Conceivability and Possibility Essay

1640 Words Feb 28th, 2011 7 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Student’s Name Professor’s Name Course Title/Number 17 December 2010 Conceivability as a Guide to Possibility In his scholarly article entitled, Does Conceivability Entail Possibility (2002), Professor David J. Chalmers of the University of Arizona examines the argument that to conceive of something necessarily entails its possibility. Chalmers states that arguments regarding conceivability and possibility typically consist of three parts; the first is the epistemic

middle of document…

So in this case, although conceivability does not mirror natural possibility, it may well mirror metaphysical possibility. (Chalmers, para. 4)

While Chalmers leaves this particular argument open-ended, he seems to be suggesting that any physical law conceived of is metaphysically possible. The test of the degree of this possibility involves further defining the degree of conceivability. According to Chalmers, there are three sub-arguments for conceivability as entailing possibility: prima facie vs. ideal conceivability, positive vs. negative conceivability, and primary vs. secondary conceivability as entailing possibility.
Prima facie conceivability occurs when S is conceivable upon first appearance, or when there are no apparent contradictions to S. For example, it is prima facie conceivable that a table is made of wood if---at first glance---nothing apparently suggests otherwise. In order for S to be ideally conceivable, however, S has to pass certain tests that support it’s conceivability. In the case of the table, for example, one would have to further examine the table and still believe it to be made of wood for it to be ideally conceivable that it is made of wood. Obviously, ideal conceivability is superior to prima
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • Evil and the Possibility of the Conversion into Good Essay

    The first one is stronger and fundamental as it maintains that free-will is not definitely committed to any maxim generally accepted. The second argument is subsidiary, pointing out a possibility of compromise between free-will and a good ground maxim in the way of building up a coherent system of maxims, what would be clearly impossible if a bad ground maxim were to be chosen. On the basis of such arguments one can demonstrate how conversion may be possible, although not as definitive and complete

    Words: 3766 - Pages: 16
  • Alternate Possibilities and Moral Responsibility by Harry Frankfurt

    accepting of the consequence of not following Black’s orders is still an alternate possibility. Adding Black into the equation doesn’t remove the moral responsibility on Jones. Nevertheless, with all inquiries, there will be objections to findings. There are objections to how Frankfurt is approaching the Principle of Alternate Possibilities. David Copp wrote an essay, “Defending the Principle of Alternate Possibilities: Blameworthiness and Moral Responsibility,” where he states that Frankfurt cases

    Words: 785 - Pages: 4
  • Essay on The Possibilities of the Gap Year

    A gap year experience is unique to each individual as are the outcomes, working with an interest, such as doing community service with children or working at a newspaper company, will help a student create a life-altering impact on his/her personality and life (O’Shea 567). If a student does not have a plan for the gap year or he/she is not very motivated, it can cause him/her to not return to the original higher education goals (Sutherland 1). Basically meaning that if a gap year is not properly

    Words: 3789 - Pages: 16
  • Possibility for Greatness Essay

    These aspects represent, in fact, well-blended necessities of human existence. If Omelas was to be faced with unhealthy children, lack of food to harvest, and constant poor weather the people would suffer immensely and eventually would be unable to survive. Also, without wise scholars and tender friendships the community as a whole would be unable to peacefully live together and advance their way of life. Through the text LeGuin has narrated that the child’s seclusion is imperative to the survival

    Words: 879 - Pages: 4
  • The Destruction of the Planet and the Possibility of Reform Essay

    Some these chemicals, namely carbon dioxide, also is a result of our destruction of the land. Deforestation of both old growth forests and rain forests have contributed to the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere because this means that there are less trees that can recycle this carbon dioxide to oxygen, thus the impact of the natural carbon cycle is limited. This mass clear cutting of forests also destroys the habitat of many species that are unique only to those environments, not to mention the posiblities

    Words: 722 - Pages: 3
  • Exploring the Possibilities of Renewable Energy Essay

    These figures convert into the fact that the United States contains only 5 percent of the global population, but consumes 25 percent of the world's energy. The amount of energy used in the United States alone poses a problem when looking at alternative energy sources. Renewable energy sources will have to be successful and as plentiful as petroleum to provide the amount of energy needed around the world (Mathewson, 1999, p. 279-80). Renewable Energy: Is It Necessary? Renewable Energy is

    Words: 3465 - Pages: 14
  • Possibility of a Future Avian Flu Pandemic Essay example

    Of the three influenza types, the Avian Flu seems to pose the greatest threat for a devastating pandemic due to its deadly characteristics. (Paul T ambyah- pg 13) As stated in its name, Avian Flu and is usually found in domestic and wild birds. This disease can be transmitted to humans, but in generally transmitted from bird-to- bird. ?Human Influenza is transmitted by the inhalation of airborne secretions and the infectious respiratory droplets (invisible to the naked eye) released by infected

    Words: 1409 - Pages: 6
  • Bus 230 Aid the Power of Possibility/Bus230Aiddotcom Essay

    Choose one other country and identify the products it would need to do without. ................................................................................... BUS 230 Unit 3 Part 2 (UOP) FOR MORE CLASSES VISIT Part 2 Small companies typically have difficulty competing against large multinationals when their governments take part in regional trade blocs. What could governments do to help their small companies compete after the formation of such blocs? ...........

    Words: 849 - Pages: 4
  • Fin 419 Edu the Power of Possibility/Fin419Edu.Com Essay

    What is the most you would pay today for a promise to repay you $3,500 at the end of 10 years if your opportunity cost is 6% ? d. Compare, contrast, and discuss your findings in part a through c. 4) Loan Payment Determine the equal, annual, end-of-year payment required each year over the life of the loan to repay it fully during the stated term of the loan. 5) Loan amortization schedule Personal Finace Problem Joan Messineo borrowed $18,000 at a 14% annual rate of interest to be repaid over

    Words: 1467 - Pages: 6
  • Productive Efficiency and In Efficiency of a Production Possibility Frontier

    an economy to produce relatively more capital goods or services and relatively fewer consumer goods or services, or the other way round. There are several assumptions made by any economies during the usage of the two good model of a production possibility frontier. The government barely assumes that in that particular situation ecological calamities, natural disasters and military intrusion will not happen. The assumption is usually that even if these calamities do

    Words: 1419 - Pages: 6