Comparing Tonya Harding And Nancy Kerrigan

Improved Essays
Figure skating has always been an aesthetically pleasing sport, but people always fail to realize what kind of physical toll it takes on the athlete. These “princesses of ice” go through not only physical distress, but also emotional distress with the ongoing obsession to be perfect and the “best”. This unhealthy obsession can make a person go mad, which opens up discussion on arguably one of the most memorable moments in the entire sport: the Tonya Harding and Nancy Kerrigan 1994 incident. Both skaters were in their prime, but like in every sport they need to win made some athletes, or in this situation athlete’s acquaintance, do some crazy things. Nancy was seen as the regal, classy, pure, and pristine skater and Tonya was seen as the “ugly …show more content…
The loop creates a line going up and when landing. Lines are perfection in skating. The judges are impressed with clean and crisp routines. Using Nancy Kerrigan as an example, every time she completed a loop jump, she would extend her non-landing leg and create three lines: one directing attention to the sky, one directing attention to the ice, and one directing attention to the viewer. To the normal eye, this linear technique can be viewed as a tool to grab the attention of the crowd and the judges, but one must review the technique in relation to the sport as a whole. Men and women both compete in ice skating, but the female side is the only side that focuses on grabbing attention through the body. It is true that men that do leg extensions, but it is not their entire routine. It is also not the only thing they are known for. Men in figure skating are athletes, in contrast to the idea that female figure skaters are just pretty objects that do cool tricks for the entertainment of Americans and people all over the world. This argument can be supported by the ESPN 30 for 30 The Price of Gold. In the documentary, focus was put on the incident between Nancy Kerrigan and Tonya Harding in the 1994 U.S Olympic trials. When filmmakers and commentators talked about Nancy they focused on her beauty and grace on the ice. Her leg extension was mentioned, but none of the other jumps she competed with. In fact, little mention of her athleticism was made and a lot of the credit she did receive was because she fits the mold of what a skate was supposed to look like. Oppose to the credit, Tonya got. Yes, Tonya is the black sheep of the skating world, but in the skating world Tonya was seen as strong, and when refined she had amazing technique. In fact, her technique was discussed by and compared to people outside of female ice

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In journalist Skip Hollandsworth’s article “Toddlers in Tiaras,” he discusses the dramatizing effects of how participating in beauty pageants is sexualizing young girls. His purpose is to inform readers about these pageants and what they demand, stating, “All around the conference room…little girls do the pageant version of suiting up” (490). Hollandsworth creates a vivid tone to express the consequences and controversy these pageants demonstrate. He shapes the article in a sturdy, persuasive way by using encounters from former and current beauty pageant contestants.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case Study: Ringette

    • 178 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Summary Host teams of developing athletes to participate in activities and attend ringette games. Work as a positive role model for young women in pursuit athletics. Offer guidance to questions about ringette and university life (activity ongoing). Impact As a member of the ringette community, I have learned the significance of creating a supportive and encouraging environment for the younger ringette generation. Ringette, as a small, female-dominated sport is not recognized to the same extent as other sports.…

    • 178 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Bone Cage Analysis

    • 1311 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In order to become talented in a specific sport it takes practice, patience, and athleticism but over time it is very possible for an ordinary person to achieve this status. However, in order to become the best in the world, that presents a completely different story. Through the eyes of both Tom “Digger” Stapleton and Sadie Jorgensen in Angie Abdou’s novel The Bone Cage, the reader quickly learns the difference between becoming an athlete and becoming an Olympian. Both of these Olympic hopefuls put their lives on hold in order to hopefully achieve this standard of greatness. Neither person has long term goals for the future after the Olympics, they subsist week to week and both have sacrificed the majority of their lives for the opportunity…

    • 1311 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I have decided to write a response paper to Jamie Schultz’s: “Reading the Catsuit: Serena Williams and the Production of Blackness at the 2002 U.S. Open.” I really enjoyed reading her journal and all the opinions regarding Serena William’s infamous catsuit. Although there are some negative opinions regarding Williams’ choice of outfit and the way she presents herself, but she has challenged the normative white identity in women’s tennis. She has pushed the boundaries not only in tennis, but also throughout women’s sports with her masculine physique and her extraordinary abilities on the tennis court.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the past 100 years, gender roles of men and women have started to change greatly in our society, and especially in the world of sports. Recently, female athletes have made great strides in gaining equal representation, and media coverage, in comparison to the past, where there was little coverage of female athletics. In addition, women have begun to participate in many sports that have previously been male dominated. Some of these sports such as MMA, and hockey have been perceived as “manly” sports, and many feel that women should not participate in them due to their physically demanding nature. However, even though many female athletes have been discouraged from participating in male dominated sports, women have continued to break…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    People that live in the spotlight may have downfalls due to a personal flaw. I chose to look at the downfall of Tonya Harding, a world famous ice skater who competed in the 1994 Winter Olympic Trials. Oedipus fell into trouble because of his arrogance, Tonya fell into trouble because of her jealousy. Tonya knew she would have serious competition at the upcoming 1994 Olympic Games. Through a network of connections, Harding, planned to attack a fellow skater, Nancy Kerrigan, just a few days before the Olympic Trials.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alyssa Roenigk, a senior writer for ESPN, presented an argumentative article, “Sorry, Cheerleading is not a Sport,” which opened a pivotal argument on cheerleading being classified as a sport. Roenigk states that all cheerleaders are athletes, but cheerleading should not be considered a sport. Why is this? Roenigk claims that sports teams are made to compete, to go against another team to win, not to entertain the crowd. Although Roenigk tries to persuade her audience that cheerleading does not fall under sporting guidelines, she contradicts her argument in immeasurable ways as she shifts cheerleading “athletes” away from sport.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “How I Lost the Junior Miss Pageant,” Cindy Bosely effectively uses different rhetorical techniques to expose the true darkness behind the workings of beauty pageants, even junior ones, and her simple country life. The story details how from a young age, Bosely watched the Miss America Pageant, participating as an independent judge, whiler her mother sat beside her and gave little commentary on what she thought of all the contestants. It was clear that her mother hoped she might be one day be the kind or pretty where boys liked her and she could win beauty pageants, even as Cindy grows older and her realizes that her daughter is not the particular kind of beautiful she had hoped. It’s when she turns seventeen that she is finally…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Twyla Tharp was born in 1941 and grew up in Southern California. Growing up, her extracurricular activities consisted of baton, ballet, toe, flamenco, drums, elocution, painting, viola, violin, acrobatics, shorthand, German, and French. Tharp graduated from Banard College with a degree in art history. After graduating, Tharp performed her first professional debut with Paul Taylor Company in 1963, having the role of crawling across that stage. Two years later, she founded her first company in which she had sustainment of various forms.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women can be strong and beautiful without having to be sexualized by the media. Should women show a little skin to promote a brand or themselves and their sport? Although this paper is about women and the things they go through to remain thin, I have to say that men have been sexualized as well. Sports players such as Derek Jeter, David Beckam, and Rafael Nadal have all been part of the pretty boys in sports image. With respect to Wimbleton female tennis players have been playing in small colorful outfits that make them stand out in the courts.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is cheer leading a sport Everyone knows those girls who sit on the sidelines of other sports and yell “GO TEAM.” These girls have to be very athletic and trained to do all of their stunts. The professional name of these girls is cheerleaders, they are the ones who get all of the crowd peppy on Friday night games and then go and compete all day Saturday and yet what they do is not considered a sport. The topic of Cheerleading has generated a lot of argument for the two viewpoints of cheerleading requires much training and skills to execute the very precises routines and the opposing viewpoint of cheerleading is only meant to support other athletes.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One moment you're using all strength and muscle of energy you have, and using your body to what you think are making them stronger. On the inside though, you’re only breaking them. “Don't get inside your head, this is easy.” I told myself before I stepped onto the mat. Competitive cheerleading is one of the most active sports and uses every part of your body and strength to flip yourself around, or throw somebody in the air.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to the article, “I won. I’m sorry”, Author Mariah Burton Nelson discuss that females are being pressured to act a certain way in society. As states in the first few paragraphs, she explains how athletes are going by the ‘final rule’. Mariah states, “Beauty and vulnerability seem to be as important to today’s female athlete as brawn and gold medals.” Although a female athlete is playing sports that make them look a bit masculine, at the end, all they regard to be gaining the males approval of their femininity.…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Recognizing and celebrating the successes of the black community perfectly describes the idea of ‘Black Excellence’. For the black community, the joy in celebrating this excellence has been counteracted by the backlash of apparent racism. Claudia Rankine’s “The Meaning of Serena Williams”, while specific to Serena’s career, discusses issues reflecting the struggle experienced by the black community, as it attempts to achieve the recognition of its excellence in the face of racist perpetrations. Imagine that you are undeniably the world’s greatest tennis player, but the twentieth most marketable athlete according to a list provided by the London School of Marketing.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No sooner had I determined that I desired to attempt field hockey than my mother had begun inquiring to our neighbors about the best leagues to partake in. She quickly acquired a sufficient amount of information to register me for a beginner’s summer camp at the 422 SportsPlex. At this point, I was incapable of doing anything but waiting for the camp to begin. Even so, I did not handle this wait patiently; in fact, I was quite the contrary. Excitement at the thought of this new adventure had overcome me.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays