The Shortcomings Of The Supreme Court

Great Essays
In 1954, the Supreme Court shifts its support of protecting economic rights during the Lochner era, to a commitment to equality liberalism. Brown is a proper use of the Supreme Court’s power. Its four valid shortcomings reveal the support Brown had from other political actors. Brown’s support provides the court legitimacy for their ruling and provided an era for equality. This era of equality allowed the court and social movements to work in synergy.
Firstly, the decision undermines the federal system that the 1787 constitution creates and forces the federal courts to micromanage local school boards without the proper implementation powers. However, this shortcoming legitimizes Brown as the Executive Branch implemented the ruling. Brown undermines
…show more content…
This critique is justified because the new racial ordering is working to eliminate the racial discrimination that existed as a result of the past racial ordering. Logically, if citizens were given the option to freely associate, the individuals will not interact with other races because they were previously exposed to the racial ordering of segregation. Derrick Bell alludes to a divide in the African American community based on class, that suggests that some African Americans not interested in desegregation yet, wanted quality schools. However, Sweatt v. Painter shows “separate but equal” can never be truly equal or of the same quality because of inherent differences demonstrating the need for desegregation. Rosenberg explains that Brown was not enforceable until Congress passed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and threatens to stop funding the schools as a result of not desegregating. Nonetheless, Brown’s decision to have a state enforced racial ordering is legitimate as it allows for individuals to have the possibility of eliminating the remains of Jim Crow laws and allow for an equitable society embracing equality liberalism through …show more content…
Despite these critiques Brown is legitimate because other political branches recognize the legitimacy of the court and supports it. As Urofsky states, Brown’s short opinion of eleven pages is a strategic political move to allow newspapers to print the whole opinion to appeal to the citizens’ hearts as it involves innocent school children just interested in equality. The Justices’ backgrounds suggest the decision is political as all justices, except one, lacked judicial experience. This is seen as past politician, Chief Justice Warren, broke tradition by declaring his vote before the other Justices and by visiting the other Justices’ chambers when drafting the opinion to ensure unanimity. The decision’s unanimity is political because the court legitimates their decision by acting united. Justice Frankfurter requests to look at the history of the 14th amendment because he could find no legal justification, yet nothing in the history suggests the unconstitutionality of segregation as many of the schools including those in District of Colombia and 21 states were mandatory or optional segregation. Even Justice Jackson remarks that it was hard to think that “the movement that carried the Civil War…” was desegregation. The justices ignore the history of the 14th amendment and deemed the information

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Professor Gerald Rosenberg, in his analysis on whether courts are powerful agents in achieving social change, highlights two main court views: The Dynamic Court view and the Constrained Court view. The Dynamic Court view holds that courts are successful agents in producing social change, while the constrained court view argues for the opposite (Rosenberg, 2). The American civil rights movement was an important demonstration in Rosenberg’s argument of the Constrained Court view (Rosenberg, 9). The Constrained court view maintains that courts cannot produce social change. In my response, I will deconstruct his court views to understand whether courts can produce significant social reform.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Karlee Sunday Mrs. Holt Due-10/8/17 Law Essay Plessy v. Ferguson and Brown v Board of Education, two of the most landmarking cases that have changed the ways of the U.S. The case of Plessy v. Ferguson started with a man who opposed to discrimination of race, Brown v. Board of Education repealing the Pv. F case and making the final change on discrimination, both cases have similarities changing the way of human history, and the Supreme Court plays a big role in making the final decision. History is made by the people that want to make a change in the world.…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It’s scary to think that only 61 years ago, American schools were still racially segregated, and African American children were kept away from white children. Earlier in 1896, a Supreme Court case called Plessy v. Ferguson made segregation legal as long as the facilities were equal (McBride). In the middle of the twentieth century, many people were working together to challenge these segregation laws. A man named Oliver Brown was one of the many people who challenged segregation laws when he brought the Topeka, Kansas school board to court. Brown v. Board of Education took place in 1954, and surprisingly, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Brown.…

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The minority said that the law was unconstitutional and violated the civil rights, this side was correct but did not win. The court went by the doctrine “separate but equal” meaning two races must be separated but have equal quality. Until in 1945 when Oliver brown helped start the complaint that the schools aren't equal. The majority this time won saying that segregation was hurting the society, then they decided it was unconstitutional. These cases are both very related because they both fight segregation.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is a heated age and the policy of affirmative action is a controversial topic. Ever since it was first introduced in the 1960s, the court has affected the use of affirmative action significantly because its rulings upheld the policy’s constitutionally and made it more acceptable to the public. To begin with, it is important to acknowledge that the court was not the only arena in which affirmative action policies have been challenged. It has also been challenged in arenas such as college admission and the job application process. In my opinion, the case of Brown v. Board of Education had a significant impact on the introducing the affirmative action.…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Following the groundbreaking and overwhelmingly momentous Supreme Court ruling in Brown v. Board of Education, the “separate but equal” policy was officially held unconstitutional. While many celebrated the decision as a testament to upholding racial equality, Southern white nationalists were not so thrilled with the decision. Thus, they created and submitted the Southern Manifesto, a legislative document condemning Brown as a violation of the balance of constitutional power between the nation and states. Moreover, in the Manifesto legislators contended that the “separate but equal” policy had become a “way of life” (Southern Manifesto on Integration) for the United States and that this decision “destroyed the amicable relations between…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first case is about Plessy v Ferguson which is a case that determined whether or not racial segregation is constitutional under the separate but equal doctrine. The second case is about Brown v Board of Education which decided that state laws requiring separate but equal schools violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. Both cases had a powerful effect on the precedents that we now have in today's justice system. Plessy v Ferguson established the doctrine of “Separate but Equal” and Brown v Board of Education concluded that separate public schools for blacks and whites was deemed unconstitutional. Without Plessy v Ferguson and Brown v Board of Education, black and white students would likely still be separated to this day under constitutional laws.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The argument the author states in the essay, (in the first paragraph), “we see clearly now that while the Brown decision informed the attitudes that have shaped contemporary American race relations, it did not resolve persistent disputes about the nation’s civil rights policies” (Carson 1). The author believes that Brown forced white schools to accept black but it did not diversify all schools across the nation. “Two Cheers for Brown vs. Board of Education” is a well structured essay, but it lacks one component of the five argumentative essay components. The essay lacks evidence to support the variety of historical information presented.…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the jury is ready to announce their decision, everyone in the courtroom holds their breath. The juror clears his throat, gulping. He unfolds the slip of paper and announces the guilty verdict. The men on one side of the court, smiles on their faces, are astonished that they won, euphoric that they had accomplished this hard task.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Desegregation and Integration: How the Brown Versus Board Trial Changed America The end of the Jim Crown era was much more than the conclusion to government-supervised racism, but the start to new lives as minorities.” The Supreme Court made it clear that America’s commitment to civil rights was firm and unshakeable” (Shwarz 84).The ruling dramatically changed the society by declaring an end to segregation in schools. Minorities, who were forced to take a subjacent role on all topics of America like voting and other unalienable rights, were now able to take their principled spots as American citizens.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Little Rock Nine Essay

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages

    During this week’s reading, my eye was caught by the actions of then-Governor of Arkansas Orval Faubus in the wake of Brown v. Board of Education II (1955). Even as he felt pressures from both the judicial and executive branches of government, he refused to comply with the new standards of racial equality. In 1955, the Supreme Court issued a decision on the case that came to be known as Brown v. Board of Education II, ruling that states must immediately end any segregation in their school systems immediately. Not surprisingly, many states in the South fought this new regulation tooth and nail, but the textbook raised one particularly interesting case: Governor Orval Faubus.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    PS1355 Unit 3 Assignment 1: Brown and Federalism Sierra Baltins Wednesday Judicial review is the court’s authority to check on executive or legislative acts to see if they are constitutional or not. The Supreme Court uses the power of judicial review to ban state and federal laws that go against the Constitution. If members of the judicial districts and circuits are unhappy with Supreme Court decisions they may attempt to pass a bill to prevent federal court hearings. This power has been used to point out that “separate but equal” went against the 14th amendment. The 14th amendment meant equal protection, and “separate but equal” made African American students feel inferior to white students.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The conflict over black equality has been an issue since the Civil War. After the Civil War, equality was slowed by many court cases and state laws. “Separate but Equal” was a term used to demonstrate that white and black people were to be separated, but have the same facilities available. Unfortunately, this was not always the case. The struggle to achieve equality was made difficult by the legislation of racism in the Plessy v. Ferguson case.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brown v. Board of Education is a historical landmark case that came from Topeka, Kansas where a young girl by the name of Linda Brown was denied admission to her local elementary school for the color of her skin. This supreme court case made the decisive decision between whether racial segregations in public schools is unconstitutional. More decisively the decision that changed the ruling of Plessy v. Ferguson that argued that although people are separate but equal, when it comes to education there is no way to make it fully equal then to integrate. This case was used by the NAACP to fight for Linda Brown. Allowing her and many other people like her to go to the all-white school.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Separate But Equal Essay

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Separate but Equal Plessy v. Ferguson was the first case to justify segregation using the ‘separate but equal’ doctrine. The Supreme Court’s stand on the Brown v the Board of Education case has been appreciated with much significance. To some people it was a sign of the beginning of the civil rights in the 1950s and the 1960s while to others it was an indication of the crumbling of segregation. The Brown decision is a landmark in history as it overturned the legal policies that had been established by the Plessy v. Ferguson decisions that made practices of separate but equal legal. For a long time, civil rights movements in the first fifty years of the 290th century were concurrent with the policy, separate but equal, in efforts to get a grip…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays