Critical Analysis Of The American Family By Stephanie Coontz

Great Essays
If the misery of the poor be caused not by the laws of nature, but by our intuitions, great is our sin
Charles Darwin

The timely segregation of inequality in America needs to be eradicated. A person is not born inadequate or penniless. Each should have the ability to become wealthy. Unfortunately, the burden of poverty for most families remains prevalent. Our families have grown and improved, the institutions remain uniform. Stephanie Coontz is a historian that had an essay “The American Family” published in Life magazine. In Coontz’ essay she claims that our contemporary family is decent, but could be better if certain aspects were to change. In slight comparison, Patricia Hyjer Dyk is a professor that wrote an introductory essay that published
…show more content…
Also, consider the lower class social and economic influences and create policies to decrease the gap in inequality. Though Dyk’s audience is relatively similar to Coontz’ audience; Dyk’s summarized research review solutions can be compatible to Coontz’ argument. Dyk’s scholarly review could satisfy Coontz argument about openness in families, which function is important in a family, the need of change in institutions and diversity in families. Both authors acknowledge the openness society has on modern family. Coontz explains the reason of the mid-1900s. Coontz explains the reason modern families have more stress than traditional families of the mid-1900s. Coontz claims, “There are plenty of stresses in the modern family life, but one reason they seem worse is that we no longer sweep them under the rug”(96). Families in the 1900s had traditional values; they refrained from talking about their problems and were hesitant to modernity. Contemporary families have stress because they are more open. Families talk about their problems or attend groups for solutions. For instance, an alcoholic might attend Alcoholic Anonymous meetings to get guideless on different …show more content…
In the mid-1900s problems such as gay families and poverty was disregarded and concealed. Now modernity is encouraged. In relations to Dyk, study groups is formed to develop policies for an issue that would never been discussed in the 1900s. Families transitioned from restrictions to openness and tolerance. Both authors declare each family has its own differences that distinguish families from one another. Coontz reveals the importance of diversity in families. “If we look back over the last millennium,” Coontz points out” we can see that families have always been diverse and in flux. In each period, families have solved one set of problems only to face a new array of challenges, what works for a family in one economic and cultural setting doesn’t work for a family in another”(97). Coontz acknowledges the difference in families is essential. One family does not necessarily have to be similar to the next to achieve stability. There is no uniform template for a family; each has diversified. Dyk explains her audience daily routine, which consists of safe shelter, utilities paid, appropriates clothing, reliable transportation, and others, but she then describes the working poor inability to achieve the same tranquility as her audience. “This will

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Love And Diane Analysis

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The documentary, Love and Diane, offered an intimate and in-depth look at the struggles that a family can face in providing effective structure and defined roles that enable success within the family context. In the film, Diane, a recovering crack addict, struggles to correct mistakes she has made in the raising of her children, including her daughter, Love, and attempts to prevent these same mistakes from impacting her grandson, Love’s son, Donyaeh. A multitude of factors make this a difficult task to accomplish, and the film depicts the socioeconomic and cultural factors that can have a multi-generational impact on a family. The decisions that Diane makes evolve have ramifications that affect Love, and in turn, her behavior and actions…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There is an image in America of what a family should look like: one mother, one father, a couple of children and perhaps the family dog. The reality of what makes a family, however, is much more complex. In the book Plainsong by Kent Haruf, the reader discovers a variety of families, that are made up in a multitude of different ways. While some of these families are defined by blood relation, almost all of them differ in some way from the traditional conception of the family unit. The reasons that these family groupings come about are as varied as the families that they create, but in the end, they fulfill the needs of the family members regardless of the existence, or lack, of blood ties.…

    • 1393 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Working Poor Book Summary Three Main Points The Working Poor was written by David K. Shipler. The book gives readers a perspective of what life is like after poverty strikes. Each chapter focuses on either the contributing factors, the causes, or the effects of poverty.…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The “Declining Significance of Race” a text by William Wilson played a key role in terms of transforming the research agenda of Scholar working on the history of Afro-American. Wilson, an eminent Sociologist spent most of his career confronting one of the nation’s most perplexed topic: namely the deep and highly persistent inner city poverty in America. In this both highly acclaimed yet highly controversial book Wilson theorizes that the significance of race is waning, it therefore follows that among African Americans, ‘class’ was comparatively more important in terms of determining an individual’s life chances rather than race which historically held more credential. Regarded as theoretically ambitious, this book is an attempt to…

    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the book, The Way We Never Were: American Families and the Nostalgia Trap by Stephanie Coontz, the author deconstructs various types of stereotypes and myths embodied by television shows that romanticize family life and gender roles. Coontz (1992) states that these idealizations promote the “traditional family” myth which she describes as “an ahistorical amalgam of structures, values, and behaviors that never coexisted in time and place” (p.9). The notions derived from this myth are a compound of characteristics that resemble mid-nineteenth century and early 20th century paradigms concerning family life (Coontz, 1992, p.9). Coontz (1992) describes both components in detail in Chapter 1 describing the first as a mother-child oriented family…

    • 1998 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With an open mindset has to face all the circumstances which is would be an end for the essay. The points he made about the detachments in American family are true, but it is not acceptable to compare with the family society of other cultures and society. I believe that in some aspects American family system is progressive. Its faults are more emphasized because the open nature of the society. The author both praises and criticizes the way of Asian version of family values.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are some things that people need to be able to thrive in the cruel world we live in today. Will Allen wrote the book, The Good Food Revolution: Growing Healthy Food, and Communities, and in this book he made some interesting analogies that interesting enough, alluded to these. Will Allen is a former pro basketball player, now he spends his time and money trying to make a difference in his town by trying to urbanize farming in a economically friendly manner. Allen talks a lot about food obviously, the book is mostly about his farming and food revolution, but he also talks about family and how crucial it is to have a strong family setting backing you up. Family has always been a big thing in my life, my family has set me up with my future,…

    • 1702 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Families change throughout the centuries, each conforming to society or breaking away from societal norms. In the 1950s, most families followed the “cookie cutter” way, which means many families were the same. Compared to today’s families, one can say that families have become very different from what they used to be. In today’s society, we have families that are bi-racial, having either gay or lesbian parents, having a single mother of father; these types of families were not as popular in the 1950’s. Families during the 1950’s were traditional and most families conformed to society.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hispanic Family Sociology

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Sociological theories are used in attempt to understand and explain why family structure is affected by these stratifications. In conflict theory, the focus resides in the inequality and imbalance of power in society that is involved in the direct stratifications that influence families. The social exchange theory illustrates a model for human behavior in the assumption that individuals make decisions by determining the advantages and disadvantages of each option. Conflict theory will give a macro-level approach that is beneficial in understanding patterns within a society.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Stephanie Coontz chronicles in her article, “The American Family,” women of lower income families were put into a tight situation, where they needed to work to support their family, but often could not find a job. Even in middle class families, women far from the happiness that was portrayed by mainstream television. (Coontz 3). There was little that women, or anyone who did not fit the cookie cutter mold of the 1950’s. People who had unconventional beliefs, be they in religion, sexual orientation, or having a disability, were faced with government investigations, and arbitrary firings, constant criticism and resentment without the enforcement of the rights given to them by the constitution (Coontz 3).…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The continuing rise of economic inequality and wealth inequality in America is one of the biggest issues in the country. Currently the top five percent in America hold seventy-four percent of the country’s wealth, leaving the other ninety-five percent of Americans are struggling financially to survive. In this article, How Experts Would End Inequality if They Ran America, written by Stein, there are several different explanations on how to address the rising income inequality in the U.S., the four suggestions that I chose were written by Boushey, Azzerad, Tedeschi and Kelton. Boushey argues that universal access to child care will drive down the inequality within our country. Azzerad states that in order to combat the current rise in income…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The novel Gone Girl, by Gillian Flynn, is a not-so-typical thriller about a seemingly perfect marriage gone terribly wrong. In the novel, Nick and Amy Dunne have been happily married for five years. For everyone else, family and friends, their marriage was seemingly flawless and filled with love and humor. What no one saw was that Nick and Amy’s’ storybook romance was far from perfect.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this assignment I chose a newspaper entry from The New York Times with the title “The Changing American Family”. I learned in lesson 1 that there is no true “definition” of family until you come to the political part of it that has to do with rights, benefits, taxes and so on, instead it’s really to each is own. A family could be two parents, one child and a dog, or it could be a mother and her child, in this day in age having one parent or even an unrelated guardian is almost “common”. Many people are considered lucky to have their biological parents still together growing up. Twenty to thirty years ago, though, it was very much looked down upon to have divorced or separated parents, in fact some people today still look down on it whether…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Family Introduction Paper Traditionally, family is defined by the title and relationship of the ancestry. However the modern day definition has evolved to include anyone with an intimate and or both vital connections to the relationship.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are a multitude of reasons that the American family is different from the “traditional family” of yesterday. The ways that these changes are influencing people are extremely positive but there will always be a negative person to point out that a few of them have the capacity to be harmful and unwanted. These changes in family are seen most noticeably in the West but are also making their way to the East as well, though at much slower rates. While reading the article “Global Revolution in Family and Personal Life”, it is noted that the author sees the American family as stronger than ever. Giddens shows that throughout history the family has continued to change and is better now than it ever was.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays