Cruzan Vs. Missouri Assisted Suicide Case Study

Improved Essays
“As illustrated in in the case Cruzan v. Missouri, implementing assisted suicide would give the terminally ill and suffering patients the chance to die with dignity.” The cases involving death have always been controversial. As the life expectancy began increasing and people began dying in hospitals, the controversy over right to die and assisted suicide came into place. This is when Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health 1990 came into limelight and became a hot topic for the next decade or so because their is no law backing up this case. “The war started when twenty- five year Nancy Beth Cruzan lost control of her car on an icy Missouri Road in January of 1983”( Cruzan v. Director of Missouri Health Department 1990, Pg 2). The accident left her into a ‘permanent vegetative state’. She wasn't able to speak or respond. The doctors described her state as persistent vegetative state where she is not able to respond. She was in this state because of lack of oxygen for a while after the accident which damaged few of her …show more content…
They wanted to free their daughter from this intolerable suffering.“The quest for legally sanctioned right to die has also arisen from the anguish of patients afflicted with other immobilizing disabilities such as terminal diseases” ( Cruzan v. Missouri: The Right to Die by Lila Perl, Pg 10). The case also involved the medical profession, in charge for saving our lives not taking it away. This was the first time when the court gave its ruling on the issue of right to die and assisted suicide, which made it an high profile case. It involved the issue of death, which affected every aspect of the society, whether on religious grounds or on the professional front, every person was involved and was equally

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In January of 1983 Nancy Beth Cruzan lost control of her car on a icy Missouri road. This accident left Nancy brain damaged and was left in a “permanent vegetative state”. She could breath on her own but other than that there was nothing she could do on her own and she showed no signs of thinking capabilities. The doctors put a feeding tube into her stomach about month after the accident.…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nancy Beth Cruzan was 25 years old when she was involved in a automobile accident in 1983 that left her unresponsive to outside stimulation. Paramedics found her face down in a ditch and had to restart her heart. She had stopped breathing for about 15 minutes, causing her to suffer from severe brain damage (“Nancy Cruzan Dies”, p1). She emerged from a three week long coma and proceeded…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cruzan v. MO Dept. of Health People are born with natural rights including life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, which the Constitution protects. Nancy Cruzan lost her ability to express and revel in her natural rights when a tragic car accident left her severely debilitated and in a ‘persistent vegetative state.’ Nancy Cruzan’s parents requested that their daughter be removed from a machine distributing artificial nutrition and hydration that kept her alive. Nancy’s parents strongly believed that pursuing a ‘plan of medical treatment that allows nature to take its course and permits [her] to die with dignity’ would be the most just decision for her (Cruzan v. Mo Dept of Health (Brennan, J., dissenting)). However, the majority of Justices…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Michael Gill’s article “A moral defense of Oregon’s physician-assisted suicide law” he defends the law against two objections by providing arguments from opponents of PAS and proponents of PAS. The first objection that Gill defends is “that it is intrinsically wrong for someone to kill herself” (2005). The second objection is that “it is intrinsically wrong for physicians to assist someone in killing herself” (Gill, 2005). The physician assisted suicide law allows terminally ill residents of Oregon who are mentally competent and have less than six months to live to request a doctor to prescribe a medication that will cause a quick and painless death.…

    • 2296 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cruzan V. Missouri Dhs Case Study

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited

    The Cruzan family won the right to remove Nancy from life sustaining machines and feeding tubes. " Last spring (1996) Ninth Circuit Judge Stephen Reinhardt wrote a fire breathing opinion to overturn Washington's Assisted-Suicide Ban on behalf of three plaintiffs who had already died naturally. Choosing a dignified death, Reinhardt asserted was a Constitutional Right under the 14th Amendment's Due Process Protection of Personal Liberties and the Principal of Privacy defined in the Court's abortion rulings. ' A competent terminally ill adult' should not be forced to endure 'a childlike state of helplessness, diapered, sedated, incompetent'" (Van Biema…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Recent stories in the news have posed this controversial question: should terminally ill patients have the right to end their own lives? Empathetic stories of terminally ill patients’ last wishes have captured attention of the media and created a controversial debate on the ethics and morals of physician assisted suicide, otherwise known as PAS. Some claim that PAS is inhumane and unethical, while others insist that it is a given right to anybody under such extreme circumstances. In his article, “Physician-Assisted Suicide Is Always Wrong,” Ryan T. Anderson attempts to convey to citizens and policymakers that legalizing PAS across the country would be a grave mistake. However, Anderson’s argument is weak due to a series of logical fallacies…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Quoting William Brennan, Supreme Court Justice, he posited that, "An ignoble end steeped in decay is abhorrent. A quiet, proud death, bodily integrity intact, is a matter of extreme confidence” in the Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health. The limitations of medicine is another reason why the physician-assisted suicide should be legalized. This practice is far from being about suicide. Suicide is seen to respond to personal disintegration, while physician-assisted practice precludes it.…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Assisted suicide or the right to die is an extremely controversial topic that has been talked about for decades. Assisted suicide is for terminally ill patients that know they will never win their battle and want to pick when and how they die, which is often used before their disease becomes intolerable. Over the last couple years this controversy has had a lot more media coverage because of people working to give it the attention that it needs. In the United States more people have been on the side of passing laws so that people who do assist do not get charged for the crime. One major story that was in the news that seemed to bring back more coverage of this topic was a young woman having to move to a different state just to have an assisted…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this article Jeffrey points out how it is hard to not to moved by emotional stories about people with terminal illnesses wanting death. However, there are thirty-four states that invoke criminal charges on people if they help in assisted-suicide. His main focus is on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Stating that judges view euthanasia like abortion. I will use this article to show that judges have no intention of changing the law.…

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes when life and suffering become unbearable, death offers a welcome escape. When it is a question between seeking expensive long term treatment or ending one’s suffering altogether, assisted suicide, Death with Dignity, gives someone a choice whether or not to end their life. Death with Dignity refers to a person’s legal right to end one’s life. This “solution” to pain and suffering is often frowned upon for various reasons in many religions and by specific individuals such as doctors, nurses, and family members. Despite these objections, death with dignity should be legal throughout the United States because it gives people a chance to decide what is best for themselves, it costs a lot less money than a long-term treatment, and it ends their suffering.…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Death With Dignity Act

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As a human race we crave control. Control of our work, control of our government, and now some even crave control of death. The “Death with Dignity” act promotes physician assisted suicide (PAS), providing an unethical and alarming “solution” to suffering or loss of hope. This bill contains numerous flaws which endanger the weakest and most vulnerable members of our society.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    No person should have to endure terminal suffering that is unremitting, unbearable, or prolonged. When the burdens of life outweigh the benefits because of uncontrollable pain, severe psychological suffering, loss of dignity, or loss of quality of life as judged by the patient, and when the circumstances are not remediable, the dying person should be able to ask for and receive help in assisted suicide (Marker, Smith 47-51). It is further argued that assisted suicide for incurably ill persons experiencing extreme suffering can be distinguished from euthanasia used for the purpose of genocide on the grounds that it is based on principles of dignity, honor, and respect and is chosen and enacted by the dying individuals, rather than being forced on them against their…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Assisted Suicide Analysis

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Assisted suicide, death with dignity, and mercy killing are just a few names for what many people see as the least painful way to leave the world. Assisted suicide has recently become one of the most talked about issues of the times. With so many people starting to use assisted suicide as a way to end their pain in their own matter, it would be a good idea to take a deeper look into the issue. This analysis of assisted suicide will include personal stories on how assisted suicide as effected two different people, it will analyze Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act along and how the six step process for ethical decision making helps with how recipients are chosen to be given he medication, who the death with dignity act primarily effect, and the…

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Against Assisted Suicide In many countries around the world, it is legal for doctors to prescribe a medicine that can potentially end a patient’s life if the patient wishes to commit suicide. In the United States, four states -Vermont, Oregon, Washington, and Montana- are the only states which have chosen to legalize assisted suicide (Backmann par. 6). Physician assisted suicide, also called assisted suicide, has become an extremely sensitive topic that has been debated by everyone, from academic scholars to everyday people, and has become almost as controversial as abortion.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays