Sabmiller's Ethical Dilemma

Superior Essays
1. There are multiple relevant stakeholders internally as well as externally whom must be identified to help determine the appropriate ethical decision on the dilemma. Maria Smith is a critical internal stakeholder, as she played a significant role in SABMiller’s tax planning strategy over the past couple of years. Other internal stakeholders include SABMiller’s over 20,000 employees, Board of Directors, and Upper-management. Each one of these stakeholders has a stake in how the company performs directly as they had a role in parts of the decision making and holding the culture.

While looking at internal stakeholders paints an important picture, there are a plethora of external stakeholders to consider as well. First, the public plays a significant
…show more content…
There are multiple long-term consequences for the stakeholders involved if SABMiller opts to continue with their current tax strategy. There are two main outcomes for Maria Smith. First, she could be fired as she was the main reason for the assumed ethical lapse of judgement. On the other side, she could continue to be employed because she saves SABMiller money with her tax strategy. Even if she was fired, other companies would want to have a tax strategist who can help increase their bottom lines, so she should not have an issue finding employment elsewhere. With this, she never did anything illegal and despite the backlash, the ethicality of the treatment is even still in question. While the strategy was aggressive, it was not as aggressive as other companies. If a business is not aggressive in certain areas, then they will fall behind the competition. Therefore, Maria Smith will likely be fine from a job …show more content…
They will hope that their studies and reports will promote change to business practices. If SABMiller continues with their practices without major repercussions, then the studies will become less recognized. With this change in the global tax strategy will be less likely to occur. Combining these, the advocacy groups will look further into other companies to see if they can push their agenda. Regulatory bodies may not be able to completely control multinationals tax strategy; but may look to further increase disclosures in both quarterly and annual reports to improve transparency to the shareholders. The regulatory bodies reputation will increase with this type of progress and the public will most likely desire this information in light of SABMiller continuing their

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Alexandra Corredor P. MGM 2301 Prof. Gwendolyn Wilson Assignment #1: Chapter 3 Understanding the Chapter: What Do I know? 1. How would you explain the difference between internal and external stakeholders? A.- Internal and external stakeholders are two groups of entities that follow a path to achieve their own objective, being that, the main differences between them.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone must make a choice at some point in their lives. Whether it’s choosing what to have for dinner or something bigger and more significant, they all make a difference. In the case of Sanger Rainsford, the latter option is the case. He is faced with an enormous moral decision given to him by an aristocratic Cassock on an island.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The importance of the stakeholders can be describe in different dimension that is based on individual perspective, but haven said that , the most important of the stakeholders is to safe guards, the life of the mental ill health, because there are vulnerable people who needs the assistant and assurances from the society to protect and safeguard their life and right. The government have the duty of making appropriate legislation to make the mental ill health equals and protect them from abuse, and regards the as citizens with same right. It is the media duty to publish good reports about mental ill health that will encourage the society to accept them and treat them with dignity. The medical professional should come up with research on how to give mental ill health a good…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    “Loblaw Companies Limited is the largest food retailer in Canada that encompasses 1,000 corporate and franchise supermarkets that operates under 22 regional and market segment banners”.(Wikipedia) Loblaw Companies have a binding hold on the retail sector of the Canadian economy; the influence Loblaw Companies holds, accelerates the number of customers by offering the lowest prices and by possessing the largest number of retail stores across Canada. By controlling the majority of consumer retail stores(No'Frills, President's Choice, No Name Brands, Joe Fresh, T&T, Shoppers Drugmart (etc); the Loblaw Companies dictate prices in most retail sectors, this is due to overwhelming majority of commodities they own. This domination of a critical sector…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    After all of this one has to wonder if legal positivism is a sound ethical theory for the responsible administrator to use in his/her work environment. This ethical theory is not sound because it takes away a sense of morals that a person grew up with in their lives. Ethics in many ways define who we are and what we think about certain things in this world. By taking that aspect of our lives out when making decisions, you are leaving out the chance to discuss the matter and leaving the decision making to higher ups who might have a different agenda from you, and make a decision that will go against your beliefs and what you feel will be the best for the…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chipotle's Business Model

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The organization’s business model satisfies the five interrelated factors for assessing ethical decisions, which effectively defines it as a socially responsible organization. They do this by supporting local family-farms through the promotion of local and organic food items on their menu over other unsustainable menu items. In doing so, the community benefits by keeping family-farms functional and productive, which in turn, keep locals employed while also keeping its customers and consumers happy and healthy. Perhaps the most potent question that gives doubt to the organization’s social responsibility is if it can still serve the interests of its stakeholders, which is also a factor to be considered in an ethical decision.…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ofra Sherman Case

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages

    She was dealing with confidential information and had no support from either company. As this can be considerate a difficult situation, Sherman is responsible for taking care of those who seek to follow and be a leader at all moment. Her strategy in this situation was to obtain as much information possible about the plans of Glaxo and visualize the different scenarios in case she had to face one or the other. However, as a leader she should have taken the initiative to communicate with Glaxo’s team and pursue answer that could benefit her team. Approaching Glaxo with the intention to be an active member in the process of transition could benefit her and the whole team instead of staying in the back waiting for their futures to be determine.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ethics Case 7-5

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Hi Dennis, I really enjoyed reading your post. I think you did a good job writing about the ethics case 7-5 presented in the textbook. From what you wrote I could understand this case a little more. For example first you discussed about the effect that the change requested by the controller does on the income before taxes. Saying that the effect will happened like the controller wants if those changes occur.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case 7: Gillian and Insider Trading Who has moral responsibility for deciding what to do? In this case we are introduced to Gillian Lee, the Senior Administrative Assistant to the VP of Operations at Global Potash Enterprises (GPE). Gillian is faced with the ethical dilemma of whether or not to use insider information about GPE to her advantage.…

    • 1830 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Values 2 Although Dow Corning’s restricted scope of business to breast implant research will prove that its “corporate culture” upholds the medical community’s “network of ethical value,” at the same time it also proves that it failed to maintain its “free expression” and “conservatism” within capitalistic markets (Brooks & Dunn, 2015, 1-530; Pfeiffer & Forsberg, 2014, p. Inside front cover -161). In other words, Dow Corning’s restricted business model could be viewed by the public as an admission of guilt for not pursuing further capitalistic ventures. Even if Dow Corning acted as a controlling shareholder in another company that produced breast implants, the criticism for doing so would be equally harsh as it would be no different than…

    • 2432 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    First Step Background In 2008, an investigation was launched by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Centers for Disease and Prevention (CDC) to explore the causes of a Salmonella Agona outbreak that affected individuals in multiple states. Although 8 people were hospitalized as a result of an infection, no people died from the outbreak (Center for Disease and Prevention, 2008). This outbreak highlighted the ways in which CDC, FDA, and other governmental agencies collaborate to solve a multistate outbreak. Issues and Additional Information…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Much care and effort should be made to build trust and relationships with stakeholders of all levels. Stakeholders are classified as internal, interface, or external, depending on their boundaries of involvement (Ginter, Duncan & Swayne, 2012). The internal stakeholders for Olympic Medical Center are all of the employees, managers, and volunteers within the organization. Their interface stakeholders include some of the medical staff and corporate officers. Olympic Medical Center’s strategic plan lists all of their numerous community partners who are external stakeholders.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Management of Stakeholders at Starbucks Introduction Irrespective of the size, every organization has its stakeholders. Stakeholders in this context refer to any person, or organization, that has some vested interests in the organization. These interests may be direct or derived. In this regard, Starbucks, which is the world’s most renowned coffee Store, has stakeholders.…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Name and provide a brief overview of the stakeholder organization. Identify and describe the key health care issue the stakeholder is influencing, who is being represented by the stakeholder, the desired impact of the stakeholder on the issue and what the stakeholder’s members or constituents stand to gain if the desired outcome is achieved. Stakeholders are very integral part of any healthcare organization. The stakeholders are basically the group of people or individuals who have interests in the decision making and actions of the organization and they too get affected by the actions of an organization. The stakeholders can be either the directors, investors etc.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The local government and legal authorities are the stakeholders of any company. Because they also affected by the regular operations of company. Their interest with the firm is rightfully paying the taxes and to check there is no violation of any local law.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays