In the “Creation Myths of Cooperstown,” Gould supports this postulate by examining the reasoning behind people’s erroneous belief in hoaxes. First, Gould explains that people embrace myths due to their “consonance with our hopes or resonance with our fears.” Rather than rely on rational judgment, people use their sentiments as the sole guide for what to believe and what to do. For instance, Gould demonstrates his point by scrutinizing the origin story of baseball. While factual evidence supports the idea that baseball descended from English stick-and-ball games, the majority of people hold the belief that Doubleday or Cartwright alone conceived the sport. Rather than recognize the game’s evolution, Americans ignore the truth in favor of believing a myth considered to be more interesting, easier to understand, and more
In the “Creation Myths of Cooperstown,” Gould supports this postulate by examining the reasoning behind people’s erroneous belief in hoaxes. First, Gould explains that people embrace myths due to their “consonance with our hopes or resonance with our fears.” Rather than rely on rational judgment, people use their sentiments as the sole guide for what to believe and what to do. For instance, Gould demonstrates his point by scrutinizing the origin story of baseball. While factual evidence supports the idea that baseball descended from English stick-and-ball games, the majority of people hold the belief that Doubleday or Cartwright alone conceived the sport. Rather than recognize the game’s evolution, Americans ignore the truth in favor of believing a myth considered to be more interesting, easier to understand, and more