Reflection On Mcniff's Cycles Of Plan-Do-Review

Superior Essays
McNiff’s diagram inspired me to construct my own illustration of practice. I have attempted to show how my numerous research cycles has linked, each informing the practice of the next whilst also depicting how the process has supported the strengthening of my identity as a leader. The need to construct such a map of my journey directed me to look more closely into the differences I experienced between my personal, professional and academic identity.

The diagram shown in figure 5 shows how I chose also to work in cycles of ‘plan-do-review’, in a reflective cycle, then before moving on, investigating the problems and outcomes of interventions. Each cycle tests and informs me as a leader with each creating multiple cycles of enquiry depicting
…show more content…
In the ‘grand theory’ approach, theory precedes practice (Hopkins 1993). Here theory is defined as more or less separated from the concrete concerns of everyday life. In a ‘theorising approach’, the reverse is true and practice precedes theory. As a result of experience and at times the collection of data from the classroom, teachers theorise on its meanings for them and their colleagues. They engage in a critical evaluation of the experience, construct a plan and then implement that plan with a view to improvement. Those engaged in educational theory control the knowledge they are creating from their own actions. In this way the knowledge is used to inform practice as opposed to the assumption that the knowledge provided is appropriate for any situation. Hopkins (1983:72) describes this as being part of the process ‘discovering self-knowledge’. This allows the researcher not only to understand their world but it also empowers them to use that knowledge in their professional lives ‘to improve …show more content…
They pointed out that often work done by academics is published in journals generally not read by this important audience. The points made by Hargreaves and Rose would be absolutely true in respect of my own experience as a practitioner, up to the point of engaging in research myself.

More directly concerned with my living theory, action research is argued to open opportunities for practitioners to be involved in research, which has immediate relevance. An action research-living theory approach further supports practitioners, providing the opportunity to critically reflect on their own practice clarifying the meanings of any explanatory values. Working and researching in this way can lead to a deeper understanding of the researcher as an individual providing a deeper understanding and more significant contribution to informed practice.
“The strength of the action research approach to professional development rests upon a creative and critical dialogue between members of a community which includes teachers, academics, parents, industrialists, and politicians. We move ahead through creative leaps of imagination. We learn from our mistakes in detailed criticisms of our positions.” 
(Whitehead and McNiff,1988:

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    When these things are in place it will help self-assessment, reflection, collaboration and conversation happen. Self-assessment is essential in promoting teacher learning. The best way to improve in the future is to learn from your past. Teachers must evaluate their teaching then pursue conversations with other professionals where multiple angles can emerge on a situation. This will in turn allow teachers to grow in their teaching practices.…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, I learned to be a consumer of research in 590 and 611. This practice of critical evaluation will be essential as I move forward in my career and education, but it also can apply to everyday consumption of controversial reporting, evaluation of political debates, or assessment of a new proposal at work. I learned both hard skills, like the ability to use instructional technology, and soft skills, like communication with stakeholders and subject matter experts. I take away from this program an understanding of methods for designing instruction, from secondary curriculum to user experience to performance improvement, the necessary skills to help contribute on a team, and lifelong critical thinking…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Part A. Reflective practice literature review Introduction The assignment is devoted to teacher self-reflection which is acknowledged to be one of the moves that will lead to development and professionalism. Part A looks firstly at theory of reflection in general and then how it works in teaching. It points why reflection is essential in teaching practice and presents different ways of reflections as well as different levels of reflection. Whereas part B, presents more practical use of reflection and how it was used by me. 1.…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In order to build a relationship, we have to know where each other is coming from and figure how to best our intentions and ideas to that particular individual. The purpose of communication is getting to know one another better, to reach common understanding and to agree on what action is required. You will have a better understanding of each other and your habits. Indeed, a skilled communicator must be aware of these barriers and try to reduce their impact by continually checking understanding and by offering appropriate feedback. Your ability to recognize communications issues and come to a resolution can significantly improve your relationship and learn more about…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I am better able to empathize and understand the difficulties of others because of the difficulties I have faced. I want to help people name their struggles and empower themselves with knowledge. The best place for me to do that would be in an inpatient or outpatient facility. That intense, high-energy environment would allow me to utilize my strengths while also keeping me interested and driven. Being a part of research and the development of effective diagnostic assessments and treatments is something I have a passion for and my creative thought processes will guide me to new discoveries.…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By researching, we were able to create an efficient design because we were able to see what works and what doesn’t and what is necessary and what isn’t. I also learned about how to collaborate and cooperate with group members. My group members and I always had clashing ideas. But we had to learn to overcome this by talking it out. I learned that to achieve a common goal, you have to get rid of personal interest and build upon other’s ideas.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lecture Reflection

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages

    We are asked to share our opinions and discuss the problems faced by us with Professor Daniel. Along with that, I got the important messages regarding a good research must be researchable where it able to apply in past with the current issue and it must be interesting so that the readers does not get bored. I noticed the problems in the research must be explained and an appropriate research design must be chosen. Reliability and validity of the research also is very important so that the findings can be accurate and the limitation of research must be stated. Besides, I also learnt to differential the conceptual framework which is an analytical tool with several variations and contexts used to make conceptual distinctions and organize ideas while for the theoretical framework which is the structure that can hold or support a theory of a research study.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To combat this, teachers need to modify their teaching style. They should focus on actually teaching the material, instead of instructing students on how to take a test. This is imperative in the development of an educated population. Ultimately, to be educated is to have a desire to gain knowledge, and thus it is imperative to create an open, safe, and interesting atmosphere in an educational facility. A person who is educated has different qualities that enable them to acquire knowledge.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That is to say it emphasizes the students’ role in cognition without neglecting the guiding role of teachers. When a person links the new knowledge with the knowledge existed, the constructive process is a kind of meaningful learning. Teaching is not to teach the textbook knowledge, but to help students construct the gradually deepening understanding and knowledge structure based on personal knowledge and experience. The key of constructive learning is to create an initiative, cooperation inquiry-learning atmosphere. The constructive view on evaluation has the following characteristics.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He further added that being able to reflect on one’s own teaching requires the teacher to make meaning from the teaching situation so that he could better understand the art of teaching practice. Richards (1996) further corroborated by mentioning the steps needed to be taken by teachers in which they would collect data about teaching, examine their attitudes, beliefs, assumptions and teaching practices and these are utilized for critical reflection to occur. Richards (1996) and Loughran’s (2002) echoed Schon’s (1987) sentiments, which think reflection is central to a teachers’ professional growth. Reflective practice is more than just thinking about what to do in teaching and learning; it requires the teacher to take a step back and re-examine their decisions, be it their pedagogy or classroom management, to be implemented in their next…

    • 3094 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays