Comparison Of Beulah And The Mary Tyler Moore Show

Great Essays
During the “Golden Age of Television,” which lasted from 1950-1970, America underwent a number of ideological and social changes, many of which can be found both on the television screen and in real life. Two sitcoms in particular exemplify these changes. Beulah, which was one of the first television shows to feature a black protagonist, and The Mary Tyler Moore Show which highlighted a career driven single women living in the city. Between the twenty year intermission between the makings of these two sitcoms, a number of cultural transformations occurred that reshaped the way that people in the United States thought about womanhood, the significance of race, and suburbanization.
The suburban family sitcom centered on family unity and life
…show more content…
She always placed the needs of her white employers above those of her own and of her family. This sentiment can be seen through Beulah’s lack of nuclear or extended family. Her boyfriend Bill and female friend Oreole serve as her only ties to the African American community. The Henderson family on the other hand features frequent visits from familial cast members such as mother-in-laws, uncles, and cousins. Beulah meanwhile has just a small racial group from which she can draw strength from and no blood family. Therefore, Beulah considered the Henderson’s her family despite the fact that she did not live with nor eat with them. Dialogue in the scripts capture this sentiment as well as Beulah’s loyalty. When the Henderson’s made an effort to cut their domestic budget in one episode, Beulah responded by informing the clan that “I am not going to have my family eat cold cuts on Saturday night.” She always considered herself to be part of the Henderson’s white family, despite the realizations she was just an employee. What is important about Beulah’s lack of a black nuclear family structure is the fact that family has always been an important weapon in the struggle for survival in the black community. If you deny yourself a black family, you are denying the struggle as well. Beulah and other early 1950 sitcoms did not portray the …show more content…
Loans were not given to African Americans who were qualified which made purchasing a home in the suburbs difficult. Following World War II, there was an effort to leave the city and to promote separatism and exclusion from non-whites. The Federal Housing Association was influential in promoting homogeneously white neighborhoods making these practices more public policy than personal opinion (Citation Beuka). “White Flight” from the urban cities to the suburbs was not only a rejection from the crime that revolved around urban living, but also the color that filled those metropolises. The idea of a suburban utopia was not intended to benefit or include everyone. According to Haralovich, an ideal white and middle class home was the primary means of reconstituting and resocializing the American family following World War II. By defining access to property and home ownership within the values of the conventionalized suburban family, women and minorities were guaranteed economic and social inequality. White racial homogeneity was one the major perks that sold suburban life to many Americans. This discrimination was reflected on television as well. If suburbia lacked African Americans off screen, there would be none on screen as

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Reading Pages Report: “Signs of intelligent Life on TV” Summary Susan Douglas’s “Signs of Intelligent Life on TV” discusses the emergence of feminism and the presence of intelligent, powerful, and hardworking women on TV. Douglas discusses how in some shows the writers will present female characters that defy gender stereotypes, however there are still signs of cultural bias against women in these shows. She acknowledges that in these three shows: NYPD BLUE, ER and Chicago Hope the writer acknowledges the significance of adult female audiences by including women as ongoing characters who work for a living, well-educated and strong.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cosby Show Culture

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Imagine a world where diversity was not relevant. Where white and black people were treated the same. However, that was not the case, the 50s displayed white people much more than black people on TV, but as change within the American Culture occurred from the 50s to the 80s, black people were seen more on TV. Two sitcom comedies; The Cosby Show(1980s), and Father Knows Best (FKB, 1950s) can be compared by connecting each of them to the era in which they aired. As the 1950s sitcom Father Knows Best illustrates a very scripted family lifestyle, the 1980s sitcom The Cosby Show portrays a realistic family, which both demonstrate the culture though their time periods.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This play is important to both black and white audiences because this story can each teach us many lessons, including the strength a family poses, that all families reach ups and downs, and how we each are very similar and have…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Places of their own: African-American Suburbanization by Andrew Wiese examines the forces behind the suburbanization of Black Americans in the 20th century and the challenges they faced in doing so. The author emphasized the importance of black suburbanization for the growth of the 20th century the United States. Establishment of suburbs was critical to the study of Black Americans in the United States. The emergence of suburbs was a representative of the new generation of black American, who were socially and economically advanced compared to the past.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America blossomed in the 1950’s. The economy was booming; household gadgets, like refrigerators, were becoming more widely available, and suburbs developed, separating people from the chaos of a city and creating a small-town environment. As the middle class of the suburbs expanded, however, so did the widening division between the white and black opportunities. Blacks were left without the prospects whites had to improve their lives. This inequality created tension within the black community as some searched for any outlet to gain control over their lives.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In contrast, the red areas with a “D” rating outlined the neighborhoods that were ineligible for FHA backing since African Americans lived in those areas (Coates). Coates argues that even though these discriminatory practices do not exist today, the African American community still suffers economically from those consequences. For example, “the income gap between black and white households is roughly the same today as it was in 1970.” As mentioned in lecture, the segregation of the 1930s assisted in forming the ghettos of…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These are just some of the ways in which structural inequality was practices in housing. However, in the 1900s segregation practices had reduced significantly, though the concept of de facto discrimination was visible. This happened when minority race groups found it difficult to get approval for a mortgage loan compares to the white persons who had applied for the same services. In conclusion, race and discrimination among Africa-American was a real national catastrophe and many had to voice it out in different ways, including through demonstrations and violence, just to be heard. America has achieved a great milestone in this venture but, of course much is still needed to eradicate the…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This did not simply mean an investment, but the opportunity to make the American Dream a reality. However, real estate agents have not seen any potential to invest in the Black community. First measure was taken by giving the lowest rating in every Black neighborhood regardless of class. Even a middle-class Black was forced to settle in those neighborhoods without consent and desire. With poor maintenance, old and substandard complexes, no potential for improvements and increasing infringement of hazards, the panorama on every Black community seemed…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although set in the 70s, The Mary Tyler Moore Show is one of the few timeless programs that remains relatable today. As an extremely likeable character, Mary embodies an innocence along with wholesome humor and her experiences are not too out of line with the average career woman today. While modern viewers of the show would perceive Mary’s life as normal, the experiences of a single independent career woman were anything but normal in 70s society; in fact, Mary Tyler Moore was regarded a television revolutionary. The Mary Tyler Moore Show set a precedent for empowering women and incrementally redefining the mold of what an average woman’s life should look like. The show became a hit due to its confrontation of taboo topics and support for…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though there wasn’t slavery at the time, many still worked under the whites. As we read the play, we start to see that there is a big economic issue that Younger family is dealing with. After the death of Mr. Younger, Mrs. Younger became the head of the house. About fifty five percent of all African Americans in 1959 were affected by poverty (Dawson 28).Walter, Ruth, and Mama put…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this time period veterans and civilians began searching for homes outside the cities and into the newly built suburbs. During the late 1940’s and through the early1960’s, America went through a massive migration to the suburbs. While historians agree that post war suburbia was the birth of our modern middle class socio status and the redefining of the American dreams many argue whether or not the post war suburbs of the 1950’s and 1960’s good or bad for America. In this paper I will discuss the rise of the American dream as homeownership during post war America; by focusing on the rise of the middle class and core middle class social values portrayed in the media and specifically looking at Levittown communities (New York and Pennsylvania) as well exploring how the idea of this middle class utopia became problematic by examining how developers and government used tools of exclusion to exclude minorities from experiencing the “American Dream” from the prospective of the white majority view points and minority view…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Great Society Essay

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Before the Great Society many minorities felt betrayed by the government because they were not receiving equal treatment. many poor people were left to start on the street and many African Americans felt left out of politics. programs such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964 in the Omnibus Housing Bill of 1965 caused these problems to diminish, and gave American society more hopeful outlook for the future. Lyndon B. Johnson referred to the Omnibus Housing Bill of 1965 as the “‘single most important breakthrough’ in housing in decades”. This bill “provided hefty rent subsidies for low-income people who moved into new housing projects, created grants to help low income homeowners rehabilitate their properties, aided small businesses displaced by urban renewal and grants to rehabilitate blighted urban property”.…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Suburban Migration

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Research has shown that for more than 50 years now, a drastic change in the population transitioning from cities to the suburbs has been occurring. After 1950, this movement originally gained momentum and become the leading demographic style for nearly all-crucial U.S. metropolitan areas. This migration has pushed many more Americans to live in the suburbs now than any other location in the states. Today, a good amount of middle-class African Americans have moved out to the suburbs but the most common people who branch out there consist of upper-middle-class, middle-class, and working-class white people. Class and race separation steady growing more due to this white flight procedure.…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gender roles have been portrayed differently throughout the history of the television sitcom. The media often portrays the conflicts between men and women, while adding a comedic twist to it. In the 1990’s women’s role in sitcoms had finally changed their character into more dominant and important figures compare to the sitcoms in earlier decades. Women have stepped out of traditional roles of the housewife, the mother and created the compelling female characters. While women began to play an independent role, men’s character in the 1990s also showed a significant change in an opposite way of being silly and trouble maker instead of being masculinity.…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The portrayal of black women has evolved greatly over time. From Oliva Pope in Scandal to Annalise in How to Get Away with Murder, black women are on-screen professionals now more than ever. Although black women are seen dealing with issues in their stories’ plot, the great majority of these plots take a back seat to the subplot of romance. The success of black women in media is relentlessly measured by their love life. Regardless of the success of their financial, employment, or platonic relationships, black women are still conceived in the media to act as if love will complete them.…

    • 2355 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays