Mosse's Ethnography Of Human Development Report

Superior Essays
Cultivating Development is an innovative contribution to the ethnography of development.. Mosse’s argument is thought-provoking and serves to provide a helpful bridge between both the popular expectation of development organizations to be comprised of charitable, purely altruistic workers and the critical, post-modern narrative of the wholly politically-driven aid monolith (most influentially driven by the works of Ferguson and Escobar). While Mosse illuminates a portion of development work previously unstudied in totality (the aid project), his main arguments are under-supported, seek to frame the development organization as a somehow different operation than any other sort of organization, and ignore the interests of workers at different …show more content…
Coming out of a period of increased scrutiny on development organizations and a string of critics deriding the top-down approach of Western development organizations, the project sought to include the perspectives beneficiaries. At the outset an experimental project, the design team aimed to pilot a new model of development project hinged on the participatory approach, involving community-wide meetings, special attention to marginalized residents (women and the poor), and mediation between villagers and government officials. Mosse’s main argument is that development practice is not driven by policy, but rather supports it. He expands on this statement through five propositions about the nature of the relationship between policy and practice in development …show more content…
Chapters 6 & 7 deal with the production of success within and outside of development projects, depending on the prevailing interests and narratives of the development organization and irrespective of ‘real’ results on the ground. Mosse seems to lament that consultant expertise (such as his own) was used to “stabilize frameworks of interpretation” and “generalize models” outward rather than generating practices and exacting operational control (18). The position of the consultant was such that they were consistently speaking upward, to the donor, rather than downward to project staff and beneficiaries (134). Halfway through the project, ODA official policy shifted causing many of the project staff and consultants to scramble to revise project documents and official statements to reflect the shift in policy (176). Rather than scrutinizing and shaping project practice, the “ODA’s interest was in the project as a coherent rationalizing policy idea,” something that they could package, model, and export according to the prevailing interest; thus, to maintain the representation of success which the project had previously garnered great support of, ODA asked the project merely to modify its theory in order to jive with the newest thinking

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Foreign Aid Limitations

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The limitations on Foreign Aid include whether or not it is effective, deciding between a planner and searcher, and misallocation of provided aid by government officials. The billions of dollars that have been collected worldwide, and specifically designated to foreign aid, have been abused by politicians in developing countries and in turn, have registered as not generating an economic growth or negatively affecting a developing country’s economy. The big argument within economics and foreign aid is whether or not it is effective. Economists argue for both sides; however, with no sufficient amount of concrete evidence it is impossible to determine which claim is true.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Worldwide population growth is an issue that grows more and more urgent with each passing day. Our earth is nearing its capacity, and its important that we address this issue to avoid a worldwide state of emergency. Garrett Hardin and Clark Wolf both discuss this issue in detail, and offer their own solutions on how we should solve this problem. However, while Hardin presents a valid view of our world population problems, Wolf provides a more well rounded argument, and goes further to provide reasonable, effective solutions that target the true source of the issue. Garrett Hardin, in his essay “Lifeboat Ethics,” describes the problem of current world population growth, and how we are making this already very serious issue even worse by living…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    PAD 510 Final Exam Solution All Possible Questions http://homeworkyahoo.com/downloads/pad-510-final-exam-solution-possible-questions/ To Buy this tutorial Copy & paste above link in your Brower PAD 510 Final Exam Solution All Possible Questions Question 1 The Streams Metaphor is associated with which scholar? Question 2 “Pork barrel” spending is most closely associated with which policy type? Question 3…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Entertainment Education Theory, is a strategy when the media message is purposely designed and implemented to entertain and educate to increase the audiences knowledge about an educational issue, shift social norms, create positive attitudes, and to change the behavior of individuals and communities. Another way to explain the entertainment education theory is that it contains content that is mostly educational but has incidental entertainment value, and content that is mostly entertaining but contains educational value. Topics that tend to use “edutainment” are teen pregnancy, immunization, substance abuse, etc. This theory can be used for public communication campaigns that want to see both, education and entertainment in their campaign. Entertaining people is an easy way to add learning, and it also gets more peoples attention.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When faced with the brutal and tragic reality of poverty around the world, humanitarians are compelled to act and earnestly ask, “What must we do to end global poverty?” Despite the sincerity of many experts, common development practices utilize authoritarian means which trample on the individual rights of the people afflicted by poverty. Easterly calls the reader to debate the merits of these methods against their counter—free development, which holds liberty, rather than economic stability, as the ultimate end. The first facet of the development debate is examining the Blank Slate approach, as opposed to considering and learning from history.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the “The Tyranny of Experts,” William Easterly explores the idea of poor individuals and development approaches. With examples and historical evidence, Easterly comes to the conclusion that to end the problem of poor countries/people and to pursue economic development is to give rights to the poor and treat them equally. Easterly provides four debates, the blank slate versus learning from history, nations versus individuals, conscious versus spontaneous solutions, and authoritarian versus free development, that experts need to pursue and understand. Easterly argues that development experts have relied on the Blank Slate instead of learning from history. Experts have a Blank Slate view that sees country’s history as irrelevant to the country.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although it might seem that this week’s topics have different themes, I think all of them had a common background; motivation related to the political forces that shape our world. From the passage of King’s Leopold’s Ghost that shows how powerful nations certainly shape trade and progress; to the fundamental issue of why and how the current notion of development was created; to the issues of how development plans interact and affect the less favored nations. It is unquestionable that the common denominator is how political forces are fundamental to understand all of situations in the readings. In this sense, King Affonso’s dilemma with the Portuguese emperor Don Joao about slavery trade and how its population was being affected is a very powerful…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. What is the author trying to convey/suggest with the title? (what does the title mean?) Elizabeth Pisani is trying to convey the variation of sexual experience and the savvy that attaches to it. 2.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genocide In Darfur

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Jeffrey Sachs is a professor of economics and a director of the Earth Institute at Columbia University. He writes an opinion piece titled “No Development, No Peace.” It is an issue generated by the ongoing genocide in Darfur. Darfur is a region located in the western part of Sudan in the continent of Africa. Since 2003 when the issue started till today, over 480,000 people have been killed and over 2.8 million have been displaced a data reported by world without genocide, a nonprofit organization.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laura Augustin’s ‘Sex at the Margins’ (2007), and Jerker Edstrom’s 2010 article ‘Time to Call the Bluff’ highlight similar barriers to effective development programs. Augustin challenges imperialism in international aid, particularly concerning prostitution. Her work discusses Western aid workers’ desire to impose their own morals and control those that they help, for example, determining what aid is received (Augustin, 2007). Edstrom notes similar issues within HIV/AIDS interventions: Westerners giving aid suited to their own culturally-specific morality, hindering its effectiveness (2010).…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    At the very basic level, a democratic structure can be defined as an ‘institutional arrangement for arriving at political decisions in which individuals acquire the power to decide by means of a competitive struggle for the people’s vote’ (Schumpeter 1942 cited in Menocal 2007). The positive relationship between prosperity and democracy has an enduring relationship in the subject of social sciences. Although there does exist a strong correlation, it does not necessarily mean causation.…

    • 1947 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Stop Trying to Save the World” The article “Stop Trying to Save the World” is about social projects, the called NGOs, which have the objective to help poor people to get better conditions to live. The author Michael Hobbs, who has experience in the subject, shows how these projects are not well thought and most of times do not work in the way they are supposed to, because there is a lack of vision, and how they end up hampering the international development. According to him, he wants to undo the concept of the “Big Idea”, which is “once we identify the correct one, we can simply unfurl it on the entire developing world like a picnic blanket” (Hobbs). That is, most of times the projects are applied in a whole based just in a result of one…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within her book, we should all be feminist, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie tells anecdotes of what it is like to be a young feminist in Africa, she speaks at one point of the ‘helpers’ found in major cities around the continent, often young men who offer to help the wealthier park cars in the congested metropolitan area. To stand out, these young men add some theatrics to the service they provide. These young Nigerian men are not the only ones who add theatrics to helping others. There are often questions of organizations around the world and whether the methods they utilize are helping women in developing countries or whether they are merely using theatrics to make it look like they are helping those on the international stage. This is especially…

    • 2326 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In this paper I will provide an analysis of a developmental interview, I performed on April 10, 2016, for about 20 minutes. My interviewee, Joan Murray agreed to sit down with me in conversation and answer a few questions about her life. This opportunity gave me the chance to explore developmental themes and think about how to apply developmental theory in live situations. I will demonstrate my ability to integrate principles I have learned over the past 12 weeks and put them into practice. I will articulate the stages of human development of my interviewee from the lens of Carol Rogers’ person-centered therapy approach, and the faith development of my interviewee from the lens of James Fowlers’ faith development stages, thereby describing…

    • 3696 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Given that inequality can be measured on different scales- not only across but also within countries- what are the implications for how we define and measure development? Answer using both theory and examples The 20th and 21st Century has seen remarkable developments in geography, perhaps most notably around development. As with many topics within the subject, development involves a myriad of complexities and its definition varies temporally and spatially (Willis, 2014). As Fraser (2010) notes, it is extensively acknowledged that many inequalities exist on a variety of scales, from global to local.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays