Conceivability and Possibility Essay

1640 Words Nov 29th, 2010 7 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Student’s Name Professor’s Name Course Title/Number 17 December 2010 Conceivability as a Guide to Possibility In his scholarly article entitled, Does Conceivability Entail Possibility (2002), Professor David J. Chalmers of the University of Arizona examines the argument that to conceive of something necessarily entails its possibility. Chalmers states that arguments regarding conceivability and possibility typically consist of three parts; the first is the epistemic

middle of document…

So in this case, although conceivability does not mirror natural possibility, it may well mirror metaphysical possibility. (Chalmers, para. 4)



While Chalmers leaves this particular argument open-ended, he seems to be suggesting that any physical law conceived of is metaphysically possible. The test of the degree of this possibility involves further defining the degree of conceivability. According to Chalmers, there are three sub-arguments for conceivability as entailing possibility: prima facie vs. ideal conceivability, positive vs. negative conceivability, and primary vs. secondary conceivability as entailing possibility.

Prima facie conceivability occurs when S is conceivable upon first appearance, or when there are no apparent contradictions to S. For example, it is prima facie conceivable that a table is made of wood if---at first glance---nothing apparently suggests otherwise. In order for S to be ideally conceivable, however, S has to pass certain tests that support it’s conceivability. In the case of the table, for example, one would have to further examine the table and still believe it to be made of wood for it to be ideally conceivable that it is made of wood. Obviously, ideal conceivability is superior to prima
CRAM Exclusive
Pear53693Hand

Related Documents

  • The Destruction of the Planet and the Possibility of Reform Essay

    The Destruction of the Planet and the Possibility of Reform It is widely accepted that humans have been a major cause of environmental problems since we began creating our cities and especially since the Industrial Revolution of the 20th century. All aspects of the Earth have been affected by humans' desire to conquer and dominate the planet. Our impact has gone beyond pollution to altering the functioning of many natural systems. These systems include our atmosphere, several land ecosystems

    Words: 722 - Pages: 3
  • Possibility of a Future Avian Flu Pandemic Essay example

    Possibility of a Future Avian Flu Pandemic Influenza is a dangerous virus and highly contagious that has potential to devastate populations should an outbreak occur. A common influenza virus that humans are familiar with is the human influenza. Researchers and scientists are concerned about an especially threatening strain of influenza virus called H5N1, commonly known as the avian flu. Although this flu is mainly susceptible to wild birds, there have been outbreaks that show that humans also

    Words: 1409 - Pages: 6
  • Homoerotic and Homophobic Possibilities in The Castle of Otranto

    Homoerotic and Homophobic Possibilities in The Castle of Otranto Eve Sedgwick describes the gothic novel as a “dialectic between the homosexual and homophobic” (92). Homosexuality was first recognized in the eighteenth century and resulted in far reaching social responses. With the establishment of the term “homosexuality”, social tensions appeared. These tensions found their way into novels as fears of sexuality and the struggle for sexual expression. Sedgwick terms this emerging homoeroticism

    Words: 1396 - Pages: 6
  • Productive Efficiency and In Efficiency of a Production Possibility Frontier

    Productive Efficiency and In Efficiency of a Production Possibility Frontier (PPF) Introduction The production possibility frontier is also known as the (PPF) in the economics world. It is simply a graph or diagram that does clearly show the production rate of two goods and/or services that an economy does produce efficiently or inefficiently over a given period of time. It accurately shows the production levels of the maximum to the minimum amounts produced in a uniformly drawn curve. This is usually

    Words: 1419 - Pages: 6
  • The Possibilities of Utopias in Gulliver's Travels by Jonathan Swift

    The idea of the perfect and model state has existed since the beginning of civilization. In Jonathon Swift’s satirical novel Gulliver’s Travels, Gulliver travels to remote lands and is keen on analyzing and investigating the possibility of utopias. There are noticeable instances of utopias in Gulliver’s Travels; such is symbolized by the Houyhnhnms and the Lilliputians. However, most of these states could not be logically achievable in Swifts’ English society due to the fact that it would require

    Words: 629 - Pages: 3
  • Should Juvenile Offenders Be Sentenced to Life Without the Possibility of Parole

    After reading the article Should Juvenile offenders ever be sentenced to life without the Possibility of Parole (Steinberg, L.& Scott, E. 2010) I did some research on the adolescence stage of human development, regarding the reason juvenile offenders should not be sentenced to life without the possibility of parole. And I have conducted a few facts of the adolescent brain supporting this argument. I have heard many stories of the cruel and evil crimes that some children have committed. There

    Words: 1133 - Pages: 5
  • Possibility for Greatness Essay

    knowledge of what is sacrificed for their life, along with all the opportunities and freedoms they are given and make choices to give great significance to what is sacrificed. The secluded child in “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” symbolizes the possibility for greatness. The people of Omelas take the opportunities they have to improve and advance their lives so that they can give a meaning to the seclusion and mistreatment of the child in the basement. LeGuin narrates through the text that by the

    Words: 879 - Pages: 4
  • Evil and the Possibility of the Conversion into Good Essay

    Evil and the Possibility of the Conversion into Good According to Kant, radical evil is the deep inherent blemish of our species that does not spare even the best of people. Despite judging the extirpation of such evil as an impossibility, Kant holds out the possibility of converting evil into good by means of human forces. But how can this be given the radical evil of human nature? I articulate various problems that arise from Kant’s conception of conversion while exploring certain resources

    Words: 3766 - Pages: 16
  • Exploring the Possibilities of Renewable Energy Essay

    Advantages & Possibilities Wind is caused by differences in temperature in the atmosphere (LeMone, 1994, p. 331). These variations in temperature cause winds to blow across almost every part of the globe. These winds have the possibility to produce energy that could power thousands of homes in the future. Wind energy has one unmistakable advantage over fossil fuels which is cleanliness. There is no pollution from windmills at all. Some estimates of the possibilities of wind power show

    Words: 3465 - Pages: 14
  • Essay on The Possibilities of the Gap Year

    and but overall better citizens of character (O’Shea 576). Overall, students learned about life and their identities on their gap year creating a better future for themselves and their communities.   Works Cited Bull, Holly. “The Possibilities of the Gap Year.” Chronicle of Higher Education 52.44 (2006): 77. Academic Search Complete. Web. 19 March 2014. Chanzky, Jean. “If Your Kid Wants to Find Himself, Just Say Yes.” Money 34.12 (2005): 40-42. Business Source Complete. Web. 19 March

    Words: 3789 - Pages: 16