Culpability Of Children As Adults Essay

Improved Essays
It is a fact that the cognitive development of a young person is not complete until they are in their early twenties. They do not have the ability of adults to understand long term consequences of bad actions. The connections in the brain literally are not there yet. Holding a 12 year old to the same standard as a 30 year old when they don't have the same mental development is wrong. Punish yes but throw away the key no. Europe considers you a juvenile till 21 or even 25 and don't try children as adults. Funny how we refer to a 16 year old as a child who doesn't know what they are doing when they have sex but a 12 year old knows all when they do something horrible.

The belief by some that minors commit crimes now because unfortunate situation of these youths taking advantage of the time when they are young to commit more violent acts knowing that the punishment will be light. Minors know the difference between right and wrong.
…show more content…
This symbolizes society's recent shift toward taking a tougher view of adolescents' culpability.
In 18th century America, little distinction was made in the criminal culpability of children versus adults. Juveniles as young as age six would be tried and sentenced in criminal courts. As psychologists and sociologists began to recognize the emerging conception of adolescence as a developmentally distinct period of life, activists argued that minors should be removed from adult penitentiaries.

In the 1990s several states have adopted a "get tough" approach to juvenile justice as a response to the increasingly violent crimes committed by children. As of 2003 many states had adopted legislation that permits more children to be tried as adults. All states have a provision allowing prosecutors to try juveniles as young as 14 as adults under certain circumstances. In a few states such as, Indiana, South Dakota, and Vermont, children as young as 10 can be tried as

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Children committing heinous crimes are not a rare occurrence anymore; the upsetting reality requires new tactics for dealing with young juveniles. Some Americans believe children should be tried as adults, yet others feel that they are too young to understand their wrong doings. In most conditions minors are quickly told they are too young or too old for something, however before being sent to an adult facility we need to contemplate all aspects of the case in order to decided whether or not being tried as an adult is necessary. Regardless of the crime, some people feel that an adult facility is not a suitable environment for children to serve their sentences.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the modern legal system, most jurisdictions view a person as an adult at 18 years of age. Until a person reaches this age, they are less likely to receive the full extent of a jurisdiction’s legal system. At certain parts in a child’s life, age can be used as a valid defense. If a person is under 7 years of age, they will not be charged in most jurisdictions. From the age of 7 to the age of responsibility, which is usually recognized as 16 but varies by jurisdiction, an offender can be tried in the juvenile system (criminal Law Today).…

    • 1739 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consequently, they are more prone to risk taking and peer influence than adults; they think less about their future and express their emotions in more volatile ways. The juvenile system recognizes this distinct adolescent nature, and allows for recovery through developmentally appropriate programs, making young adults under eighteen better suited for the juvenile system rather than the adult system. However, when young law-breakers murder or rape someone, it is much more difficult call on whether they should be tried as adults or juveniles. The decision should be made on a case-by-case basis, depending on the severity, motive, and nature of the crimes. For example, a sixteen-year-old boy murdering his father to protect his sister warrants a different analysis than a case of a remorseless sixteen-year-old boy who murdered a mother and her two young children to steal a car.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Juvenile crime has been an increasing point of debate in recent years. Many people argued whether they should be sentenced as adults or not when convicted of a serious crime, such as murder. Some argue that juveniles deserve to be treated as such despite the crime they have committed, while others believe they are to be treated as adults. This resulted in many juveniles receiving adult sentences like life in prison without parole. Some juveniles commit crimes without a thought of the risks, while some carefully plan out their crimes and get a serious thrill out of it.…

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    By definition a juvenile is “A person who is not yet old enough to be legally considered an adult” (Merriam Webster Dictionary). Despite this definition, America chooses to try juveniles as adults. Juveniles who commit certain violent crimes are subjected to being imprisoned in adult facilities. These violent crimes are known as the seven deadly sins and include murder, voluntary manslaughter, rape, aggravated sexual battery, aggravated sodomy, aggravated child molestation and armed robbery with a firearm. Over 200,000 juveniles are charged in adult courts every year in the United States and should not be (Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults? 11).…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is not the kids that are doing it, it's the parents that are not helping their kids. “Kids need parents, not a part-time person in their life.” In simplest detail, It is not the kids' job to be parenting themselves it is the parents' job. Know while some kids have commited attempts of murder, or actual murder itself, they are kids and don’t understand what they are doing is wrong, yes they should definitely be punished, just not as harsh and extreme in some way, as adults. Taking examples of other kids who are extremely dangerous, they know the risk and understand what they are doing is wrong.…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Juveniles in American societies should encounter the responsibility and consequence of being tried as adults, despite their age, when committing unspeakable, heinous crimes. In Richard A. Serrano’s article, Young killers serving life without parole may get chance at freedom, he introduces reasons why it is acceptable for juveniles to be tried as adults. Seranno lists, seventeen-year-old Johnny Freeman “raped a five-year-old and tossed her from a fourteenth-story window,” sixteen-year-old Peter Saunders “bludgeoned an elderly woman, then from prison mailed a bomb-like device to a judge,” and sixteen-year-old David Biro “marched a husband and his pregnant wife down their basement stairs and shot them both” (Serrano, paragraph 12). Although…

    • 2180 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile law is typically governed by the state and most states set the age for criminal culpability at eighteen (deferring between seventeen and nineteen in some cases) (Walsh, 2016). The founders of the juvenile court saw it as “a system of justice that would protect youth from potential harms of adult court and that seek to not only punish but also to advance the ‘best interests’ of youth.” The juvenile court, unlike adult court, is guided by parens patriae, which is Latin for “state as parent.” The juvenile court is set up to act as the parent and it can punish and dismiss cases how it seems is appropriate, while also seeking to help juveniles in a way that can lead them to live productive lives (Mears, Kuch, Lindsey, Siennick, Pesta, Greenwald & Bloomberg,…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When it comes to the criminal justice system, there are many varying elements that contribute to the process through which accused offenders are counseled. As is expected, there are also numerous moral and ethical disputes that come with the territory, such as whether or not children, or 'juveniles', should be tried as adults in court for the violent crimes they commit. Some may say any child over the age of five should know the difference between right and wrong; for an individual to plan out a crime and act on it, the punishment should fit the offense, no matter the age. However, there is a thin line between vice and neurosis when it comes to juveniles. The incarceration of individuals under the age of sixteen at adult correctional facilities…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One quote I picked out was “...the zeal to corral wildly troubled, ever-younger kids and ram them through the adult system belies everything the juvenile justice system…” (Lundstrom 14). The main problem about this Most minors waiver to be tried as an adult because they get more protections in court. When you are being tried as a minor you do not appear before a jury. You do get that right when you are being tried as an adult.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Juvenile Court Cases

    • 207 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Kids in some states are prosecuted as adults when they're at the age of 12 or 13. In the state of Georgia kids are prosecuted and sent to a juvenile facility until their 18th birthday then sent to jail. Stories of kids being prosecuted like this aren't uncommon you hear about them every other week. In various states around the U.S kids are prosecuted as adults and then treated with adult like punishments like being sent for life or no parole. Some reasons these cases happen is just because their juvenile court doesn't handle that type of case.…

    • 207 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the article written by the CNN legal analyst, Phillip Halloway named ‘Should 11-year-olds be charged with adult crimes?’ on 14th October 2015, there has been an increase in the number of juvenile offenders who have been sentenced as adults. These are the issues presently plaguing the American legal system, as the brutal deeds of juvenile wrongdoers keep on to making headlines (Halloway, 2015). The primary question is, are children able to understand the consequences of their actions? Maybe, not as latest studies suggest that the brain 's prefrontal lobe, which some scientists study, performs an important role in slowing down improper behavior, may not attain full growth until age 20.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Juveniles should not be tried as adults for it is wrong to hold adolescents, under the legal age, to adult standards. If children do not even receive the same rights as adults in the first place, it makes no sense to try them in adult court. These juveniles should have the opportunity to be rehabilitated in a positive manner, for they tend to come from troubled households and violent neighborhoods. In over half of the cases these troubled kids don’t know any different way than a life of crime when surrounded by both social and environmental factors that influence their delinquent actions. One must commemorate that juveniles are mentally underdeveloped, and still have time to innovate if their issues are dealt with precisely and accurately.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The decision of juveniles being tried as adults in the world of criminal justice has usually been an object of controversy. Some agree that an adolescent who commits a serious crime like murder deserves to be penalized exactly like an adult; while others declare that a minor should not face the same punishment as an adult. However, no matter how severe or appalling a crime may be, juveniles should not be tried as adults; the reason being that everyone should be granted the chance to learn from their mistakes. Juveniles should not be punished as adults, simply because they biologically distinct from adults. Teenagers are the midsection between children and adults.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, some states sixteen is the maximum juvenile age and after the age limit juveniles are tried as an adult in a criminal court. According to Liz Ryan article, Youth in the Adult Criminal Justice System(2012) in states such as North Carolina, and New York, youth aged 16 and 17 can automatically be tried as adults no matter what the offense. In 9 other states (Georgia, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, New Hampshire,South Carolina, Texas, and Wisconsin), 17-year-olds are automatically prosecuted as adults. When a minor commit a crime they do not have all the constitutional rights compare to an adult tried in a criminal court.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays