Offender Profiles

Improved Essays
Discussion Bennel’s study examines the effective use of offender profiles during a criminal case. There is strong criticism toward the use of profiling in the justice system because of the ambiguity that surrounds many of the statements made by experts in profiling. Multiple personality traits made up of vague statements are frequently taken into perspective as part of these outlined criminal behaviours. The aforementioned ambiguity creates doubt in what may constitute an aspect of the recommended profile leading to a narrowed suspect pool that does not accurately represent the offender. The current study, similar to participants of the early Barnum studies, suggests individuals may be able to attribute inexplicit characteristics toward a …show more content…
In theory, offender profiling could be a strong asset in the beginning of a situation, and only to limit the number of suspects in a case with a large suspect pool because any later in the investigation the accuracy will begin to sharply decline. The outcome of this experiment indicates that offender profiling is not as reliable a prioritization tool than once believed. This is because of the generalized statements and the obvious results that support the statements given by the profiler to be extremely vague. Considering both suspects were deemed to be appropriate candidates for the crime with no similarities in personality between them it is quite apparent that the use of profiling is very unreliable. It is likely that the offender profile was used as a confirmation tool, in which the detectives unconsciously viewed the descriptors in the suspects profile to match because they believed the suspect they were given was guilty. This is entirely plausible as confirmation bias states that individuals are likely to favour information that conforms to their beliefs. If the participant wanted to believe that their criminal had committed a crime then there was multiple ways to easily connect an ambiguous statement to their profiled suspect out of an unconscious inclination towards …show more content…
Had this not occurred there was the possibility that internal validity of the study would be compromised. Nonetheless, there are several limitations to be considered in the application of this study. First, the experience in profiling versus no experience in profiling provides a limitation on how reliable the application of profiling is in a case. If the participant has no experience their view on how useful profiling is when put into place can be skewed, allowing their belief to improperly represent the facts. A second limitation is the lack of representation found within the sample, as the way in which it was created is extremely biased. It is an example of convenience bias, where an easily accessible police station was chosen due to its locality. Had the sample been generalized in an area that had higher profile crime the idea of profiling may not have been quite so novel a concept. It is unclear if the experience in profiling lead to a view tainted by what could be considered a novel concept, or the biased sample did not accurately represent the use of a profiler. However, future research examining subjects such as a random stratified sample of the population is encouraged to allow for better external

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Racial profiling is defined as the use of race or ethnicity as grounds for suspecting someone of having committed an offense. Racial profiling encourages the perpetuation of racial stereotypes therefore it will lead to an estrangement of the races. Unless you are a minority, you most likely have never experienced racial profiling. Since the election of Barack Obama as President of the United States, Americans have fallen into a state of delusional thinking by which they believe his being elected eradicated racism as well as prejudices and unfair treatment of minorities. It is not my purpose to accuse all white people of being racist or bigoted, but it would be foolish to assume that these attitudes do not exist or that they are not more prevalent than many people would like to admit.…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Issues Relating to Racial Profiling in Law Enforcement Law enforcement officers often use the term profiling, which refers to a practice of describing individual behavior (positive or negative) and/or certain personal characteristics. At some point in time, the term profiling has evolved from its original specific intent and shifted from an individual’s actions to the individual’s race, ethnicity or national origin of an individual. Many individuals have seen law enforcement officers from interstate highways to airports describe an individual criminal behavior based on race. In the United States, racial profiling has been used as a way to stereotype an individual or groups solely on race and/or even on the person’s negative behavior still…

    • 1446 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sex Offender Registry

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As with many social problems, the question of labeling a sex offender on a national registry is met with many different options. The different viewpoints of the offender, the victim, the family, and the administrators of justice must all be taken into consideration. This can make it difficult to disperse a clear and uninformed form of justice in these types of crimes. Being placed on the national sex offenders registry changes a person 's life dramatically and I feel the punishment should fit the crime. They are restricted from living and working in certain areas that seem common to regular citizens whose lives are not under constant surveillance.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Modern day America racial profiling has become a major issue. According to Higgins (2008), profiling is a conglomeration of physical, behavioral, and psychological components that increase the probability of apprehending a suspect. During the 1980s, law enforcement began introducing race as a trait for profiling an individual. This was during the rise of drug use in the United States. Racial profiling allowed law enforcement officials to identify drug couriers.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Profiling Analysis

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Katz analyzed different cases of racial profiling and assesses the outcomes of these various situations. It looks at how the Fourth Amendment has been applied in various racial profiling cases and how this affected the results from the prospective trials as outlined. Through an analysis of the outcomes of these cases, one can understand how racial profiling has become a significant aspect of the criminal justice system as well as the various steps in place to reduce the occurrence of racial profiling. The article gives a detailed analysis of different aspects of racial profiling and how it undermines criminal justice. VII.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ` Law enforcement and race have always been a part of American society and controversial. In 1632 the first american law enforcement system was an established night watch by the townspeople of Boston. Since then policing in America has changed immensely for the good and bad. In those early days of policing, law enforcement was more reactive to crime, more or less after a crime was committed watch groups or sheriffs would address suspects accordingly. From the 1830s to the 1870s, there was an unprecedented amount of civil disorder occurring throughout the industrial United States.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first type of profiling mention in the textbook is behavior profiling, which is associated with the suspect’s assumptions and inferences. Within this profile, the detective relies on the methods and psychological stereotypes to identify the suspect. However, research has shown that this type of profiling is not accurate or helpful when catching criminals (Schwartz, 2016). The second type of profiling found in the textbook is one of the most controversial profiling techniques because is often associated with the suspects’ racial and religious identity. When a detective tries to use this type of racial profiling, they tend to rely on the racial, ethnic and religious stereotypes to identify the suspect (Schwartz, 2016).…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    One very contradictory issue that has emerged over the recent years within community policing is racial profiling. Racial profiling is defined as the use of race or ethnicity as grounds for suspecting someone of having committed an offense. Profiling of this nature impacts communities, minority groups, and even policing agencies in a negative manner ultimately. Many argue that criminal profiling differs from racial profiling and is a vital part of the job therefore it must be done. Others argue that it is not as great of a problem as the media sometimes portrays it to be.…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Profiling is used to narrowing down list of suspect. This method cannot solve the case, but develops potential suspects and further investigative follow-up (Hadley, 2005). The profile seeks for the offender’s behaviors, psychological climate, and physical persona.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But despite criminal profiling being used in complex investigations, and in a number of jurisdictions, as expert evidence in criminal trials, it hasn’t been proved to be an exact science. This paper will explore evidence for and against criminal profiling by looking at the essence of criminal profiling, the concerns, and the success of criminal profiling.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    [Topic Justification] Knowing the human behavior of offenders by using the psychological profiling method is the the best way for criminal investigators to apprehend the culprit(s), specifically serial killers. The answer to…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Confirmation Bias Essay

    • 2410 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Confirmation bias can lead to things such as a false confession or a wrong eyewitness identification. If the police officer thinks the suspect is guilty even before conducting the interview process, they will most likely seek information that is incriminating towards the suspect (Hill, McGeorge, & Memon,…

    • 2410 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unfair Lineups Make Witnesses More Likely to Confuse Innocent and Guilty Suspects A lineup is comprised of a suspect who is either guilty or innocent amongst various others who may or may not be in connection to the crime in which are deemed innocent. This article hypothesized how unfair lineups make witnesses more likely to confuse innocent and guilty suspects. This study was orchestrated by Melissa F. Colloff and Kimberley A. Wade in the Department of Psychology and University of Warwick and Deryn Strange in the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, City University of New York.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jack the Ripper is arguably, the first serial killer to ever be profiled. The Whitechapel murders are infamous in the history of unsolved crimes and whodunit cases. The case of Jack the Ripper was influential in the conception of criminal profiling. Although, it was unsuccessful in the Ripper case, criminal profiling has come a long way since the 1900’s. Originally criminal profiling was considered an art form, however, it is slowly being accepted as a science.…

    • 179 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A more recent approach to profiling will also be investigated to establish whether the problems from previous approaches can be ameliorated: - Investigative (Statistical) Profiling (Canter, 2000) This report will aim to guide practitioners within the criminal justice system (e.g. police) by providing a succinct review of research around the approaches. The approaches should be considered with knowledge of the problems involved and what potential solutions are required to avoid them. The Criminal Investigative Approach: The National Centre for the Analysis of Violent Crime (Formerly known as FBI Behavioural Science Unit) described the Criminal Investigative approach as ‘trait based’ profiling.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays