Darkest Hour Analysis

Improved Essays
It is often debated whether or not films can be used as a historical source. People such as Ian Jarvie, an English philosopher, argue that films are nothing more than mere entertainment. He said that “At best, film is a visual aid.”. On the other hand, you have people like French theorist, Pierre Sorlin, who said that “historians have admitted for a long time that films are important pieces of evidence for any study of the twentieth century and it is no longer necessary to justify an incursion into this field”.

Films can be used as a historical source because they can put the audience in the time and in the setting of the event that the film is portraying. Films such as Dunkirk and Schindler’s List, while not completely true, put the audience
…show more content…
Churchill was an ex-senior official in the British Army, who then sat on the House of Commons, and in 1940 became Prime Minister of Great Britain. Great Britain were going through a rough patch at the time of his appointment, Germany were about to invade France, and the country did not trust then Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain to lead them through the war.

The movie starts with Chamberlain resigning, which occurred on the 10th of May 1940. Despite doubt from a lot of the Conservative Party, who wanted Viscount Halifax as leader, the senior officials recommended Churchill to King George VI, who then appointed Churchill as Prime
…show more content…
The film has made up dialogue, such as the war cabinet scenes, where arguments erupt over peace negotiations. It also overdramatizes a ‘feud’ between Halifax and Churchill, which wasn’t exactly the case. This provides no use to historians as it is factually not true, meaning that there is nothing to learn from these scenes and lines. The film also has a sense of British patriotism, meaning that there is a bias towards the British in the events shown throughout the film. This also provides no use to historians, as the bias towards the British alters the facts of what happened in these events. Overall, there are instances of uselessness as a source for historians in the film, due to the use of false dialogue, over dramatization, and bias.

To conclude, Darkest Hour has parts that can be a source to historians, but overall cannot be considered a source due to the false dialogue, over dramatization and bias. The film doesn’t really address historical reliability, but what it does, however, is show that the story is always told by the

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    However, this misleads the audience as it distorts the reality that was actually seen with then Dani people. On some level, this dramatizes the events and cultural norms of the tribes in the area. Also, because of technological limitations and Gardner choosing a better picture quality camera, there was no sync sound being recorded. The audio had to be separately assembled, some while they were on site, while others were added later on (Bishop, 478). Watching the film itself, one most likely could not distinguish that the sound was not diegetic.…

    • 1843 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the evolution of technology rapidly increasing and becoming more and more advanced, in correlation, the accepted knowledge concerning film and media are also changing just as fast. Since the birth of the cinema and Hollywood style movies, many philosophers and theorists have shared their knowledge concerning film theory. However many theories are having to be updated and even ruled out due to the advancement in technology. For many years these theories were commonly accepted with minor changes. Not only does technology affect film through technical and aesthetic ways, but it also has awoken many questions involving political correctness and the reflection of film in popular culture.…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    White House Reaction

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the case of the Iraqi conflict, Rumsfeld and Cheney were working alone, shutting out other political figures, to further their own interest. In doing this, their policies were primarily egoistic and therefore ineffective in the long run. There are some who say the rational actor model is beneficial when dealing with these self-interest groups. But in my opinion, the rational actor model does not account for egocentric players. These people do not make decisions on cost/benefit for the group as a whole, but rather for themselves alone.…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dunkirk Analysis

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages

    An adaptation that follows too closely in the footsteps of its source material will be pointless, one that departs to much can't be said to be an adaptation at all. But we must allow for Directors to take risks, otherwise we'll be left with direct adaptations. Sure, sometimes you get watchmen and yet other times you get World War Z, which has so little in common with the book; the author said "QUOTE". Both of these two sides make terrible…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He noted in resignation, war is neither heroic nor glamorous. It is messy, very disruption, and especially corrupts the morality of individuals. War is an event that can not be justified. Vonnegut is able to show the readers what war is like, even if it is conveyed through untidy themes. Furthermore, it is sensible to mention that Vonnegut’s literature is not able to actualize the depiction of such catastrophic event that takes part in reality.…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hitler also began to violate terms in the Treaty of Versailles, which wasn’t discussed in Rivero’s argument. In a quick search a focus point of Riveros’s argument was easily refuted because his opponent had multiple pieces of evidence, not just once select event, to support their argument. This helps solidify my view on Rivero’s argument, although well worded with factual evidence to support it, isn’t a full argument. He doesn’t include a counter claim which…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Winston Churchill, one of the greatest war leaders in the world failed the entrance exam twice at the Royal Military College at Sandhurst (Thompson). Winston Churchill was known for his career as Prime Minister of England during World War II (Thompson). Before World War II and before Winston Churchill was Prime Minister, he spoke and wrote, trying to warn the world and his nation about Nazi Germany (Thompson). While Europe was conquered, England was the final standing country against the Nazis (Thompson). During the turmoil in Britain, Winston Churchill inspired the British people to “‘their finest hour’” (Thompson).…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moore also tends to oversimplify complex problems. Near the end of the film he makes it clear that he believes capitalism is the opposite of a democracy, and does not support it. He uses many examples to get his point across and is very thorough at times. However, he does not recommend socialism and he does not think that Obama has brought significant change. Instead of stating what he wants to see changed, he shames corporations that he believes exploit Americans.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, not only is it unfair to expect perfection of historical accuracy in films, it is impossible. This can be attributed to multiple factors. Firstly, Bluestone argues that content of a film and novel cannot be expected to transpose from one medium to another (Preface VIII). This is because the two mediums differ vastly from each other. Therefore, it is problematic to compare the two.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Something that is utilized a lot is camera tracking. It allows the audience to move with the character in movie and makes them feel like they are a part of the action and conversation. The viewer is not just watching the character go someplace, they are going there with them. This creates a more dramatic feel to what is happening because it makes it personal. Another factor that adds to the personalization of the film is that DiCaprio talks to the viewer while the camera is following him.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays