Confinement Vs Superstition

Good Essays
A lunchroom fight breaks out and the prison guards come rushing in to break it up. The man that had started it is being placed in solitary confinement because of the actions that he portrayed during the fight. These actions led to him becoming completely isolated from everyone else for days and maybe even weeks. The prisons that still have solitary confinement claim that it teaches the inmates a lesson by keeping them away in isolation in cruel conditions. Furthermore, this will get the prisoners to stop acting up in the future. It has been proven that by keeping the very aggressive prisoners in solitary confinement that it will help keep the other prisoners safe as well. However, studies have shown that placing inmates in solitary confinement …show more content…
In point of fact, when a prisoner gets left alone in isolation for a period of time, they have time to reflect on themselves. They now have a chance to see the errors that they may have made in their lives and change their character to make themselves a better person (“Should Jails, Prisons Use Solitary Confinement?”). Strictly speaking, solitary confinement will change a very dangerous person into a better one. Furthermore, once the prisoner is placed in solitary confinement they won’t want to be put back there. Once out of solitary, the prisoner will try everything they can not to go back, which ultimately makes them a better person (“FRONTLINE”). As a result, by placing a prisoner in solitary confinement it will make them a nicer and better person when they get out. The goal of this is to make them socially acceptable when they get out of …show more content…
It has been proven that long periods of isolation and loneliness can cause major mental disorders like schizophrenia (Hadro). It has also been proven that prisoners that have been to solitary confinement have sometimes committed suicide while in it or when they get out of it (Hadro). These claims can be debunked because most of the people that are said to have gotten mental disorders in solitary have already had some before they got there (Metzner). This means that solitary confinement doesn’t always cause a prisoner to get a mental disorder. In addition, the better you behave while in solitary confinement the less you have to stay in solitary confinement (Chammah). This is saying that if you behave well while in solitary, you have a less of a chance to develop a mental disorder. This makes it very clear that solitary confinement is not the real reason why people are developing mental disorders and also they can be prevented by the inmate if they behave well enough. Ultimately, solitary confinement will continue to keep people safe, change a person’s character, and help the guards discipline the prisoners. By keeping solitary confinement a viable technique, it will be what is best for not only the public but also the rest of the United States. If it is terminated the crime rates will never drop and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Throw Away The Key Analysis

    • 2405 Words
    • 10 Pages

    I somewhat agree with this, but we will never know unless they are given the chance to learn from their mistakes because after all they are human like me and you. This author is making the decision that will benefit society by keeping them in prison. Is are they not also part of society. They have made mistakes as a normal human would but don’t get a second chance because it would be a threat. There are solutions that are working, but we as society don’t want inmates to go…

    • 2405 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Their participation can help the case more and have a higher chance of getting their accused sent to jail. By giving information about what was witnessed, it provides closure and a bond between the justice system. There can be a change where a victim does not participate due to emotional stress. This can cause the accused to end up not guilty just based upon their main witness not testifying and providing information to the system. At the end of the day, the justice system wants to help people, but to do so they need cooperation.…

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “The interpersonal and emotional aspects of the therapeutic relationship… linked to increased neural plasticity, emotional regulation, and attachment behavior,” (Bland, 2014). Bland believes that when the inmates are given time with the correctional counselors they have to create a relationship with that counselor in order to open up and discuss ways to make their situation better. Because inmates are not given enough time with the correctional counselors, they are unable to make that close relationship and make their situations better. One perspective of correctional counseling is that by telling the inmate that, “they are valuable only if they behave, think, and feel a certain way,” (Farber, Bohart, and Stiles, 2012). Bland disagrees with this perspective because if you tell an inmate just to believe that things can get better, they are not learning how to change their situation and they are not bonding with their counselor.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It possibly could seem as a loss of responsibility but it is not . We need prisoners to learn how to better themselves which will in fact better society as a whole. The only way to try to rehabilitate criminals is to allow them to take certain programs which will help the individual stay sane, learn a trade, and meet god. Having prisoners set goals in their time of imprisonment will surly make the prison society have a much safer atmosphere. (Colson, Charles.…

    • 2222 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With the improvement of these areas, the inmates can be better educated and safer. It is a risk to release inmates back into society without helping them develop as an individual. If that is something that the prison systems can’t do, then the system is flawed. Society is in danger because inmates are in prisons to be corrected and if that is not something that happens then those inmates are just going to go back do the exact thing they were doing before they were in prison. Educating them is one of the most important elements that needs to happen.…

    • 2629 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Once released from prison it is difficult for the offender to become a productive citizen because they have no sense of responsibility, therefore their decision making for themselves is disrupted. As a suggestion upon release offenders should be given more responsibility. For instance, like the prison in Norway (which has low recidivism rates), inmates were given responsibility giving them a sense of purpose and dignity. Not suggesting that America should adapt a prison like the Norway prison, but the factor of responsibility is important for successful re-entry. Possibly allowing offenders to move to a low security prison-upon release- would enable them to grow a sense of responsibility and help them successfully re-enter into society.…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The offender is given the opportunity to leave the jail as long as they have a place to live and a job waiting for them. It is believed that if you treat the criminal with respect and fairness, they are less likely to foster defiance and continue their criminal path. Restorative justice also reduces the offender’s criminal involvement (Lilly, Ball, & Cullen 2015). Restorative justice is not going to be as effective if they offender is court ordered to do so. It has also been found that it is “more effective with low-risk offenders” (Lilly, Ball & Cullen, 2015).…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I think the mentally ill will do better in a mental facility, especially getting the treatment they need. The mentally ill will eventually stop being a danger to themselves and others. They will be where they belong rather than where they were thrown in. We cannot just send them to a prison because there is no space for them somewhere else; there should be options for them. They make mistakes, but hey!…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I believe it falls under this category because the system believes that by keeping this inmates in solitary facilities, it will teach them discipline, order and it will create more security because the inmates will not be able to harm other individuals. The system hope that by keeping the inmates locked in a room for twenty-three hours a day, it will help them repent for their crimes and thus they will be ready to go back to society. In order for them to reenter society, they need rehabilitation.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Even if the man did not have a desire for education, he would have had the option of vocational training. For prisoners who do not have a desire for a college education, vocational training is often a more pleasant alternative. As one man said,“Inmates agree that being employed in CI provides them with an incentive to stay out of trouble for a number of reasons” (Richmond 240). Although there is sometimes a negative stigma around vocational training, many prisoners change their attitude about it because of the skills they are earning. Similar to college education, vocational training allows a person to set goals for themselves through hard work.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays