Deborah Tannen Analysis

Good Essays
Task of Understanding One Another
“Why aren’t you listening to me?” that is what I would ask my dad when I would not see him engaged in what I had to say. However he never failed to repeat exactly what I told him. Most women need eye contact to show that the listener is absorbed in the conversation. That is just one of the many examples that are presented as what we naturally expect a certain way to act or listen when one is present. The reason why we do not realize this natural presumption is proven by the individual research Daniel Goleman and Deborah Tannen logically shared. These authors present multiple misunderstandings of the opposite sex and how reasons such as socialization and communication lead to these misinterpretations.
Our
…show more content…
It is very difficult however for one to present that emotion as well as understand what one is trying to establish. Deborah Tannen presents her factual clarifications in her article But What Do You Mean, where she lists the common areas of miscommunication. One area she mentioned was the moment of “praise”. When a girlfriend asks another friend her opinion on an outfit one does not expect a negative comment, she expects a nice comment and maybe a suggestion if the outfit does not wear the outfit well. Women try to avoid being blunt. If a girl asked a guy about an outfit she would expect a nice critique, but men are more than likely to respond with a straight honest answer. For example, Tannen shared a story about a named Deidre who asked her co-worker about a presentation she performed. After the Deidre gave him her complimentary feedback he gave her a little too much of an honest feedback that later led her to become uncomfortable (“But What…”4). “It would be easy to assume that Deidre was insecure, whether she was fishing for a compliment or soliciting a critique. But she was simply talking automatically” (4). She was what Tannen states, “performing one of the many conversational rituals that allow us to get through the day.” The reason for the automatic conversation traces back to socialization of adolescent children. We do not realize what we do or say simply because we …show more content…
Women complain that men do not listen or are unsupportive because of their lack of body language that shows they listen. Women are used to talking to their friends using eye contact or supportive gestures showing the person sharing that they are listening. Men on the other hand also get frustrated from women. “Men expect silent attention interpret a stream of listener noise as overreaction or impatience,” and that is what women do the majority of the time because of the way her social surroundings structured her views of emotional communication. Daniel Goleman explains in His Marriage and Hers: Childhood Roots men and women want very different things from a woman in a conversation; men are content to talk about topics while women seek emotional connections (400). It is amazing how accurate Tannen’s and Goleman’s observations are because socialization do shape our views and expectations, if it were different then there would not be a majority of people having the same common misunderstandings. Men feel the way they do because as Tannen mentions “they are on guard to protect themselves from being put down and pushed around” (444). The reason why it culminates into a common misunderstanding is because women want the opposite of “being on guard.” Women want men to express their emotions

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Men get blamed for not being emotionally intuitive and women for not being emphatic. The solution to this would be looking at conversation between men and women as cross-cultural communication. It would allow them to become understanding and solve problems more logically. “Once the problem is understood, improvement comes naturally, as did to the young woman and her boyfriend who seemed to go to sleep when she wanted to talk” (121). The young woman explained that there are differences in men’s and women’s way of alignment during conversation.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Women usually have a problem with that because they don’t understand why their spouse will not talk or communicate with them as they do men, “He doesn’t talk to me” Pg.408. Most men will talk they just have their own way of doing it., but for women they feel men are not listening when they are talking because they do not respond with conversation or may be looking away or changing the subject, they are listening just in their own way. Subjects they are not interested in or they feel not important will probably not get women the full attention. They are expecting. Usually women will become frustrated with their spouse.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    These conversational habits are as frustration to men as they are to women. Men expect silent attention; however, when there are listener noises men perceive them as impatience or overreaction. Another difference among men and women is how they express support. Women have the tendency to agree to each other, while men tend to point out the other side of an argument Men’s conversational duty can be seen to women as disloyalty, and refusal to offer the requisite support (Tannen 284). Men take too literally women’s “trouble talk”, just as women mistake men’s challenges and real…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Communication Between Males and Females Let’s face it, communication holds a great significant and value in life. Communication is everything. Men and women tend to communicate differently, which causes issues between the male and female bond. Deborah Tannen wrote an article called “Sex, Lies, and Conversation: Why Is It So Hard for Men and Women to Talk to Each Other.” She talks about the difference in the chatty conversation women want and how verbal communication is not necessary for men. The bonding process is dissimilar for male and female.…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When women share their issues with guys, the men always look for a way to solve the conflict. Women see this as taking the other point of view and think you are disagreeing with them, when you are just trying to find a solution to make things better. One would think that women would be appreciative that guys are trying to help, but they don’t see it that way. Ladies will sometimes just shut down when men offer solutions. Maybe asking if she wants the guy to just listen or does she want feedback?…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This will often lead to anger, which will lead to fights. Back to the idea of men needing help, when men do in fact need help, and ask for it, rather then help find a solution to the problem women will often sympathize with the man like she would do with her girlfriends (Tannen, 51). Men find this degrading, as if the women is putting down their problems as no big deal. Women often don’t understand this concept, that while they like giving and receiving advice, men feel as if they aren’t good enough, and need to be…

    • 1349 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Tannen goes on to say that many men view things in the same way such as, they are trying to achieve and maintain a status. Whereas women view the world as a network of connections seeking support and consensus (Tannen). Men always want to be better at everything and make themselves look superior over others, while women like to talk about their problems and seek advice and support from others. This makes men and women very different because they do not see the world in the same way. An example of this is, “To Josh, checking with his wife would mean he was not free to act on his own… Linda actually enjoys telling someone ‘I have to check with Josh.’ It makes her feel good to show that her life is intertwined with her husband’s.” (Tannen).…

    • 1960 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “… Often voiced by women about the men with whom they are intimate is "He doesn 't talk to me" and the second most frequent is "He doesn 't listen to me." Women claimed that even talking to their husbands was difficult cause their husbands were telling them that they should stop gossiping. “This simply provides further confirmation that what appear senseless of mindless to men is of considerable important to men .” So I would say that this so called “gossip” is actually the way that women speak and share themselves with one another, and instead of seeing it as ide chatter we should understand that its an important part of women self disclosing to one…

    • 1262 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If the guy pleases her then she will be a pleasing wife in return, but this shows that the man has to be worthy and he has to work to win her. The song gives off the impression that women are easy and if they say no they don’t really mean it because through a few compliments you can get them to change their minds. This is a bad vibe to let off because it makes a women’s word worth nothing and it lets men override what a woman has to say and interpret it for themselves. In Thao’s article, Sins of Silence, it is stated that “Nod your head and say yes even if you don’t agree” (18). Although Trainor does not remain mum about her expectations, she does readily agree to give whatever the man wants if he fulfills her small standards first.…

    • 2069 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I did not find it is fair to force all the women to follow these rule, and it will cause a lot of problem if they are continuing to doing that. When Kimmel said in her article “the Guy Code fits as comfortably as a straightjacket.” (para. 30), I think what she means by that is the straightjacket make every guy look good when they are wearing it, but it is not comfortable to wear. It is the same as the Guy code. When “guy” follow these Guy Code, it will make them look good by other people, but not all guy feels comfortable when follow these code.…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays