sanctioned these violent measures as…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The word 'Islam' means 'peace.' The word 'Muslim' means 'one who surrenders to God.' But the press makes us seem like haters.” This quote by Muhammad Ali shows how people’s perception of Islam isn’t the ideal meaning of Islam and due to ignorance, anyone who is classified as Muslim or Islam is seen as an evil person. This made me wonder what Islam really is, how it is perceived in the Middle East, where most of the region is dominated with this specific religion, and how that view of Islam impacts America.…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Persepolis, by Marjane Satrapi, is a graphic autobiography about growing up in Iran during the Islamic revolution in Tehran from age six to fourteen. This graphic novel contains several recurring visual symbols and icons. One of the most important of these symbols and icons in Persepolis is the symbol of God. God represents faith and Marji’s belief in what is said to her and how she perceives it. When God is present Marji is undoubtful that everything is alright.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because of these influences, Marji is able to grow and learn to be herself and have her own voice. Throughout Persepolis, Satrapi explores many themes surrounding feminism and is able to break down female stereotypes within to book. The Western and Iranian women are depicted as unique but also as rebellious. Showing both sides of these women helps one another in the fight to reach a common goal.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though there was an immense range in which who were the targeted readers for Satrapi’s book, Persepolis, it seemed to be that the book was more designed for young adults reaching to gain more insight towards the conditions in Iran around the time of the Islamic Revolution and Iran-Iraq War. Satrapi’s decision in writing Persepolis as a graphic novel opened up the range of audience for her book. Because the book was filled with pages of illustrations, it made reading a lot easier. As pictures filled up most of the pages with minimal words, it also allowed for a quicker read, perfect for young adults who may not have the extra spare time.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays