Dbq Debate

Improved Essays
When considered within the context of the weak Articles of Confederation, the political divide between those who wanted a strong central government and those who wanted a weak central government played a key role in the 1780s in the United States. However, this disunity was not a crisis, but a catalyst for a debate and conversation that would center around the political ethos of the country. Many philosophies came out of this new conversation, with the most polarizing one being Federalism. Many of these new ideas would take center stage in Philadelphia at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, which was necessitated by this ideological split. Compromise between both sides of the debate allowed the Constitution to be completed and later ratified by all of the states in 1789, as there were aspects of the new American government that satisfied both the framers and the states. In 1821, James Madison …show more content…
Prior to The Great Compromise of 1787, the two main plans put forth at the Constitutional Convention were the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey Plan. The larger states favored the Virginia Plan, as the number of representatives in both houses of Congress per state was based strictly on population, giving them more power. The smaller states preferred the New Jersey Plan, which ensured that all states had the same number of votes. The Great Compromise, which became the basis of the new American government, was possible through the coming together of the small states and the large states. In this new plan, the number of representatives per state in the lesser House was based on population and the number of representatives in the upper House was the same for each state, satisfying both sides of the debate (Lapsansky-Werner, 356). Without this compromise, the Constitution would have looked very different, or perhaps would not have existed at

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Edmund Randolph of Virginia proposed the number of representatives for a state would be determined by the population and the amount of finances the state provides the federal government. This became known as the Virginia plan. The smaller state opposed the Virginia plan feeling they would be under represented and taken over by the larger states. William Paterson purposed a new plan, referred to as the New Jersey plan, suggesting each state would have equal representation regardless of size. Both sides found it hard to find compromise.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, this was not very popular option between the states, so a committee worked hard to come to an agreement that every state would give their approval on. In the end the Great Compromise was a combination of the Virgina and New Jersey Plans which has created our government system the United States currently uses.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the other american states closed their ports to British shipping, Connecticut wasted no time to profit by opening its ports The Confederation could not supply the unified front that john adams needed. And thus were the flaws in the articles revealed, and The Constitutional Convention was called to meet in Philadelphia in 1787 to resolve the issues the the original articles of confederation presented. The Articles of Confederation they looked at it and that this won 't work. It was clear to everybody involved that the articles were just not cutting it anymore. This statement marked the decision that resulted in the current constitution.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1787, a convention was held to assemble all of the fifty-five delegates at the Pennsylvania state house in Philadelphia. During this convention the New Jersey plan and the Virginia plan which were inherited from the Articles of Confederation were discussed. These two plans had different opinions on how the states were to be represented. The New Jersey plan called for equal representation between the thirteen states. While the Virginia plan called for representation by population.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Convention Dbq

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Large states supported this plan, and smaller states generally opposed it. The US would not be better off because smaller states would have a disadvantage and little say in the government. 8) Would the United States have been better off if the New Jersey Plan had been adopted? 9) The New Jersey Plan detailed a legislature of only one house and featured equal representation in which each state had the same number of representatives.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Great Compromise reconciled the differences between the Virginia and New Jersey plans, as well as resolving the debate over representation in Congress by creating a bicameral legislature with 1 house with proportional representation, creating 1 house with equal representation for all states, and allowing slave states to count each of their slaves as ⅗ of a white man. To begin, by having proportional representation in one house, the Great Compromise appealed to larger states and the Virginia Plan, which had suggested a bicameral legislature with proportional representation. In addition, the Great Compromise gave all states 2 delegates in the other house. This appealed to the New Jersey Plan, which suggested a legislature with one vote for…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Great Compromise was a huge compromise between New Jersey and Virginia. It was made up of those two states and how they had plans. The New Jersey plan was led by William Paterson. The government for this plan was based off of one single house for government. There was equal representation for all states.…

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These sources help us understand the post-Revolutionary era and the debate over the Constitution of 1787, because at the time that the American nation was still in its infancy, there was great debate over what would become the framework of the United States government that we know today, the Constitution. The nation was split between two groups, the Federalists, or the supporters of the Constitution, and the Anti-Federalists, who opposed it. There were three significant disagreements between the Federalists and Anti-Federalists, the first of which was the amount of power that the central government should have, as the two groups were torn between how to balance powers between the states and central government. The second was decision of whether…

    • 189 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Virginia plan, the first house would be selected be an amount of representatives based on the population. This gave bigger states with bigger populations more power so the smaller states did not like this plan. The other plan was the New Jersey Plan. This plan gave each state one vote or representative which would decide on the first house. The bigger states did not like this because they felt that they should have more power because of the larger population.…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Founding Fathers had a very difficult job. The delegates knew that they had to find a way to work together and be one united nation, and they knew that they needed one leader who would represent the whole country. Many of the delegates were afraid of giving a central government too much power, because they believed it would be no different than having a king. Very soon after the American revolutionaries completed the Articles of Confederation, they realized that the documents were inadequate to the task of unifying a diverse group of newly-independent colonies. A debate thus ensued, between the Federalist side, led by Alexander Hamilton and James Madison, and the Anti¬Federalists, led by Thomas Jefferson and Patrick Henry, over exactly…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During the Great Compromise American leaders had to decide what plan of action they should take when improving America’s weak government. State representation was a major controversy between the north and the south. In my personal opinion, I think that states should have a proportional representation in Congress according to its population also stated in the Virginia plan. The reasoning behind my conclusion is that, yes, some states are larger than others and may be split in opinion.…

    • 95 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On the other side the smaller states suggested that every state received the same number of representatives, this was known as the New Jersey Plan. Due to the constitutional convention not going anywhere the Connecticut Compromise or Great Compromise was suggested. While there are many powers that the Senate and The House Of Representatives share. There are also powers granted strictly to each chamber of the bicameral legislature.…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From around 1780 to around 1840, America struggled with the Constitutional Convention, Federalism and anti-federalism, the war of 1812 during the Jeffersonian age, the Jacksonian age, and the fight for equal right for all people living in America. Struggling through these events is what made America become the country it is today. In 1787, the Constitutional Convention was held in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. One of the major dissuasions at the Convention was how the states would be represented in the federal government. There were two main plans for the representatives.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another compromise was made regarding “the proper balance between the federal and state governments and between the interests of large and small states.” (p.258) First the Virginia Plan was suggested by Madison. In this plan, there was a two-house legislature, with representation in both houses based on state population. That was shut down due to the smaller states’ fear of larger states’ domination over the federal government.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This was a conflict between small and large states on whether who had the most power and if it was fair. The Virginia Plan was proposed by larger states to build a strong government with power based on the population of the state (Greenberg, 38). The New Jersey Plan was proposed by smaller states to build a strong government with more power than the article based on the equal representation in national legislature (Greenberg, 38). The Connecticut Compromise was than created at the Constitutional Convention where lower and upper house of legislature was determined from population and equal representation (Greenberg,…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays