Critical Analysis Of Uncle Tom's Cabin, By Harriet Beecher Stowe

Superior Essays
Jane Tompkins’ essay, Sentimental Power, offers the reader a brash, analytical perspective of the book Uncle Tom’s Cabin, by Harriet Beecher Stowe. Tomkins details her thoughts on why Uncle Tom’s Cabin had little impact on feminism, has an unwarranted claim as a sentimentalist classic, and why it is an unrealistic depiction of death relying too heavily on religion. This essay with offer a counter argument to these three topics.
On page two of her essay, Tomkins states that, “Unwittingly or not, so the story goes, they [the female writers] were apologists for an oppressive social order”. It can be argued that Tomkins is offering this critical analysis from a modern perspective without taking into consideration the silent power behind Stowe’s female characters and how it was presented in an effective way to appeal to a broad audience when the book was published. If all male readers of Uncle Tom’s Cabin were met with strong-willed, obviously powerful female characters, it could possibly have been considered to be too unrealistic for many men to relate to, and subsequently alienate a part of her audience.
When looking at the emotional
…show more content…
She states, “Little Eva 's death, so the argument goes, like every other sentimental tale, is awash with emotion but does nothing to remedy the evils it deplores. Essentially, it leaves the slave system and the other characters unchanged”. According to this quote, it appears that Tomkins expected deaths like Eva’s to have a sudden, profound impact on the entire course of the novel. In reality, the religious aspect should be analyzed, but there should also be a focus on the emotional devastation that Tom felt through his loss of Eva. The reader is provided with an example of a deep connection between two races, and Tom is left powerless after Eva’s death, just as he was before. Because he is a slave, he is incapable of remedying deplorable

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This happening is an example of slavery tearing families apart and making the possibility of having a stable family life nonexistent. Another instance in which slavery causes agony is portrayed within Chapter Fourty of the novel in which Uncle Tom is beaten by his master, Mr. Legree, for refusing to reveal the locations of the escaped slaves; the brutal beating eventually causes his demise. With this, it can be concluded that slavery is evil and immoral for the reason that it degrades and exploits human beings. There are several other main points that Harriet Beecher-Stowe exhibits in Uncle Tom’s Cabin that does not involve slavery such as a child’s heart and intentions are pure and benevolent, a parent’s love is eternal and truly selfless, and that faith in Christianity can assure you that you are not alone in your hardships. Evangeline St. Clare is the only child of Augustine St. Clare and Marie St. Clare.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bad Indians Summary

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages

    By drawing from her own experiences and those of her ancestors, she brings into sharp focus the relationship of present-day struggles with not only the past, but the refusal to correct the whitewashed narrative. Even after all the violence, she shows how the truth is still not heard of her people. By retelling the all-but-forgotten stories of her people, Miranda shows how Native American history has been erased as missionization changed their culture forever. Miranda is methodical in making her case about how the whitewashing of missionary history has nearly decimated Native American culture, identity and pride; she brings example after example to trace the current struggles of Native Americans back to the erasure of their proud history. By pointing out the damage, she brings awareness.…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Moreover, the sin that Hester executed also brought a miserable state upon Arthur Dimmesdale. While Hester assures Dimmesdale that he can live his life without Chillingworth and everything will be alright, he cries, “O Hester! Thou tellest…

    • 2565 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She is born a woman in a world dominated by men. Yet, “The Wife of Bath” demonstrates how Alys attempts to exploit the blind spots of the patriarchal system she lives in. She uses the bible to help maneuver through the heart of the patriarchal thinking that defined the medieval era to achieve her own personal empowerment. Chaucer takes his main protagonist and writes her as manipulative, licentious, and deceitful which can be interpreted as her falling into the same stereotypes she is protesting against. However, in spite of her characterization making her seem hypocritical and the overall narrative as antifeminist, Alys openly decries against the clerical tradition and misogynistic social norms that dictate her society in such a demanding and authoritative way that she cannot be regarded as anything short of proto-feminist.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Scathing Review Some novels are passed down through history because they offer great entertainment, while others have great historical significance, yet at first glance Mrs. Dalloway seems to have little to no significance at all. In reality Mrs. Dalloway actually is an attempt to scrutinize the social injustices of the time from a real person’s point of view, without compromising true life and thought in any aspect. Through one particularly poignant scene of Clarissa Dalloway’s inner monologue, Woolf is attempting to give society a scathing review regarding its injustice towards woman, as well as the division it creates between people of different backgrounds. Throughout the novel Clarissa is scrutinized for a variety of reasons, by almost…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people are unaware of all the negativity and uneven treatment people show females. I would not consider myself a feminist in any way and I know that men have just the same amount of stereotypes for their gender as well, but I researched more into what the feminist fight for for the sake of this paper. On humanevents.com I read an article about the main feminism topics. The article brought up about the Roe vs. Wade case which made abortion legal. I agree that it is the woman’s choice even though I do not agree that it is a good decision.…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The poem stated, “Death, be not proud, though some have called thee.” From the start, John Donne is taking away Death’s confidence by warning him of having pride. The second line also shows the warning for death to avoid reconsidering with his positions, “Mighty and dreadful.” Death might think he is the almighty and very dreadful person, however, John Donne is pointing out for death with mockery. Donne did not particularly use evidence until line 5 and in line 5, John Donne is mocking the Death as he is merely a slave of fates, chance, kings, and desperate men. The poet is stating that Death does not control anything. The Death certainly does not control other forces.…

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When John arrives to the World State, he is shocked at their low moral values and lack of religion. He does not wish to be with Lenina after he realizes that they have drastically different morals and values. Furthermore, the suppression of emotions through the use of soma prevents citizens from having feelings of empathy and sympathy, which are important for holding moral values. An article written about the uniqueness of human beings states that, “We are the only creatures that show disgust, blush in embarrassment, or shed tears of emotion. We display levels of empathy attained by no other species.…

    • 1762 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The “unruly” nature of their growth reflects the unchecked emotional shielding the narrator employs, much like their grandfather, who so greatly withdrew from his loved ones that his own grandchild is unable to appreciate him in death. As they passively allow their grandfather’s influence to remain unchecked in their life, its impact is magnified. Their unwillingness to recognize it, which would enable them to address it, only allows the problem to grow. Laurence calls our attention to the problem of denial. We must first accept that our dead shape who we are in order to weed out the negative influences they leave behind to avoid the danger of stagnation.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stowe includes another incident with Cassy and Tom, where Cassy tells Tom she wants to kill Lagree, Tom insists that she shouldn’t do that because it’s is a sin and encourages her to escape instead (chapter 38). This communicates to the audience that slaves were treated so badly that they became psychologically affected and were tempted to do things because of anger that had been building up because they could never say anything to their owners. It also shows how they respected their owners and are loyal to…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays