Debra Satz's Defense Of The Asymmetry Thesis

Better Essays
The market in women’s reproductive labour is one that is complicated and contentious. Many people view the selling of women’s reproductive labour to be an unacceptable form of market exchange as compared to other forms of labour market exchange. It seems intuitive to people that the treatment of women’s reproductive labour as a commodity and its exploitation for money, as compared to other forms of labour as commodities, is worse. This view is known as the asymmetry thesis. In the book “Why Some Things Should Not Be For Sale”, Debra Satz agrees with the asymmetry that exists. While I am in support of the asymmetry thesis on the market in women’s reproductive labour, I disagree with Satz’s way of defending the asymmetry thesis. Satz is of the …show more content…
I, on the other hand, adopt the essentialist view and think that there is something about the nature of women’s reproductive labour that makes it problematic to sell. In this paper, I will first present and examine Satz’s defense of the asymmetry thesis. Next, I will argue against Satz’s defense of the asymmetry thesis. Lastly, I will argue in favour of the essentialist position in support of the asymmetry thesis.
Satz argues that the market in women reproductive labour is problematic because of the gender inequality that it promotes in society. She thinks that “it is the background gender inequality that makes the commodification of women’s attributes especially objectionable” (Satz, 2010). Firstly, Satz raises the worry of the market in women’s reproductive labour encouraging women to give up their control over their own body in a contract pregnancy. In contract pregnancy, those who pay for reproductive
…show more content…
It is only natural that a surrogate mother develops a bond with the child she has conceived for she has devoted tremendous physical and mental resources into the pregnancy. Thus, it would not be surprising if the surrogate mother regrets her decision of entering into a pregnancy contract and decides to breach the contract to give away the child, due to the intimate bond she has formed with her child during the period of her pregnancy. When we demand that a surrogate mother give up the child and her parental rights to the child, we treat the child as a mere commodity. (Lack of appreciation for the child’s intrinsic value other than its instrumental value) However, Satz’s argues against this as she does not think that there is a “difference between women’s reproduction labour and human labour that would be relevant to contract pregnancy”. She raises criticisms against contract pregnancy that believes in the special nature of parental love which arises when conceiving the child. She views the mother-child bond to be similar to the bond formed between a worker and his product. She also argues that contract pregnancy does not cause parents to view children as commodities. She believes that even if those paying for the women’s reproductive labour are not satisfied with certain characteristics of their

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Discussions if Commercial surrogacy is ethical or not is often controversial. Generally, the term Commercial surrogacy refers to an arrangement between the surrogate mother and intended parents in which there's a mutual benefit. It has turned into an appealing substitute for new couples because of adoption troubles, fertility issues, or high pregnancy risks. However, many still question the morality of surrogacy. A contemporary moral philosopher, Elizabeth Anderson, argues that surrogacy contacts degrade children and women's labor by treating them as commodities.This is the belief argument for surrogacy not being ethical.The following will be a close evaluation of the conflict.In which follows, I will explain the positive outcomes of surrogacy…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, people tend to have the wrong idea about feminism. Feminism is the idea that women are equal to men, not superior to them. There are many ways to experience feminism. Short stories are one of the most crucial ways to learn about gender inequality and feminism. Several authors choose to propose stories based upon feminism and gender inequality to show an uprising problem throughout society.…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Wage Gap Among Women

    • 1035 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Human Rights Campaign website defines workplace discrimination as “ discrimination based on gender indentity and sexual orientation”; and according to Compact Law , direct discrimination is “when and employee or prospective employee is less favorably treated because of their race, sex, marital status, religion, sexual orientation, gender reassignment, age , disability, pregnancy, or maternity.” Blau and Kahn states, “ Women anticipate shorter and more discontinuous work lives” and that is why women face direct discrimination. Workplace discrimination occurs because “many women may not be able to handle the hard labor a job bares” (Blau and Kahn) The difference in rates of pay between men and women does not only affect women; the difference affects their children and their future also. When women do not make enough money to provide for their family, their children are affected because they are not able to get what they…

    • 1035 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Her manifesto critiques the feminist movement’s inability to establish their own position, shedding a new light on feminism. Marinetti’s offensive support for women suffragettes irritates Loy, so “Feminist Manifesto”…

    • 1553 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Sexism is most commonly discriminating against women. Today there are many gender norms that are followed by our society today. In Paulo Freire’s piece, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, he states that a social justice issue is, the permanent fount of the generosity, which is nourished by death, despair, and poverty” (Freire 44). Freire would classify sexism as a social justice issue because women are being oppressed from their ability to be equal to men. Sexism is dehumanizing because it is limiting people from reaching their full potential.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For first wave theorists, such as Mill, the solution to gender inequality is by changing the laws. Mill argues laws in regards to martial contracts need to be altered. Mill believes that women are oppressed due to the unfair marital contracts. So, in order to achieve equality Mill argues that women should have the right to earn and own property while married or not married. First wave feminism solution to gender equality is largely through legal means of women’s rights.…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Gender Biased Language

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There is no doubt that females are under-represented in politics and this is to due to social constructs, which restrict participation and representation. Language is often used to trivialise the involvement of women in politics, and as politicians are considered the masters of rhetoric, it is no surprise it is employed to devalue the contributions of their colleagues based on gender. An example of this is the common criticism received by women in politics of “playing the gender card” to seek advantage (Donaghue, 2015). Such use of rhetoric implies that women who point out the injustices faced by females are using gender as a tactical advantage. As Donaghue (2015) says, it is quite ironic considering that most females in politics who bring attention to gender inequality are often faced with harsh…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the new wave of feminism, people have come to see this word as ugly and undesirable. It has become skewed and twisted by the people who are against the movement giving it a negative connotation. Instead of imagining the brave and courageous women who are fighting for equal treatment for all women of the world, they see “man-hating”, ugly, masculine women. Thinking this…

    • 1932 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Women haven’t just been affected by sexual division of labor, but also to class divisions related to modes of production. The legal system, education system, and the labor market are all factors that construct gender inequality and the subordination of women. Women’s lack of economic power is the most important factor of gender inequality. The division of labor at the societal level reinforces that of the household which is a source of a women’s disadvantages position. Men and women have unequal access to political and economical power.…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In society today, it is often assumed that women are the victims of atrocious oppression at the hands of men. This belief includes the thoughts that women are held back by unequal pay, being denied leadership roles, having to be the primary caretaker of children, and more. Feminists argue that they are trying to improve society by correcting these issues. Richard Dorment is his essay “Why Men Still Can’t Have It All” explores the topic of feminism and attempts to show a different view of it by showing some negative aspects of the feminist movement. This stance challenges a movement that proclaims it is fighting for an honorable cause.…

    • 1836 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays