Death Of Ivan Ilyich And Death Of A Salesman Analysis

Improved Essays
Two books, The Death of Ivan Ilyich by Leo Tolstoy and Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, give insight two men’s consequences of leading a specific life when faced with the thought of death. Their deaths mean more than just passing off from the mortal world, it reflects and questions their morals and behaviors in their lifetimes. Although Ivan realizes how meaningless the pursuits of his life have been in his final moments before death while Willy dies still delusional and dwelling in pleasant past events, both men crave for solace from people and die for redemption of their failures.
Ivan comes to the realization that all his achievements and pursuits for happiness did not any long-term satisfaction, but Willy constantly thinks of past
…show more content…
This proves unsuccessful as he finds himself unsatisfied in what mattered to him most in his life, his work, his house, and his relationships. When his job’s income cannot provide for his expenses one time, he sees that period of his life as “the most painful one in (his) life” ( 15) and goes out of his way to leave his highly reputable job just for a higher income. The job that he takes so much pride in and garners so much respect in distraughts him greatly with just the arrival of a miniscule problem. The house he spends so much time, effort, and passion on creating only agitates him when he sees that some furnitures are not perfect. His relationships with friends and family give him only loneliness and despair as no one cares much of his death. As he dies and his left alone in his home when his family go outside to enjoy their own social lives, he “longs to be petted, kissed, and wept over, as children are petted and comforted”, revealing that he never acquired personal love (37). He then understands that all he ever desired was mutual love and comfort from his friends and family during hardships. In …show more content…
In his death, Ivan realizes that his mannerisms in imitating people of high class leaves him with no true close relationships with his friends or family. From childhood to adulthood, his lives “with the approval of people of rank” (10), like marrying his wife only because everyone around him approved of their relationships. That leaves him with only hatred for his wife toward the end of his life and no family member to feel genuine love from. His colleagues care less about his death as seen when they brush off his funeral procession and go play cards instead of attending it. The lack of close relationships leaves him clinging to Gerasim for some comfort. When his family leaves to go out for dinner, he desperately desires for them to stay despite reassuring them to leave. Willy also is lonely as he wants to find someone to talk about his financial problems to. As he starts to fail in his job and becomes financially broke, he believes that he has no one to shoulder his problems with. Willy cannot tell Linda that he cannot make payments due to the fear of burdening her with more problems as shown when he continually says that “the woman (Linda) has suffered,” and does not want to tell Charlie due to his pride (Act 2 125). Instead, he confides in his affair with a woman for affection, stating to Biff that he only was in a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Willy Loman Failure

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Willy becomes jealous of Charlie’s achievements, maybe because Willy never obtained the American Dream he desperately chased his whole life. Charlie appears to be a caring neighbor for Willy, even paying for Willy’s bills when he can no longer pay for his own. Willy refuses to show Charlie any respect despite his kindness towards Willy, until in the last parts of the play when he comes to the realization that Charlie might be his own real friend left. Charlie also acts as the character of commonsense and reason, even proposing a reasonable solution to Willy’s financial…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The idea that one day we will all die is inevitable. Most individuals do not think about the future and death. We shrug this thought from our minds because we cannot predict the future. In some cases, some will say that they are young and that the idea of death, now, is preposterous. For others, that day may seem to be looming closer and closer as they advance into their 70s. Despite how you may feel about death, we can all concur that this will happen to all of us, and how we approach death, will vary from person to person. In the book “Tuesdays with Morrie” by Mitch Alborn and “The Death of Ivan Ilyich” by Leo Tolstoy paints the journey of two men and their inevitable date with the grim reaper. In the following paragraphs, I will discuss the similarities and the differences between the trials and conflicts, these men endured on their journey.…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Millions of people live ordinary life. These people, not marked with any advantages during their lifetime, struggle with daily challenges trying to survive in the world where money rules. However, it is hard to say that they are all unhappy because they all have different values and morals in their lives. The meaning of the happiness has its own face for every individual. For example, the birth of another baby in the family with low income will mean a blessing for some; for others, it will be another mouth to feed and extra expenses. People choose for themselves what happiness in their lives is. In the play “Death of a Salesman” by Arthur Miller the readers observe a life without the happiness and consequences of living the life in never ending pursuit of ghostly wealth trying to achieve their American Dream. Willy Loman, the main character of the play, in marathon of wealth and recognition in society, is ruining the lives of his…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Willy is often frustrated by the sudden changes in the work force- worrying him that he will soon meet his end as a salesman. He states, “There’s more people! That’s what’s ruining this country! The competition is maddening! Smell the stink from that apartment house! And the one on the other side…” (17). He believes that as more people populate, the competition for jobs drastically increase as they compete to gain Willy’s position removing him from the workforce. With all of his heightened madness, he is drawn to flashback to times when he was successful and joyful. Willy finds himself in a moment in which he has a resilient bond with his two sons - especially Biff, his oldest son. These moments of Willy’s escape relieve him and help him rethink the sudden discharge he just laid out. Miller’s insert of a flashback contrasts the two situations at hand, allowing one to be seen as the better option as Willy’s fear nearly terminates due to the flashback. Ultimately, this gives him reason to keep pursuing his long dream of being successful. The protagonist’s method in handling the drastic changes to the work force helps the display man’s inability to accept…

    • 1074 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At the beginning of the flashback, Willy is shown as talking to young Biff and Happy, and representing a more stereotypical parent than he appears in the present time scenes of the play. He is full of guidance, providing knowledge to his children, as a typical parent would, saying "Just wanna be careful with those girls Biff" which also shows a protective side to him. He also says "You want to watch your schooling first", as he knows what is better for his children, and looks out for them. This could also represent a calmer side to Willy, as he is not frustrated by his children, and instead calmly provides advice, allowing the audience to wonder why he has changed so much. However, some of his personality appears to be similar, as his mercurial…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Willy didn’t understand this he was so caught up in his own world were he was a salesman that he believed you needed money to be happy. He created this lie were he was a successful salesman in order to make it seem like he was happy. In his mind that was being happy and to a lot of people being financially stable is the ultimate goal, but loosing a loved one in doing so is the wrong way to go. He was so engulfed on the idea of failure that any success was considered happiness for him. He forgot about the meaning of family not that he didn’t love them but he forgot that being a family meant being a part of something bigger than yourself. And taking his own life was the only answer he new not knowing how his absence would affect the loved ones around him. He is dead due to a car crash and now one of his sons will use the money so his death can have some value. But Linda admits that they had finally paid the last bill for the house. Everybody knows that the house payments are one of the biggest payments someone will go through. And the fact that he took his life so close to that date brings up the question wheather those were his true intentions. Maybe he was weak and couldn’t live with himself any more and the life he provided his family was shameful enough for him to feel like nothing. He was a salesman and a salesman knows one thing better than anybody. And that’s investing money in order to…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is believed by many critics that this is Willy’s shortcomings and his own flaw that causes him to end up in such a tragic ending. In this case, J. I. Guijarro-Gonzalez and R. Espejo assert that:…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Willy's Flaws

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Even though Biff confessed to his father that he doesn't want to continue Willy’s dream, Willy misinterprets this. He exclaims, “‘He cried! Cried to me. He is choking with his love, and now he cries out his promise: That boy”’ (Miller 133). This shows how Willy was unable to resolve his flaw given the chance he had. If he resolved his flaw by coming to realize that Biff is suffering, he would of been able to resolve their relationship with each other. Taking his life after this reveals that he has nothing to rely on to achieve the American Dream. Before this, Willy showed signs of his suffering when Linda discovers that he is suicidal. When Linda was scolding Biff and Happy she mentions how Willy has been trying to take his life, “‘he wasn’t driving fast at all...he didn’t skid...deliberately smashed into the railing”’ (Miller 59). Willy shouldn’t push himself to death just because he isn’t able to be as successful as he hoped he would be. Willy resorts to death as the only way to try and resolve the situation he was in. When he is talking to Ben, he explains his the reason for his plan, “‘that funeral will be massive… that boy will be thunder-struck, Ben, he never realized- I am known!”’ (Miller 126). This reveals that Willy is willing to take drastic measures to try and fix his relationship with Biff when he could just take make easier for himself he just owned up to his…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although Willy loves his sons dearly, he is unable to get loved by them. When Biff calls Willy a “phony little fake” (Miller 121), Willy can not restrain that memory. He is not able to bear the fact that he is alone responsible for his son’s failure. “Depressed people have a tendency to blame themselves for the bad things that happen to them” (Silverstein 63). Willy is also in this state of guilt. He knows that Biff flunking math is his fault and just because of him, his son was unable to receive post-secondary education. Guilt is a difficult feeling to live with because a person’s conscience does not let them live in peace. When Willy returns to reality, he finds that “[his] boys left with the chippies” (Miller 121). Willy’s sons have abandoned their old father in a restaurant. At this point, Willy must feel unloved and uncared. When a person becomes so lonely, thoughts of suicide occur. Even though a person’s family cares about the life of their loved one, a person feeling left out may not think about that. Willy “has been involved in several inexplicable automobile accidents, and he has perhaps planned to asphyxiate himself” . . . (Lerner 45). When there is nothing worth living for a person will want to commit suicide. Linda supported Willy throughout his tough times but perhaps he did not think about her feelings. Willy has lost the quality of his life which is causing him to give up his life. After being abandoned in the restaurant, Willy asks “is there a seed store in the neighbourhood” (Miller 122)? This implies that Willy needs to start again with his family. Earlier in the play Linda tells Willy that the flowers will not grow because there is not enough sunlight. Despite this, Willy wants to plant seeds, and this indicates that he is not happy with his life. Willy is always setting goals that are unrealistic. A simple example of this would even be to expect…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ivan involuntarily enters into a pivotal search for a definite conception of the meaning of life. His sickness can be seen as sort of a coincidental remediation. When Ivan is forced to wrestle with the concept of his own death, he is brought face to face with the realization of his own isolation. This realization horrifies Ivan, and he responds by retreating into sober existential contemplation. As Ivan undertakes the examination of his own life, as he considers the reason for his existence, and the justification behind his misfortune, he starts to realize that his life was severely lacking in value and substance. Through Ivan’s affliction, he eventually discovers the true essence of life. At the climax of the story, when Ivan is passing into…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Death Of Ivan Ilyich Essay

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In Leo Tolstoy’s novella The Death of Ivan Ilyich, the reader experiences Ivan’s death as he looks back on his life and how he has lived it. The ideas I have mentioned above, such as the balance between your personal life and your official life and how honest you are with yourself, are explored through the story. Because Ivan lived by “what others said and did” and always “did what highly placed people considered right” (Tolstoy 51) whether it be in work, or marriage, or personal attributes, he was always afraid of death- afraid because he was never…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    American Dream Analysis

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages

    He dreamt and longed to be popular and well liked because why else would he lie to his family and Charley that he is popular. He told his boys that he had met the mayor and how the cops protected his car like their own, but he is wrong to go after this dream of popularity since in reality he is not liked at all. He told Linda that “people don’t seem to take”[pg.28] to him, they “laugh”[pg.28] at him and he is “not noticed”[pg.28]. The word ‘laugh’ insinuated the fact that people thought he was foolish and do not take him seriously. However Willy only revealed this self reflection for a few pages in the book, and then continued with his delusions. This dream ends up a failure because Willy did not realize that he wanted to change and hide the truth about himself. So he found personal security and contempt about himself through sexual infidelity. He had an affair with a ‘Woman’ who stroke his ego and made him feel good about himself. This later on ended up in a disaster because Biff surprised and caught Willy in the act. Biff exposed Willy to be a “fake”[pg.95]and lost all trust in his father. In going after the popularity dream it led to Willy making the wrong choice and ultimately destroying the relationship he had with…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Willy is closed-minded and cares more about having a well-known reputation and living the American dream than allowing his son to do what he loves. Willy wishes for his family to do economically better. Willy wants for his other son Happy to get married; this is ironic because Willy has a mistress. Willy gives two boxes of new stockings to his mistress while his wife is mending his stockings and struggles with money. As he calculates the amount of money needed for the bills, he realizes that his appliances break down before he can pay them off. He struggles to make ends meet and does not have enough money to pay bills. Willy encounters this conflict by relying on other and borrowing money. Willy lies and pretends that it is the money from his commission. Willy’s main internal conflict is with his mind; he has lost a sense of reality, and he realizes that his thoughts are strange. Mr. Loman says “Biff is lost” (1003N), it is ironic that Willy describes his son with the word “lost” when in reality, Willy 's lost in his mind. For example, when Mr. Loman drives off the road…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Just as my grandmother’s fear only came to her mind intensely as she actually felt death coming, Ivan Ilych feels the same. But near his final moments the character of Ivan “sought his old habitual fear of death and could not find it. Where was it? What death? There was no more fear because there was no more death. Instead of death there was light” (91). Once, Ivan reached his final moments of life, he then finally overcame the fear that haunted him in his experience of dying, and the fear disappeared to light. Once death hit Ivan, his fear vanished, and death was easy. Ivan Ilych has lived his whole life with a fear of death that he did not recognize. But he feared it, just like everyone else. It is not apparent until you actually believe that you are going to die. Although, he suffered before his death, he was prepared for his final moments on earth.…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His complexity comes from his unmoving characteristics with the opinions of others, the stubbornness and desperate nature that contradicts itself in his life. This can be seen with his interactions with Howard and his internal conflict of losing his job. As Willy attempts to reason with Howard his desperate nature emerges to simply, “set [his] table [with] fifty dollars a week,” which was a dramatic change from the sixty-five he was asking for a few lines before and more than the forty he asks for in later lines (Miller). As the lines continue Willy’s scene cues even come with notes such as, “desperately” and “desperation is on him now” (Miller). More of the stubborn side of his nature is revealed after Howard fires him and tells him to take, “a good long rest” (Miller). Willy instils into his mind that, because he must earn money he still has a job with Howard and he’ll “go to Boston tomorrow” (Miller). His conscience refuses to accept the fact he no longer has a job believing that he deserves the world for all that he believed he did in the past for the sales firm, “I averaged a hundred and seventy dollars a week” (Miller). Willy continues to live in his own mind in which he provides for his own image and…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays