Comparing The Works Of Emily Dickinson And Charlotte Perkins Gilman Perkins

Improved Essays
Emily Dickinson and Charlotte Gilman Perkins characters in their poems are both being challenged to keep forces out and away from others so they can be alone with their thoughts and secrets. However, they both differ in their reasoning, motives and strategies. The study of these to works will reveal the differences in their methods to achieve their goals.
At first glance, Dickinson and Perkins are both capable of having and keeping secrets in common. They both revere their independence and have a love for writing for pleasure as well as therapeutic reasons. Dickinson starts off by declaring she’s nobody as if she’s neither here nor there, but either way she is not pleased about what is happening in society or with the people who are trying
…show more content…
Dickinson is mocking public figures who likes the notoriety and wants to benefit from this and the people who encourage them to do so. Her motive is she wants the readers to be in favor of her way of thinking because she has made the choice not to be like the others and exploit her works. Her strategy was to write and publish her works she chose anonymously so she would not be well known and can continue to be a free thinker and keeping the nobodies from advertising and talking about her. Perkins husband placed her in the room with yellow wallpaper due to her mental health after having a baby. He pacified her with things but was mostly absent. At first she hates the room and the wallpaper patterns and bars on the windows representing confinement, but as time passes she becomes obsessed with the wallpaper patterns and begins to try to find this woman in the midst of the disturbing patterns. This activity gave her purpose a reason to get up each day. Perkins felt lost and did not feel like herself. Her motive for following the patterns on the wall and peeling the wallpaper was to get back a piece of herself each day without her husband knowing what she was doing. Her strategy was to continue ripping away as much of the wallpaper as possible until it was all gone. This was her way of symbolizing peeling away the layers of unhappy her life allowing her to seek her true identity, freedom and destroying

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In her essay, Cixous states that “a world searching the elaboration of a knowledge, on the basis of a systematic experimentation with the bodily functions, a passionate and precise interrogation of her erogeneity” (1644). One may argue that Dickinson is using objects that are around her proximity because they are familiar with her. In one of her stanzas, Dickson writes “We cannot put ourself away A Completed Man or Woman- when the errands are…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People are to focusing on what others around them will say that don’t focus on themselves. Therefore, people could relate to the poem that Dickinson wrote in a very emotional time of her life that shape a new…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The narrator in the poem is depicted as exposed and anticipative. Dickinson declares, “I willed my keepsakes, signed away What portion of me I Could make assignable” (10-11). She is anticipating death, by cutting her attachment to the physical world. She is waiting for the revelation of death and what it will bring as she lies on her deathbed. Some part of her life will stay behind when she leaves the world, and transitions into death.…

    • 157 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As told by Lilia Melani, “Dickinson adopts the persona of a child who is open, naïve, and innocent”. She pokes fun at the thought of her being a nobody, but as the poem continues into the second stanza she becomes more…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Billy Collins’s poem “ Taking off Emily Dickinson’s Clothes” his diction was very intriguing to the readers. His word choice made the readers visualize the scenario and understand everything that was going on. When I first read the title I was a little confused on why we had to read such a poem, but then I soon understood. Billy Collins’s style of writing is very unique and different. It’s not like Robert Frosts’ or Edgar Allen Poe’s writing .…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Emily Dickinson, an introverted American poet with epilepsy, wrote her way into the world of literature in a distinctive and intriguing manner. Her words, while often unrhymed, have left a perpetual ringing in the minds of her readers. Her poems will forever provide them with wonder, however, one may find themselves speculating about what influenced Miss Dickinson to write her poetry the way that she did. Richard Wilbur, an American poet, described Emily Dickinson with the following quote; “I think that for her there are three major privations: she was deprived of an orthodox and steady religious faith; she was deprived of love; she was deprived of literary recognition.” (p.859) Wilbur’s interpretation of Miss Dickinson’s…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dickinson’s life influenced her poetry to a great extent. The things she experienced and the situations that drove her into seclusion so that she can write shaped her poetry. Her style has influenced other great poets of her time and has also affected American literature. Her life influenced her style and dictation and also was used to express her feelings. The themes of Death, Love, and Friendship can be also seen in her poems because they were impacted by the people in her life.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    -Born in Amherst, Massachusetts -Poet -Transcendentalist Emily Dickinson was a poet born in 1830 who was considered one of America’s greatest poets and a Transcendentalist because she often discussed the acceptance of death. “Emily Dickinson was a poet who was born in 1830. She wrote about 1800 poems, most of them being published after her death. Her quiet life was infused with a creative energy that produced almost 1800 poems and a profusion of vibrant letters.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By accounts written by Dickinson herself, she enjoyed her education having…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These poems argue with the ideals placed upon Dickinson by the traditional catholicism of the community. They attack the need for churches, binding marriages for all eternity, heaven or immortality, and the belief passion as a sin. Emily Dickinson could not vocally express her ideas on the religion society forced her into, so she created her poetry as a way to express her views without the dismissal from society that would follow the expressions of such ideas. Similarly, today many find they fail to agree with all the teachings of the church and subsequently find themselves shunned for their personal beliefs as they don’t follow those of their community. Through the use of slant rhymes, imagery, and metaphors, Dickinson can express her points ,against the religious society that affects the masses even now, in a safe…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She relates important characters and gives basic descriptions of important figures in the Bible, such as Eden, Satan, and David, which makes it more personal and less religious (97). For example, she calls “Judas the Great Defaulter” and “David a Troubadour” (97). The comparisons showcase Dickinson’s religious freedom because her personal interpretation of the Bible is unlike someone that believes it is held to a higher standard. It is ironic because Dickinson grew up around the Bible being the center of everything in school and in her household as a child, but her interpretation lacks the symbolic importance that everyone else had, such as her family and…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In saying this, Dickinson cultivates the idea that once a small society is chosen there is no more room for others, the decision of a selective society is set in stone. Some strive to be popular and liked by everyone, but this causes a sense of emptiness and depression. Rather than having a large group of people who know little more than a person’s name, a tight-knit society containing people that are willing to support the others in the society is…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Emily Dickinson The originative Emily Dickinson was a gifted poet as she composed passionate poems that baffled readers with her literary style. Using her naïve perception, Dickinson’s poetry was written on a daily basis. Through her use of quick-witted metaphors and improvised grammar, Emily Dickinson remains a classic poet whose poetry influenced American Literature today. Emily Dickinson was seen as psychologically unbalanced and reclusive in her life, as shown through her varying emotional poems which had an impact on American Romanticism, through her style of writing, which did not follow the rules of grammar, and through her connotative word meanings which intrigued the twentieth century critiques.…

    • 1598 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Emily Dickinson’s poetry reflects a sense of death and inclusiveness that stemmed from her own life. Dickinson lived a life of solitude and only accepted a few chosen people to visit her or to correspond with. Unlike those of her time period, she did not find pleasure in entertaining visitors nor did she conform to religious or societal expectations of the society she was living in. Her works of poetry correspond with her life of seclusion and only having a small social group. It has been rumored that her reclusiveness and poetry lament of an unreciprocated love that may have been related to her relationships with Reverend Charles Wadsworth or Otis P. Lord.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By closely reading Dickinson’s poems we see that she struggles…

    • 2198 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays