Rescuing Justice And Equality Analysis

Improved Essays
In this section I turn to a critical evaluation of Williams’ objection, beginning with Cohen’s own rebuttal presented in chapter 8 of Rescuing Justice and Equality.

Cohen reconstructs Williams’ argument like so:

P1: Justice is a set of demands
P2: Demands of justice are to be discharged (only) collectively
C1: An individual is not obliged by a (punitive) demand of justice unless others in general are disposed to observe that demand. (By 1 and 2.)
P3: You are not obliged to discharge a demand of justice unless you can know that you are obliged to do so.
C2: No one can be obliged by a demand of justice unless it can be known, unless one could be assured, that others are observing it. (By C1 and P3).
C3: Nothing is a demand of justice unless
…show more content…
Cohen’s rebuttal takes the form of denying that Williams’ publicity requirements, specifically (ii) and (iii), are a demand of justice and therefore cannot be drawn on to discredit his egalitarian ethos.

Williams assesses the premises and conclusions of the above reconstruction, explaining where the argument breaks-down. Referring to racial discrimination, Cohen points out that C1 must be false: even if I do not expect others not to discriminate with respect to race, it does not follow that it is not a demand on me. In other words, justice demands non-discriminatory behaviour per se, no matter if others are adhering to it. Cohen is appealing to our intuition here; that this is such an obvious and unequivocal demand of justice is sufficient to reject C1. It follows from this that P1 and/or P2 are false. The obvious target being P2, since, as the racism example highlights, a just act need not be ‘collectively’ discharged to count as such. By extension, the racism example gives us good grounds to reject C2, since “justice does not only bind under assurance”. Further, the problem with the inference from C2 to C3 is that “justice can require something even when no one is obliged to ensure the fulfilment of that requirement”, such as where “insolvable coordination problems

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Case: Katzenbach v. Grant 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 46756 *; 2005 WL 1378976 Facts: The Plaintiffs, Katzenbach and Osuna filed a lawsuit against Defendant Grant over a film and book rights. Grant owns a website called “thenightexposed” (www.thenightexposed.net). The Plaintiffs claim that Grant caused problems with negotiations with Sony Pictures and the USA Network. Plaintiff further claims that Grant sent a letter calling Osuna book a fake and made other defamatory articulations about the Plaintiffs on his website.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the time of Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson the controversy of separation of church and state was at its prime. This matter has long been an issue in our country’s history and the discussion continues today as we still struggle with the decisions of our forefathers. However, Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson played an important role in shaping the outcome of our country’s laws regarding the severance of church and state. Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson spoke out and taught about their views to others which completely went against the rules of the Puritans. The Puritans were strongly intolerant of other religions, or even members of their religion getting strange ideas, like Hutchinson and Williams.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are always two sides to an argument, but different people have different opinions on which side is right and wrong; as a result, we can compare a debate or argument as of a coin, due to the fact that it has two sides. When it comes to the topic of judicial system in America, most of us will readily agree that it needs to be reformed. Where this agreement usually ends, however, is on the question of who will step forward and make changes to the court system. Whereas some are convinced that no one is going to do anything about it, others maintain that the government will be the savior by making the changes. In the introduction of Just Mercy: A Story of Justice And Redemption, by Bryan Stevenson -an American lawyer, social justice activist,…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Bryan Stevenson’s memoir, he explains how “the power of mercy…belongs to the undeserving. It’s when mercy is least expected that it’s most potent – strong enough to break the cycle of victimization and victimhood, retribution and suffering” (294). However, Stevenson isn’t just talking about mercy. Mercy plays a part with other prominent aspects of the book, most relating to problems in the justice system. These faults are what led Walter McMillian being put on death row for a crime he did not commit, which is the main storyline of the memoir.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The argument for separate but equal precludes the notion that, separate but equal is not inherently connected to the American system of racially-based slavery. However, I find this claim to contradict and violate the very nature of the Thirteenth Amendment. In segregating the two races of the nation, we draw on the previous caste of bondage. We inherit the distinctions and prejudices of this previous system in our attempts to regulate race relations, to segregate the lives of Whites from those of Blacks. Our inheritance of prejudice, of supremical thought, will continue to infinitely exist if we allow for the complete segregation of these two races.…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Just Mercy Summary

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In his book Just Mercy, author Brian Stevenson details many of the failures of justice that he has personally witnessed in his long career as a public interest attorney. Mr. Stephenson relays each case as a personal story. As a reader, I found myself sympathizing with many of the people Brian Stevenson worked to defend. I found myself shocked by how poor and underprivileged people were so often treated horribly coldheartedly by our justice system. Before I had believed our justice system to at least be fair and impartial.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summary Reading The Case for Reparations was not a basic reading. Although the writing was very straight forward the content was profound. The author was able to illustrate different aspects that one endured growing up as an African American in America. The writing began by explaining how the environment of America, especially the South was more of a kleptocracy.…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Finkenbiner Case Summary

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Finkenbiner 1 MCCLESKEY V. KEMP Emma Finkenbiner Block 7 Mr. Moore 20 April 2015 Finkenbiner 2 McCleskey v. Kemp was a Supreme Court case in 1897.…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The legal system of America exists for resolving disputes, maintaining order, and protecting various liberties and rights from violations or unreasonable intrusions by persons, organizations, or government. In Jonathan Harr’s A Civil Action, the formal moments of the Woburn case show how, in many cases, the legal system fails to promote justice, truth seeking, and fairness. First and foremost, the adversarial nature of American law, specifically in civil cases, prevent the discovery of the truth. In the adversarial system, two sides clash head to head in front of a neutral fact finder and the idea is that the truth should tip the scale. The verdict in theory should be just and fair.…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite the natural rights and humane principles presented in our nation, we are not all treated equally. Our modern world struggles with social and racial discrimination, despite lawful efforts to prevent such attrocities. This has impacted our society through unspeakable means, and has molded many of our beliefs and ideals regarding the freedom and equality of those around us and how they strive to rightfully earn and represent these privleges. These thoughts were much different in 1832, however, and are demonstrated through Maria W. Stewart's lecture. Through careful utilization of the three rhetorical strategies, Stewart enables herself to appeal to logic, emotion, and ethics to persuade her audience of her personal (although biased)…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His triumph, ceaselessly setting up the right of the underprivileged to advocate in criminal act cases in America, was one of the milestone cases of the Warren Court. The book, Gideon’s Trumpet has been penned down by the author in order to call to mind the old times behind the Gideon v. Wainwright court case and the ways in which it made such an everlasting impact on the laws of the United States. This exceptional book scrutinizes the case Gideon v. Wainwright, the milestone 1963 Supreme Court case which detained that impoverished criminal defendants are unconstrained to legal advocates at the expense of the government. Gideon’s Trumpet is an articulate and edifying book which provides the reader with at the imperative tale which has never before occurred in the United States legal system.…

    • 2209 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whilst these two speeches are written such a long time apart, they both address many of the same topics, including the military, current state of the democratic government, and the constant positive outlook on both America and Athens. Both speeches are similar and different in their own way, however the one almost consistent similarity is the positive outlook that both Pericles and Obama have on their empire/country The speeches although written so far apart from each other, are both so similar to each other in both content and stylistic outlines. Pericles's speech was written to give as a eulogy for the fallen soldiers fighting for Athens, and to make potential soldiers feel like dying in battle is a honorable thing, and to encourage the growth of Athens army. Thousands of years president Barack Obama writes the two thousand thirteen State of the Union Address which was made to give hope to the nation about the present state and hopeful future of america.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Proposition: Hart argues that we conceptualized the Grudge informer case by maintaining unjust law is still a law, but perhaps so unjust that it should be disobeyed: On the one hand, we will begin our analysis by explaining the first part of the proposition “Hart argues that we conceptualized the Grudge informer case by maintaining unjust law is still a law”. In order to understand why according to him an unjust law is still a law, it is necessary to remind briefly his view on the connection between law and morality. As a matter of fact, it is obvious that as Hart is a legal positivist, he is claiming that there is not a necessary connection between law and morality but a contingent one . Nevertheless, even if there is a possible connection…

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his 1973 paper, “Is There a Prima Facie Obligation to Obey the Law?” M.B.E. Smith posits that the questions asking, “have the citizens of any government a prima facie obligation to obey the law?” and “what governments enjoy legitimate authority” are two distinct questions, and thus should not be conflated. It is my contention, that while these two questions are—and should be kept—separate, the latter can inform the former. Smith argues that “although those subject to a government often have a prima facie obligation to obey particular laws (e.g., when disobedience has seriously untoward consequences or involves an act that is mala in se), they have no prima facie obligation to obey all its laws" I believe that this statement is incorrect.…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Form Of Beauty Essay

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Self-predication: the Form of Beauty is itself beautiful. But this is different from the way in which all other beautiful things are beautiful. Every other beautiful thing is beautiful because it ‘participates in’ the Form of Beauty; but the Form simply is beautiful. It is what it is in virtue of itself.…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays