Analysis Of Hirsch's Critique Of A Thoughtworld

Improved Essays
Critique of a Thoughtworld
1.) In Hirsch’s “critique of a thoughtworld”, from The Schools We Need and Why We Don’t Have Them, he begins by talking about what he believes to be is the “one true belief” among mainstream educationists. He believes that the “one true belief” is characterized as a “constantly repeated catechism” that has “currently no thinkable alternative”(Hirsch, p.69). What he means by this is that for quite some time now educationists have been using the same old out dated logic in our education system, and they will not look at any different options, because they will not accept that their “one true belief” could be wrong. If they could just put their beliefs and pride beside then we would be able to reform our schools and
…show more content…
Since we are so “different from other countries we have little to nothing to learn from them.” This is important because it is one of the examples of how Americas education system how American educationists are only focused on what they think that we should be learning and will not take into consideration the other alternatives that are out there. In Hirsch’s “critique of a thoughtworld” he talks about how by 1987 the most of the Britons had converted over to their new education curriculum and after only a small time period were doing better then the British school …show more content…
By having these separatism educators will be able to easily teach their students without biases. Hirsch also talks about William Heard Kilpatrick and his connection with professional separatism. Hirsch talks about how Kilpatrick when he was the new institutional dispensation he implemented a militant separatism. With this militant separatism Kilpatrick was able to separate the “subject matter from pedagogy, and the separation of forward-thinking social thinkers.” As a result of this separatism the army’s strengths increased because its “principles were the best ones socially, scientifically, and philosophically” (Hirsch,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    As I mentioned earlier, Mark Edmundson, Gerald Graff and Jonathan Kozol all introduced an issue they believed to be causing problems in our educational systems. Students are always exposed to problems especially in education. I introduced Edmundson ideas about how he believed that students are not understanding that we have education to grow and learn from. I also included Graff’s point of view about why we face issues in education which were, that it all depends on how education is perceived by students. Concluding with a different perspective that ties in as well was Kozol how he mentions that segregation is limiting our students and opportunities to our…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America’s graduation rate, although it used to rank a lot higher, is now much lower than most developed countries. Even if students aren’t looking to drop out, if they are not motivated enough to learn, it is incredibly hard, if not impossible, to teach them. One reason…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brownson’s Assessment Horace Mann gained support for his educational reform during the 19th century, yet there was some opposition to his proposals. Orestes Brownson constructed the best appeal to his reforms with several well-grounded concerns. Brownson reveals Mann’s undermining of the democratic and meritocracy society through the education of students and their educators, the extension of politics into education, and using education as a means of mass control. Mann’s ideas for the educational system reform in America for its students were swiftly followed by his call for reform on how the educators were to teach. There are several references to the Prussian educational system at that time.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zhao summarizes the chapters with a somewhat simple solution, “In order for America to compete in a global society American needs to be more American”. He again references the fact that this a mindset changes away from centralized policies that include sameness among all educational institutions. Because of this Zhao states we are seeing more teachers teach to the test because of the high stakes involved with standardized testing. To expand our diversity, we have to step away from emphasizing the importance of success in the areas of math and reading. The shift to a more personalized learning educational plan is what Dr. Zhao supports.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America’s education system is no longer one of the best in the world. Americans may act like education is the most important asset a person can earn. However, our country is falling way behind many Asian and European countries because children are lacking education in almost every subject. Benjamin R. Barber, author of “America Skips School”, explains what really is wrong with our education in in his essay. The article explains what is wrong with America’s educational system because we are focusing on other inputs but, not school.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Barber shows how foreign students receive better education than American ones when he cites, “American children are in school only about 180 days a year, as against 240 days or more for children in Europe or Japan.” From this, it can be seen that America does not prioritize education as much as other countries do, and is currently being left behind. With increasing dropout rates, lack of basic literacy, and de-emphasis on getting a good education, American students are being deprived of their civil right to be able to become well-informed and cognizant people, which later on will prevent them from being successful in…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poetry is a way for people to express their inner most thoughts and feelings. When I read poems, I feel as if I can feel exactly what the author is feeling. Edward Hirsch believes “a reader of poetry is a kind of pilgrim setting out, setting forth” as explained in his article, “To the Reader Setting Out”. Hirsch compared a reader to a pilgrim in his article. In his article, he stated, “Reading poetry is an adventure in renewal, a creative act, a perpetual beginning, a rebirth of wonder.”…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In today’s society, students are required to follow with the American educational system. Instead of learning…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Karissa Mata Globalization has been the major dimension of change in American education. American education has reflected public concern about the nation 's role in the world. Back-to-Basics was represented by the conservative ethos in Reagan’s election. It called for an end to liberal policies associated with the 1960s.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In his article “Lost in America,” Douglas McGray focuses heavily on the problem of isolationism and a lack of worldwide perspectives in the U.S. education system in order to prove that changes in the education of young Americans must be made. “Lost in America” was issued by Foreign Policy magazine in 2006, which reveals that McGray’s audience includes American legislators involved in the elaboration of American curriculum policies. In order to support his argument for this audience of policy makers and legislators, McGray builds credibility through the use of anecdotes that surprise and shock his audience, hyperboles to overemphasize his points, and a well-elaborated call to action to encourage his intended audience. McGray effectively employs…

    • 1519 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American Education is failing due to horrific teachers, not keeping up with the rapid evolution of technology, and the continued distribution of useless material. According to thelearningcurve.pearson.com, America’s Education ranks 14th in the world in (Pearson, “World Education Rankings”). America is one of the most advanced and innovative countries in the world, yet it struggles in the department of education.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Hirsch’s Desire for a National Curriculum” Hirsch’s Desire for a National Curriculum by Eugene F. Provenzo Jr. is a reading that compares Provenzo and Hirsch’s thoughts on whether or not to establish a national curriculum. What motivates Provenzo to write this piece it to challenge Hirsch’s views on having a national curriculum, which includes his views and opinions on curricular fragmentation and the decreasing literacy rate of students(P.3). Provenzo’s purpose is to get the audience thinking about what is really best for the American education system. Is it a uniform system bases on another man’s, “cultural and ideological orientation,”or one that follows national subject standards that every state and school follows to ensure that students…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Critique of Diane Ravitch’s “Education in the Post Sputnik Era” On October 4th 1957 the Soviet’s launch the world’s first satellite called “Sputnik 1” ending the debate that the quality of education in America’s school system has been a concern. This event that the Russians beat the Americans sparked crisis in America’s education system. This crisis lead to restructuring the education system in English, History, Science, Mathematics, and foreign languages. While many programs were developed and government funding was allocated to enhance school systems and colleges, the racial revolution presented a forceful challenge to the political, social, and economic basis of American schools (Ravitch 324).…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Teach Knowledge, Not “Mental Skills,” author E.D. Hirsch bases his argument on an experience he went through when he was a teacher in public school. He worked with two different principals in the same school. Comparing these two principal, the first principal did not care about what students acquired from their lessons, and the students’ academic performance was really bad. The second principal was more worried about the knowledge and his students’ academic performance. Hirsch argues that school should teach more knowledge instead of mental skills, and American should learning the teaching method of Europe and Asia which have a similar method of core-knowledge; problem-solving skill is important but depend on pertinent knowledge.…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But the American school system seems to be becoming stagnant or even declining in spite of that. I can support that with the fact that “education is still based on the outdated model of college prep that prepares students for middle management and factory jobs that… no longer exist.” (60) Not to mention the fact that…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays