Criminal Contempt Case Study

Improved Essays
Criminal Contempt is defined as a disobedient or open disrespect for the court. It punishes conduct that violates a courts rule rather than a penal statue or some criminal law.
Arthur Kirkland was charged with criminal contempt because he punched Judge Fleming. This incident happened when Arthur was in Judge Fleming court room arguing Jeff McCullaugh case a client of Arthur. Jeff was stop for a broken light and then mistaken for another man that had his same name. McCullaugh had already spent 1 ½ years in jail and Arthur wanted to prove his innocence but Judge Fleming didn’t allowed Arthur to show him the evidence and refused to see it because it was two days late. Arthur was mad because thanks to Fleming an innocent man was going to stay
…show more content…
Garner and Graham v. Conner was a different story. In the case of Tennessee v. Garner police officers were wrong in using deadly force. The suspect had no weapons on him, the suspect was a suspected felon meaning that he might have not been the suspect at all, the victim ignore the police officer order and continue to climb the wall to scape. The officer shot him and killed him. I believe that the police officer could of have use his Taser gun and gave him an electric charged to get him down, apprehend him and then interrogate him reading the crime. Instead he decided to shot and killed him knowingly knowing that he had no weapons. This was very unconstitutional of that police officer in doing so because deadly force should only be use when there is a threat to the community and in this case there was none. Graham v. Conner was another case in which deadly force was use unconstitutionally and wrongly. The petitioner Graham was diabetic and he asked a friend to drive him to a store so that he could get some orange juice for his diabetes and because he can in and out so quick of the store the officer thought that he was suspicious. He handcuffs him, the officer failed to treat Graham conditions. Instead he had multiple injuries and then the officer learned that nothing had happened in the store. Not only did the officer acted wrong, he violated Graham rights and assume that he had committed a crime when he had no real evidence. There was no search …show more content…
In his 5th his due process right when it comes to a jury trial. In the movie it was only the judge and defense attorney and the other side there were no jury for his defendant to fight his case. In his 8th the judge was harsh when he sentences him to prison/jail without parole and permission of bail. This was cruel and unusual punishment from Judge Fleming and this was not correct because being a judge should be more than just sentencing a person without having to hear a good fighting argument from both sides and this was something that Robert didn’t have and he was just sentence to prison for it.

The meaning of life in judge Rayford words was when he went skydiving and his parachute didn’t open and fell on a tree top that’s when he discovered the meaning of life and he said that it sucks.
The half way point is a little game that Judge Rayford plays each time he goes out flying, and the way he does this is by calculating how much fuel he has left and flying a little further than what he can’t and he calls this a little beyond the half way point and still getting back to where he started with the amount of fuel that he has

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Bad Evidence Case Study

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages

    But why would Wilds go to the authorities in the first place, if from there, he doesn’t even have his story made up? The only reason he went that day was to tell lies and expected the police to believe him, which they did, understandably. Because they didn’t have a lead. In the podcast, Koenig refers back to the Justin Wolfe case and how he was wrongly convicted of the crimes that was accused of him. And was later found that the one who gave police the lead, was the one to blame for the crime.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Groups such as Black Lives Matter, The Black Panthers, and other such groups may support the preservation of minority safety but definitely do not speak against violent protests like Dr. King did. For example, in the Ferguson riots the town was burned and looted in outrage on the fact no charges were brought onto Officer Wilson. In large the riots were probably due to bad reporting. The media portrayed a Mr. Michael Brown as an innocent, young, unarmed, African American male shot by a white police officer. In reality Brown had just violently robbed a convenience store and despite being unarmed charged the officer grasping for his gun, in retrospect I would be scared if a six foot four inch two hundred ninety-two-pound man charged at me too.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before he was arrested, he received an Associates in Arts at Florida State University. He wanted to work at Walmart to get back on his feet, but Walmart turned him down because the company viewed his record. His opportunity to change and make a living was taken away from him just because of a mistake made in the past. According to The New Jim Crow, “as a criminal, you have scarcely more rights, and arguably less respect, than a black man living in Alabama at the height of Jim Crow” (Alexander 2). Felons of all races, including African-Americans, are denied the right to succeed and achieve to benefit themselves.…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Treyvon was unarmed walking out of a 7-11 store with a bag of skittles and an iced tea. Saying he was acting in self-defense, Zimmerman’s trial had become inconclusive due to the lack of evidence in the case file showing that what he had just done was just or unjust. Although Zimmerman has much to blame for this tragic incident, he is not all responsible for this. The United States Legal system shares the blame. Yes, he may have been the one who had shot and killed a young unarmed “innocent” boy; the legal system let him get away with it and did not punish him in any way.…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most of all, officers will never give a clear image of what happened unless there is visual evidence such as a video taken by a bystander. In the Michael Brown killing, police couldn’t stick to one story about what provoked the office into shooting Michael Brown. “The story changed: that Brown was portrayed as a bad kid who may have stolen cigars from a shop. Then footage emerged apparently showing him paying for the cigars” (Penny 24). After the shooting of Michael Brown occurred police protected Officer Darren Wilson was told by police to not talk to any media, and they justified his actions.…

    • 1698 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the trial Atticus brought up Robinson wouldn’t have been able to beat her due to the fact that he had to use his disabled arm which obviously couldn’t have been done, however whenever Robinson was asked is Mayella purposely threw herself at him he never agreed with it. Robinson was later found guilty and was sentenced to death. Before he left the electric chair get the best of him Robinson tried to escape out of the jail yard one day by climbing the fence. Maybe if he wouldn’t have had a disabled arm maybe the outcome would have been different but since that slowed him down he was shot seventeen times after he was given two warning…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perez said that it was a patrol officer who discovered the weapon and that there was no evidence linking the gun to Lobos” (Lait and Glover). Lobos was an innocent man that live in LA but since he looked like a gangster and they needed a suspect. That is why they choose Lobos and not the correct guy they should have arrested and put to jail. Some police officer abuse their authority and frame people they do not like, seem suspicious, or need the person’s money. This is most common one because police officers get away with this case, because it is hard to fight against an officer word.…

    • 1760 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nature Of Poverty Essay

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The doctor said simply if they sent the boy to jail he would have 10% of living a good life and not get the help he needs. There are so many people that commit a low level crime because of poverty and thrown in jail. Where is there chance and who is going to stand up for them. Maybe the state appointed attorney if they cared enough. Once they have a record there done and left poor decision to come if no one helps them.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once they got to a cul-de-sac, the officer pointed a gun at Prince, without showing his badge. Prince got into his car and rammed the undercover officer. The officer killed him. Ta-Nehisi talks about how he pictures himself tin the situation. He would not have trusted the officer because that’s hard to do when the officer was dressed as a criminal yet he didn’t show his badge.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Thesis:The second amendment should not be taken away from the american citizens. The argument that guns kill people is stupid because someone has to exert a force on the weapon for it to even fire. he problem is not guns it’s the crazy people that do crazy things whether they have a gun or a knife or any object that can be used as a weapon so if you are gonna ban guns then you might as well ban kitchen knives and pencils. the people that want to ban guns never look at how many innocent lives are saved by guns in the hands of responsible civilians. to add to this point.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays