Constitutional Originalism

Decent Essays
So, I'm writing my philosophy of law paper on constitutional interpretation; "originalism" in particular. At first, I thought the whole idea of originalism kind of silly, but after doing some reading and thinking it's clear that there are some important reasons to consider some brands of originalism. It really comes down to what kind of originalism we're talkin' 'bout. Originalism can be divided roughly into two camps: original intent and original textual meaning. Those in the original intent camp derive their interpretation from trying to figure out what the particular issues of the time were and interpreting the constitution in relation to that.
There are quite a few general problems with this view which I won't go into because I'm

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The defendant in the case that was with Heller, whose last name is Stevens, stated his opinion on the matter. Stevens stated that, “The Second Amendment was adopted to protect the right of the people to maintain a well-regulated militia. It was a response to the concern that the power of congress to disarm the state militias and create a national standing army posed an intolerable threat to state sovereignty (Lawnix, par. 15).” Neither in the manuscript of the Second Amendment or in the quarrels in the advocate’s evidence, was there even the least interest of the Framers in limiting of the legislature’s power of controlling the uses of firearms used by the private citizen. Stevens also said, “There is no indication that the Framers intended…

    • 203 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the short video about activist (Breyer) vs. originalist (Scalia), I learned about the empty bottle, the purpose and consequence, the constitution as the living document, and the decision on the problem. In my opinion, the activist is more liberal because the constitution depends on the nowadays situation. However, the originalist is more conservative since it wants to keep the point that was written by the author. On the purpose and the consequence, Scalia argued that all of the tools should be used in the constitution, and the purpose and consequences needed to be prioritized. Nevertheless, Scalia argued that the limitation was needed on the tools because no one wanted to take risk in the situation that they faced.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Brennan, the originalist view demands that Justices decide exactly what the framers thought about the question under consideration and simply follow through with what they determined the framers intentions to be. However, he argues that from our vantage point, it is impossible to gauge accurately the intent of the founding fathers in addressing contemporary questions. After listing many of the constitutions amendments, Brennan claims, “To remain faithful to the content of the constitution, therefore, an approach to interpreting the text must account for the existence of these substantive value choices, and must accept the ambiguity inherent in the effort to apply them to modern circumstances.” Further, Brennan quotes predecessor Justice Robert Jackson in saying, “the burden of judicial interpretation is to translate ‘the majestic generalities of the Bill of Rights, conceived as part of the pattern of liberal government in the eighteenth century’” for the purpose of supporting the loose interpretation view more…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    New Jersey V. Tto Case

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Question 1: The Constitution and Bill of Rights what did the founders have in mind original intent: constitution was perfect the way it was written, or was it meant to be perfected. The American constitution is a fixed document, because the constitution has only undergone minor changes. As society has been changing, the Constitution’s interpretation has been tweaked and altered to fit today’s situations. The American Constitution and the Bill of Rights drives politics by the way people interpret the constitution.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    It has long been taught that the first constitution and idea of a representative government first came into existence with the creation of the United States’ constitution. However, six hundred years prior to that creation, a group of native tribes came together and forged the America’s true first constitution. Through this creation, a powerful nation, known as the Haudenosaunee, or known as to Europeans the Iroquois Nation, became an important part in the shaping of the Americas. The creation of this constitution would serve as a model for the need and creation of the United States’ own constitution. This will be shown by examining the why it was created, the principles held within it and its influence on the creation of United States Constitution.…

    • 2452 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The 18th century was a time of change and reform for Americans. Having gained newfound independence from Great Britain, they now faced the task of coming up with an efficient way to govern themselves. After a long process, both the Constitution, and eventually the Bill of Rights, both emerged and both which are still the governing documents of America today. In Jack Rakove’s book, Declaring Rights, he states that “how Americans thought about bills of rights was a function of how they thought about constitutionalism more generally.” He was correct in his statement; Americans views on constitutionalism did directly affect how they viewed bills of rights.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Assignment 1: Rewriting the Constitution When the Framer’s first wrote the U.S. Constitution, they included the articles and amendments they felt were necessary for the success of American democracy. Over time, the nation has changed and some of the amendments reflect these changes. However, society is still evolving and the Constitution should continue to evolve with it. The Constitution could be altered to better reflect modern society by addressing the relation of social media to free speech and the amount of funds used to support political campaigns.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Strict Interpretation of the Constitution Strict interpretation means that the Constitution must explicitly grant a power or privilege in order for that action to be legal. A loose interpretation doesn’t give any safeguards against government intrusion on the people’s liberty. Strict interpretation is better because it is an approach more likely to get to what the original intent of the Founders of America was. Whereas loose interpretationists can make new laws and invalidate old ones based on an understanding of the Constitution.…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After reading the first amendment, I felt that the first amendment had many loopholes that the forefathers didn’t imagine at the time, such as flag burning, pornography, solicitation, and tobacco advertising. While reading, I commemorated that the first amendment was created to protect the citizens of the U.S from the power of the federal government. However, according to paragraph 5 of the article, people are misinterpreting the spirit of the amendment to cover other forms of symbolic speech like flag burning and various forms of hate speech. Hate speech and flag burning should be rewritten into the first amendment because hate speech is targeting a group of people that wouldn’t necessarily appreciate it. Flag burning should also be covered…

    • 151 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States Constitution: A just document The United States Constitution has it 's final draft submitted and receives acceptance by thirty-nine of the remaining forty-two delegates today in Philadelphia (Sidlow and Henschen 37). I have received and read a copy of this Constitution given to me by an anonymous source and will go into detail on what this new document proposes. After reading this document, I 'm sure there are many questions that would concern us all. What extent of power does this document give to the new centralized National Government, and how does it affect the several state 's ability to delegate power within themselves?…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Describe some of the principles behind the Constitution. Discuss how the separation of powers and checks and balances are supposed to operate. How did the Constitution arrange the power relationships between the national government and the states? There are several principles behind the United States constitution, such as popular sovereignty, limited government, separation of power, checks and balances, and federalism.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Let us now consider the other side of the coin, the argument in favor of a dead Constitution. In 2008; Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas said at the Manhattan Institute, "Let me put it this way; there are really only two ways to interpret the Constitution -- try to discern as best we can what the framers intended or make it up. No matter how ingenious, imaginative or artfully put, unless interpretive methodologies are tied to the original intent of…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It all started in July 2, 1776 when a committee drafted a formal declaration of Independence for a resolution. “That these United Colonies are, and, of, right, ought to be, free and independent states, that they are absolved from all allegiance to the British crown, and that all political connexion between them and the state of Great Britain is, and ought to be, totally dissolved” (Brinkley 107). After two days’ congress approved the Declaration of Independence which had formal justifications. After the Declaration period of enthusiastic political innovation launched and formation of “State” began. By 1781, most states already made their own version of constitutions.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Federalist Argument

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Trump plans to enlist grassroots and Democrats to sell tax plan he will call biggest in history,” from USA Today connects with, “The Federalist,” the ideas of urban over rural, persuasion, updating ideas, and political disputes all work to tie these pieces of writing together. Many people have feared the urban and wealthy have taken advantage over the poor and rural populations. Americans leaders have tried to please both by coming up with alternative ideas to bring a sense of equality to all people of the region. “Critics say there’s no way to eliminate enough loopholes to compensate for the advantage the wealthy will enjoy from a major rate cut.”…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There has been many Amendments that have been passed to protect the American citizen and his or her rights. Each Amendments in the Bill of Rights and the Articles in the United States Constitution all have a specific role to play in the American society. However, the most important articles are in the Bill of Rights. The Amendment V of the Bill of Rights is the most important one out of the whole ten original Amendments. Amendment V promotes and protects the American idea of unalienable rights of “life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness.”…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays