Comparison Of The Psychoanalytic Approach And The Humanistic Perspective

Superior Essays
Compare and contrast Psychoanalytic Theory to that of Social Cognitive Perspective and the Humanistic Perspective. Also, tell me who are the primary psychologists who came up with each theory/perspective?

Sigmund Freud was an influential psychiatrist and clinical psychologist. Freud began his work when he found that the disorders of the patients he was seeing made no neurological sense. What could be causing feelings that had no physical cause? He began to wonder if neurological disorders had psychological causes. He developed his belief that our unconscious mind plays a greater part in our patterns of thinking, feeling, and acting (i.e. personality) than we previously believed it did. Freud believed that the personality was shaped toward
…show more content…
It is a genetically determined part of our temperament, there is brain activity and autonomic nervous system activity that all reacts to the situations and events we are in. Freud believed that we also had no control of the stages we entered as a child. The trend seems to be that there is some aspect of our personality that we lack control over. Whether it is a psychosexual stage or a biological influence, humans can not entirely control their own personalities. The social-cultural influence is just what I said above- cultural expectations, social support, and childhood experiences all change how we will react to people in situations. If you think someone is mad at you, you are less likely to be warm and outgoing towards that person. This contrast greatly to the humanistic perspective below. The humanistic perspective states that you can influence your personality if you come from a positive background, have a positive outlook and basically if you are a genuine and healthy person. Maslow and Rogers believe that people can reach self-actualization rather than staying confined to their situation, past experience or biology- if their basic needs are …show more content…
Bandura’s theories were praised for getting psychologists to think about the way individuals and their situations affected one another. Freud’s theories were praised for getting psychologists to think about how a personality could largely be shaped through the unconscious. The amount of “unconscious” attribution in Bandura’s theory stops at the way people attune to certain situations that they may have previously been in. For example, an anxious person will view the world as life-threatening. Bandura’s best way for predicting future behavior is often used today in applications- look at the person’s past behavior in a similar situation to predict how they will act. This is called an assessment strategy, by looking at their past behavior, or simulating a new situation you can get an accurate view of the person’s personality.
The social-cognitive theory is useful for determining future behavior, while Freud’s psychoanalysis only determines what the impetus of a specific personality aspect is. The humanistic personality theory is the theory suggested by Maslow and Rogers. Immediately a huge contrast between the humanist theory and the psychoanalytical theory is that the humanist perspective encourages theories focused on healthy people driving for

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Albert Ellis considers that there are specific symptoms that will show the therapist how the client may view events and situations that bring out unhealthy behaviors or thoughts. An example of this is a client that is dealing with depression. When I become a therapist, I would use cognitive and behavioral therapy that will allow me to touch base on prior conditions from any environment or trauma that will not allow the client to control unhealthy behaviors through rational thoughts. Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) plays a big role in Cognitive behavior therapy because it explains how beliefs, interpretations, and reactions to life situation can bring a client to have irrational beliefs that starts in a clients childhood and creates these unhealthy thoughts that can bring a client to have a depression. I consider that REBT therapy can be beneficial to the client because it can help the client have a rational emotive imagery which means the client can picture themselves how they really want to behave in life.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    CBT sees the process of change as a relatively short-term process. Psychodynamic theory on the other hand, is a long term process of change. While both aim to reduce symptoms and distress, perhaps the most central difference between CBT and psychodynamic therapy is that psychodynamic therapy tries to get at why you feel or behave the way you do by uncovering deeper and often unconscious motivations for feelings and behavior. CBT educates clients to identify dysfunctional thought patterns, perceptions, and behavior and replace them with more realistic ones in order to alter behavior and emotions. Despite the…

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Theories Of Eminem

    • 1906 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Also, analyzing his behaviors by different personality theories makes it possible to catch his personality patterns properly. Theories of Freud and Erikson might be the most appropriate personality theories while focusing on the unsettled psychological development of Eminem. Sigmund Freud's Psychodynamic Theory that perceives human personality as the result of largely unconscious forces and internal conflicts among the structures of human mind. Because psychosexual conflicts does not constitutes the huge part of Eminem's personality of psychological conflicts, it will be appropriate to focus mostly on other personality dimensions that affects human personality of Freud while studying personality of Eminem. So, the Psychodynamic Theory could explain the roots of Eminem's psychological struggles by focusing on his unconscious childhood conflicts.…

    • 1906 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Therefore, it must mobilise its defences. Consequently, symptoms can result in it being even less likely that the true nature of the problem (underlying conflict) will be spotted. (Gross, 2010, p730) A strength of this theory is it explains the different parts of our minds. Another thing which makes this theory more creditable is how the understanding of human nature allowed the inventions of different therapies. A weakness of this theory however is, we can sometimes rely on the unconscious/memories too often.…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Complexity Of Personality

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Understanding the complexity behind personality gives a unique advantage of self awareness and awareness of other individuals. Doing so we 've achieved the ambition of psychology which is to predict and control human behavior. Personality is built up of 5 traits ( Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism) that develop through experiences and occurring events. Hence, personality is who we are because of what we 've been through. Which leads to the capability of controlling others and predicting their behavior because of what their past has given them a reputation of.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The purpose of the Psychoanalytical therapy, the Psychoanalysis, is insight. It deals with the unconscious, encouraging the client to uncover the past in order to bring memory to significant events and understand unresolved conflicts. In contrast, the purpose of the Cognitive Therapy is to help the client change their behavior by recognizing negative thought patterns and learning new ways of thinking in order to find solutions to current problems. It focuses on the conscious, the here and now. The key therapeutic interventions used in Psychoanalysis are free association, interpretation, analysis of transference, resistance and dreams, and projective tests (e.g.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The behaviorist would imply a type of therapy that would position the client into an ordinary, realistic, concrete condition where he or she is bothered by depression and anxiety, while a cognitive psychologist preform a therapy session very similar to this; in addition, the cognitive psychologist would also examine how the client’s destructive thoughts contribute to the anxiety and customs to think positively. The humanist approach today would attempt to aid the individual so he or she could come into terms with their, often, painful actuality in the world by accommodating the obligation of their existential self-determination. Cognitive is the leading sort of therapy used to treat anxiety because the best cure is to approach the clients own thoughts; although the behavioral and humanistic approaches work, cognitive is the most commonly used…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Milton et al. (2011) described psychoanalysis as a theory that explores the human mind workings, and a method of psychotherapeutic treatment. Psychoanalysis was founded by the psychologist Sigmund Freud (Jarvin, 2011). The central feature of this theory is the belief that most of the thoughts and dreams are unconscious: the individual is unaware of its existence (Milton et al., 2011). The main aim of psychoanalysis as follows: to help individual’s suffering from psychological disorder, gain insight about the cause of disorder, work towards change, to utilise healthier methods of defence, to alleviate the symptoms and distress caused due to the disorders, and strengthen the ego to manage inner balance effectively (British Psychoanalytic Council,…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For both major and minor emotional disorder, facing their problems through introspection is necessary. Knowing a psychological phenomenon can relieve people as the academic study shows that there are similar cases with they-selves’. For example, when trypophobia became a widely used word, people have become possible to explain their irrational fear about the collected holes. After…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cognition is our thoughts, so cognitive behavioral therapy combines working with our thought process and changing our behavior at the same time. CBT starts by breaking down your problems into smaller components, often trying to identify certain problematic thoughts or behavior. CBT is a form of psychoanalysis that focuses on the importance of thinking in determining human actions. However, Cognitive behavioral psychotherapists believe that the thinking of an individual influences his or her actions and emotions. Hence, if an individual is experiencing undesirable feelings and behavior, it is a result of his or her thinking.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays