Dualism In M Butterfly And Chen Kaige's Farwell My Concubine

Improved Essays
The transgender actions of the stage create a realm where there’s a dualism between reality and fiction. When a character is portrayed in a believable manner, it’s likely because the actor has assumed at least some of the characteristics of the part they are playing. The fault lies in the dichotomy of the stage; the physical aspects take place in the actual sense anchoring them in reality. However the movements, lines and even the emotions are calculated and derived to evoke imagination and the fantasy of the show. David Cronenberg’s M Butterfly and Chen Kaige’s Farewell My Concubine are films that explore the duality of the stage. Both films explore the idea of femininity, and what it means to “act” the part of being a woman. However, both films seem to embody the female, but only in regards to her male counterpart. They have created her character inside of patriarchal stereotypes, and have rejected the concept of the real woman in favor of the staged one. In Kaige’s Farwell My Concubine, the dichotomy between the staged woman and the real woman is heavily prevalent. Kaige’s portrayal of Dieyi is one that fits into a larger historical construct. Traditionally Peking Opera female impersonators were required to constantly imagine themselves to be women. This is evident throughout Farewell My Concubine as Dieyi seemed to not only imagine but truly believe in his own feminity. After being essentially beaten into submission, Dieyi finally …show more content…
It’s in this assumed role that the gender of the character can be explored. Both Farewell My Concubine and M Butterfly, have explored the gender roles of their characters. Both films exploration of the female femininity is exemplified and embraced, however only in regards to her male counterpart. The films seem to favor the idealized version of what a woman should be rather than who she actually

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the 1953 western-musical parody Calamity Jane the butch heroin, Jane Canary (Doris Day) undergoes a makeover, by imitating Katie Brown (Allyn McLerie), to become a feminine female; thus engaging into a heterosexual romance with Bill Hickock (Howard Keel) (cf. Mizejewski 185). Katie Brown an aspiring, burlesque singer and dancer, whom Jane mistakes as the famous hyper feminine Adelaid Adams (Gale Robbins), helps Jane to transition from a masculine cowboy into a real and proper woman, by confronting Jane with her own inadequate gender performance. Bill Hickock as the embodiment of a hyper masculine male authenticity shames Jane “to consolidate [a] normative, ‘feminine’ identity” (Savoy 169) in order to shape her character specifically to a “gradual conformity to heterosexual expectations of the feminine”, according to “what her culture regards as the ‘real woman’ (Savoy 165). I claim that Jane Canary’s object of affection is an arbitrary choice, according to gender normativity and that in fact Jane’s secret love is Katie Brown.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fresh Bait is a short story written by Sherryl Clark. It is aimed at teenagers going into adult hood and doesn’t necessary lean towards any particular gender. Sherryl is an author based on writing children’s books since 1996 and now mostly writes short stories and personal essays, as well as poems for adult readers. (Sherryl Clark, 2014) Sherryl now has more than 50 published books, with Fresh Bait being published in 2007.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    While the majority of Bacon’s “Idols” that “beset” our minds and lead to error are present in Plautus’ play, Double Bind, the Idols of the theater is the most prevalent “Idol” with regards to how male characters both discuss and engage with female characters. The Idols of the theater are used as methods for understanding, which are dramatized (in that they are generalizations or stereotypes), unreal, and are made up or false, all of which ultimately lead to some form of error. Double Bind plays into the stereotypes of women as inherently less than men as they are considered idiotic and stupid, promiscuous, and crazy. This connects to the Idols of the theater because the male characters only see the predominant female characters, such as Dovey and Loveykins, in terms of generalizations or stereotypes of their gender. Male characters in Double Bind, such as Clueless One, Clueless Two, Antiquides, Smug, and Diddley not only discuss females as a generalized form of error, but they also engage with the females in a manner…

    • 1602 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Savagery In The Odyssey

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Savagery is defined as the quality of being fierce or cruel by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Savagery is seen in everyday life, from bullying in school to physical torture to murder. However, there does seem to be a difference between the brutality of men and women. When thinking back to a more primitive time, it was a male’s job to hunt and kill while females had a more protective role. The difference between men's and women's cruelty is that women are more defensive in their savagery while men tend to be more aggressive.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender roles have been engraved in our society and our culture. It 's an idea that has been accepted and taught generation after generation and is the ideal of what is expected of us accepted individuals. There are the gender roles assigned to men of being strong, and being good providers. For many generations, the definition of being a good father was of being a good provider. Women have their set of gender roles, of being dainty, pure, timid, homemakers, submissive, subservient.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drag Queen Gender Roles

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages

    I struggle to understand why anyone would go and see a drag queen play a leading lady in musical theatre.” (Barnes, 2015. 119) The purpose of this dissertation is to discuss the portrayal of drag queens within musical theatre and how, if any, societies perceptions have changed over the last 40 plus years. This research will be revised between 1970 to the present day, which will include case studies from three major plays/films and one television show.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the Act starts these images flicker so if one was not paying attention to their surroundings they become acutely aware at the women staring down upon the birthday party. Crowley created a cast of characters of gay men who embody the spectrum of personalities, however the only way the feminine perspective (homosexual or otherwise) is represented is through Bernard’s comment about how Emory, the most effeminate man is the one referred to being “at the bottom of the Totem pole.” In fact, he is the only one of the play that was physically assaulted. This shows that queer history mirrors heterosexual…

    • 1918 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Borrowing the genre of melodrama, Almodóvar’s award-winning film, All About My Mother (1999), features transgender and post-queer study of sexuality. Apart from presenting two pre-op transgenders, the film renders a variety of “abnormal” intimate relationships, including the protagonist, Manuela’s family without a father, Huma’s ultimately failed lesbian relationship with Nina, and the family formed at the end of the film, constituted by Manuela, Rosa’s baby, and queer girlfriends. These unusual forms of intimacy disturb the hereto-sexist institutions, e.g. marriage and family. Portraying gender, sexuality, and identity as unfixed, the film mocks the conventional perception by interweaving the theatrical performance with the real life: On the one hand, the fixity and stereotype of femininity and masculinity are fostered by cinematic representations, exemplified by Hollywood productions; On the other hand, the reference to…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Aesthetic of Astonishment: Early Film and the (In)Credulous Spectator”, Tom Gunning argues that the first people who watched Lumiere’s Arrival of a Train at the Station were not in shock because they believed that the train was real, they were astonished by the illusion they witnessed before them on the screen. In contrary to the myth that people feared that they were going to be killed by a train, Gunning stresses that the Audiences’ astonishment was derived “from a magical metamorphosis”(Gunning, 119). This metamorphosis is essentially cinema itself and the illusions it produces on screen. Gunning calls cinema a “magic theatre”(Gunning,117) where filmmakers strived to make the impossible, appear believable through visual representations.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These characters show reversal, and disregard, of gender roles throughout the novel. The gender reversal the audience is given is not a negative thing. Alexandra is a strong woman. There is nothing that she needs from a man she does not even marry until the very end of the novel. American literature almost always shows some sort of controversy with gender roles.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Legally Blonde: A Meditation of Stereotypes Gender stereotypes are simplistic. Stereotypes do not bother to take account of the thoughts, behaviors, and individual desires of a person, merely taking interest whether or not the person is male, female, or nonbinary. In film franchises, such as Legally Blonde, writers and directors insist on propagating stereotypes despite the ongoing evolvement of archetypes in current society. Although in the final moments of the flick, Elle Woods surpasses such stereotypes and displays aberration, the number of cliches in the movie serves to reinforce negative gender identities.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not only do male protagonists vastly outnumber females in most narratives, but also gender-stereotyped portrayals dominate. By giving a female a protagonist/ dominate role, it attracts more audiences that involve…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Sweet Girl Graduate by Sarah Curzon focuses on this specific representation of gender where the heroine of the play is attempting to comply to societal norms by cross-dressing in order to receive a higher education. The heroine is obliging to the gender hierarchy that exists, and as a result, this portrays the heroine as someone who is attempting to break away from male dominance, while at the same time accepting it as women were expected to. The representation of gender roles in The Sweet Girl Graduate creates a contradictory perception of what women are meant to achieve in the play, and this is due to the portrayal of the heroine as a free individual; however, at the same time she is subjected to follow the status quo forced…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Epitome of Masculinity There is no grey area when dealing with the expectations of men and women in a tribalistic society; there is only black or white. Men and women are on completely different ends of the spectrum regarding how society perceives them. In the Igbo culture, men are considered the head of family and society while women are considered caretakers and are subordinate to men. Men are expected to have an active and aggressive personality while women, however, are expected to be subservient and passive. These expectations shape how society is supposed to be and influence the decisions of individuals.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “It is clear throughout the film that when difficult decisions must be made, they must be made by a man. This message, like the reassertions of feminine gender norms off the pitch and masculine norms on it, serves to undermine the progressive messages of the film.” (Abdel-Shehid 150.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics