Animal Farm Comparison Essay

Superior Essays
Aside from the obvious species differences in the characters of Animal Farm and 1984 (animals and humans), the characters of both books offer an interesting comparison. Napoleon, great leader of the animal rebellion, mirrors many of the authority figures in 1984, such as Big Brother, leader of the Party, or O’Brien, member of the privileged Inner Party. O’Brien in particular offers a good contrast to Napoleon. Both the pig and the man share the dubious characteristic of hiding behind an identity that promotes hope among the masses. O’Brien pretends to be a member of a secret resistance society, the Brotherhood, and easily fools Winston and Julia into trusting him, ultimately sealing their doom. Napoleon is less subtle, but all of rights he …show more content…
In Animal Farm, the prevailing ideology that controls the farm is the philosophy of Animalism. The seeds of Animalism were planted in the minds of the pigs after Old Major’s rebellion-inciting speech at the beginning of the story. Napoleon and a few of the other pigs then crafted the philosophy of Animalism as it exists throughout most of the story. Eventually, the pigs simplify the philosophy into seven rules, called the Seven Commandments. The Seven Commandments include important truths such as “Whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy” (Orwell 24), and “Whatever goes upon four legs or has wings is a friend” (Orwell 24). There are also rules governing animal behavior, and the most important commandment of all, “All animals are equal” (Orwell 25). The basic ideology of Animalism begins as a seemingly innocuous list of rules, but all of these commandments are eventually changed until they barely mean what they did when the ideology was conceived. While Animalism may have started out as a good set of rules that eventually “went bad,” the ideals of IngSoc, 1984’s governing philosophy were obviously disordered from the start. The ideology is based on the simple fact that Big Brother (de facto the Party) is the supreme ruler of the country. All things good are attributed to the Party, all things bad are wiped out, so that they never existed. There are three slogans that …show more content…
I don’t blame you. George Orwell wrote Animal Farm and 1984 especially to warn against the dangers of Communism and Socialism in the mid-1940s. The characters, events and ideologies he created in both books were especially relevant in that time period. The frightening part about both books is the simple fact that they still apply to us today, nearly seventy-five years later. Uninformed voters, citizens of countries who don’t know basic events in their national histories, foreign countries run by dictators, and government overreach all exist today. In fact, they are alive and thriving in some places. The challenge is to listen. Now more than ever, in a world where media and politicians constantly bicker, we must listen to the silent promptings of Mr. Orwell’s books, about futures that must never come to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Perhaps the reasons of similarity do not match to another’s standards, or the differences do not stand out enough to be considered heavily contrasting. The movie, after all, can stand alone with no prior background, why compare it to a book written fifty or so years ago? The book stands as a very old book, standards for a story could have changed since the time it was published and required changes to a movie. There exists a number of things that could contradict the statements above, questioning why there even needs to be any comparing of the two. The differences in the novel and movie of Animal Farm makes both unique in their respective fields.…

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George Orwell, the author of the classic novel 1984, created at the time it was published on June 8, 1949 a distant utopia set 31 years ago from today that is shockingly not that far off in a sense. This fictional world that the main protagonist Winston lives in called Oceania depicts a world of endless war and the control and oppression of its inhabitants, voiding the rights of its citizens. It seems as though like Orwell effectively predicted a similar outcome to the progression of society to the modern world that we indeed live in today. Some may already say we’ve arrived at that point, but others will at least agree that it seems we are definitely heading in that direction. The two terrifying things about George Orwell’s 1984 is first…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The writer of the novel Animal Farm, George Orwell, and the writer of the teleplay Animal Farm, Alan Janes, based their writings on containing several similarities and differences. The similarities between the novel and the book subsist of The Seven Commandments, the Animalism Flag, and the key point of Old Major’s speech. The Seven Commandments stand as a similarity because they stayed consistent whether they changed or not throughout the novel and movie. The Animalism Flag stands as a similarity as well because in the novel and the movie it remained a green tablecloth with a hoof and horn painted on it in white. The key point of Old Major’s speech stands as a similarity in both the novel and the movie because the key point stood as the rebellion…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sadly many similarities in dystopian books and movies are showing up in our society today such as the different social classes, the government watching us online etcetera. It’s scary how dystopian books and movies are so closely similar to modern time. Some that really stand out are from the book Animal Farm by George Orwell and movie V for Vendetta. In summary, Animal farm revolves around the Russian Revolution but Mr. Orwell uses animals to delineate indirectly the people involved in the Russian Revolution. People such as Stalin, his mindless followers, and others.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal Farm Comparison Contrast The novel, Animal Farm by George Orwell conveys multiple similarities and differences regarding the movie. In the movie, as well the book Mr.Jones the owner of the farm is a drunk, Old Major a highly respected elder dies, and Napoleon destroys the order of the farm. However in the movie, unlike the book Old Major was shot by Mr.Jones’ bullet, Mr.Jones was a cheater, Mr.Pilkington was on the animal's’ side from the beginning, and Squealer turned out to be just as evil as Napoleon. The setting in the beginning of the book takes place as Mr.Jones forgetting to lock up because of the whiskey he drank prior that evening. As for the movie, his behavior did not change.…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Title In a world which attacks language, history, and love, is thought possible? In Animal Farm and 1984, citizens under totalitarian rule experienced this world; the results were catastrophic. Language, history, and love, all essential to freedom of thought, were distorted and became nothing more than tools—puppets—used for manipulation. As a result, citizens of Animal Farm and Oceania lost their ability to think beyond the propaganda fed to them, blindly accepting it as reality.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Animal Farm Comparison Contrast The novel Animal Farm by George Orwell had its similarities and differences. Some of the differences were that rather than the animals talking in the beginning of the book, the narrator tells mostly all the story. Old Major dies by natural causes in the novel, but in the book, he dies by a gunshot. In the movie, they show Old Majors head and in the book it doesn’t.…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In George Orwell’s novel, Animal Farm, he proves that it is inevitable for humans to equate everyone. Orwell explains this by his story which is about a group of farm animals that rebel against their farmer. After he gets kicked out, Napoleon, a pig, takes power and corrupts the farm. His power gets to the point where they were better off with the farmer, Mr. Jones. Orwell also illustrates how it is human nature to make mistakes and take control of power.…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The novel Animal Farm by George Orwell inspired it’s production, both produced and directed by John Halas and Joy Batchelor; the audience can distinguish many differences and similarities between the novel and movie. The seven commandments, the speech and the flag, appear in the novel and movie in order to show the similarities. The seven commandments exist to keep the animals from turning into the humans, the animals consider the seven commandments as their boundaries stopping them from mirroring the human’s. The director probably decided to keep Old Major’s speech the same as how Orwell wrote it because Orwell created the speech in order to have an impact on the animals, causing them to come to the decision of rebelling against the human…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal Farm Why does animalism fail? "Meet the new boss, same as the old boss. " All this started when the Manor farm had their oldest pig have a dream. Major had a dream that one day the animals would be free of the control of the humans. When Major died the animals took action, they thought that they could make Major's dream come true.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1984 & Animal Farm Comparative Analysis 1984 and Animal Farm are two novels written by George Orwell. These two books overall want the same thing, obedience and total control. In 1984 we have our main character Winston Smith. He is a man who has no love for Big Brother. He does not agree with the rules and wants to rebel.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Communism is government system in which the major resources in a society—such as factories and farms—are owned by the public or the state, and wealth is divided among people equally or according to each person 's needs. In the book Animal Farm, George Orwell wrote about communism during World War II, using the term Animalism to represent Communism and animals to represent most of the major players of the Soviet Union during that time period. Orwell followed the development of a farm once controlled by humans to a farm eventually controlled by very human acting pigs. A prize Middle White boar, Old Major (who represents the two founder of Communism, Karl Marx, and Vladimir Lenin) has a concept for Animalism, which is that all animals are created…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “All animals are equal.” (Orwell) This statement is certainly applicable to human society, and is the basis for some peoples ideals, but in George Orwell’s Animal Farm it sums up the entire book completely in an ironic way. Communism, while innocent and appealing in thought, was proven in Russia during the 1900’s to be damaging and easily corruptible in practice. Pure communism is the sharing of wealth and abolishment of private property, where everyone works to provide for the state, and receives only enough to sustain life.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Biographical Lens George Orwell is the author of Animal Farm and he wrote it based off of what was going on in his life at that time. George Orwell was only his pen name because the publisher wanted to conceal his true identity. His real name was Eric Arthur Blair. He wrote Animal Farm in 1944 but it was only published in 1945 because nobody would publish it for its insult to Stalin. In the 1930's Orwell fought for the communists in the Spanish Civil War against their fascist leader.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The novel, Animal Farm, was written by George Orwell, this story takes place on a farm where the animals revolt against the humans, developing their own political theory and society. From the start, we learn of a theory composed by Old Major known as Animalism, a theory which has close ties to that of Communism. Following his death, Snowball rules over the farm, but is overthrown by Napoleon. In time both leaders ignore the equality Animalism meant and conditions worsen. The story has a very present similarity of the Russian Revolution and Joseph Stalin’s leading…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays